SECURITYOFTRUTH。
Ithenthought,andamstillofthesameopinion,thaterror,andnottruthofanykind,isdangerous;thatillconclusionscanonlyflowfromfalsepropositions;andthat,toknowwhetheranypropositionbetrueorfalse,itisapreposterousmethodtoexamineitbyitsapparentconsequences。
IMITATIONANINSTINCTIVELAW。
Forassympathymakesustakeaconcerninwhatevermenfeel,sothisaffectionpromptsustocopywhatevertheydo;andconsequentlywehaveapleasureinimitating,andinwhateverbelongstoimitationmerelyasitissuch,withoutanyinterventionofthereasoningfaculty,butsolelyfromournaturalconstitution,whichProvidencehasframedinsuchamannerastofindeitherpleasureordelight,accordingtothenatureoftheobject,inwhateverregardsthepurposesofourbeing。Itisbyimitationfarmorethanbyprecept,thatwelearneverything;andwhatwelearnthus,weacquirenotonlymoreeffectually,butmorepleasantly。Thisformsourmanners,ouropinions,ourlives。Itisoneofthestrongestlinksofsociety;itisaspeciesofmutualcompliance,whichallmenyieldtoeachother,withoutconstrainttothemselves,andwhichisextremelyflatteringtoall。
STANDARDOFREASONANDTASTE。
Itisprobablethatthestandardbothofreasonandtasteisthesameinallhumancreatures。Foriftherewerenotsomeprinciplesofjudgmentaswellasofsentimentcommontoallmankind,noholdcouldpossiblybetakeneitherontheirreasonortheirpassions,sufficienttomaintaintheordinarycorrespondenceoflife。
USEOFTHEORY。
Atheoryfoundedonexperiment,andnotassumed,isalwaysgoodforsomuchasitexplains。Ourinabilitytopushitindefinitelyisnoargumentatallagainstit。ThisinabilitymaybeowingtoourignoranceofsomenecessaryMEDIUMS;toawantofproperapplication;tomanyothercausesbesidesadefectintheprinciplesweemploy。
POLITICALOUTCASTS。
Inthemeantime,thatpower,whichallthesechangesaimedatsecuring,remainsstillastotteringandasuncertainasever。Theyaredeliveredupintothehandsofthosewhofeelneitherrespectfortheirpersons,norgratitudefortheirfavours;whoareputabouttheminappearancetoserve,inrealitytogovernthem;and,whenthesignalisgiven,toabandonanddestroythem,inordertosetupsomenewdupeofambition,whoinhisturnistobeabandonedanddestroyed。Thus,livinginastateofcontinualuneasinessandferment,softenedonlybythemiserableconsolationofgivingnowandthenprefermentstothoseforwhomtheyhavenovalue;theyareunhappyintheirsituation,yetfinditimpossibletoresign。Until,atlength,souredintemper,anddisappointedbytheveryattainmentoftheirends,insomeangry,insomehaughty,orsomenegligentmoment,theyincurthedispleasureofthoseuponwhomtheyhaverenderedtheirverybeingdependent。Thenperierunttemporalongiservitii;theyarecastoffwithscorn;theyareturnedout,emptiedofallnaturalcharacter,ofallintrinsicworth,ofallessentialdignity,anddeprivedofeveryconsolationoffriendship。
Havingrenderedallretreattooldprinciplesridiculous,andtooldregardsimpracticable,notbeingabletocounterfeitpleasure,ortodischargediscontent,nothingbeingsincereorright,orbalancedintheirminds,itismorethanachance,that,inthedeliriumofthelaststageoftheirdistemperedpower,theymakeaninsanepoliticaltestament,bywhichtheythrowalltheirremainingweightandconsequenceintothescaleoftheirdeclaredenemies,andtheavowedauthorsoftheirdestruction。
INJUSTICETOOUROWNAGE。
Iftheseevildispositionsshouldspreadmuchfarthertheymustendinourdestruction;fornothingcansaveapeopledestituteofpublicandprivatefaith。However,theauthor,forthepresentstateofthings,hasextendedthechargebymuchtoowidely;asmenarebuttooapttotakethemeasureofallmankindfromtheirownparticularacquaintance。
Barrenasthisagemaybeinthegrowthofhonourandvirtue,thecountrydoesnotwant,atthismoment,asstrong,andthosenotafew,examplesaswereeverknown,ofanunshakenadherencetoprinciple,andattachmenttoconnexion,againsteveryallurementofinterest。Thoseexamplesarenotfurnishedbythegreatalone;norbythose,whoseactivityinpublicaffairsmayrenderitsuspectedthattheymakesuchacharacteroneoftheroundsintheirladderofambition;butbymenmorequiet,andmoreintheshade,onwhomanunmixedsenseofhonouralonecouldoperate。
FALSECOALITIONS。
Nosystemofthatkindcanbeformed,whichwillnotleaveroomfullysufficientforhealingcoalitions:butnocoalitionwhich,underthespeciousnameofindependency,carriesinitsbosomtheunreconciledprinciplesoftheoriginaldiscordofparties,everwas,orwillbe,anhealingcoalition。Norwillthemindofoursovereigneverknowrepose,hiskingdomsettlement,orhisbusinessorder,inefficiencyorgracewithhispeople,untilthingsareestablisheduponthebasisofsomesetofmen,whoaretrustedbythepublic,andwhocantrustoneanother。
POLITICALEMPIRICISM。
Menofsense,whennewprojectscomebeforethem,alwaysthinkadiscourseprovingthemererightormerepowerofactinginthemannerproposed,tobenomorethanaveryunpleasantwayofmispendingtime。
Theymustseetheobjecttobeofpropermagnitudetoengagethem;theymustseethemeansofcompassingittobenexttocertain:themischiefsnottocounterbalancetheprofit;theywillexaminehowaproposedimpositionorregulationagreeswiththeopinionofthosewhoarelikelytobeaffectedbyit;theywillnotdespisetheconsiderationevenoftheirhabitudesandprejudices。Theywishtoknowhowitaccordsordisagreeswiththetruespiritofpriorestablishments,whetherofgovernmentoroffinance;becausetheywellknow,thatinthecomplicatedeconomyofgreatkingdoms,andimmenserevenues,whichinalengthoftime,andbyavarietyofaccidents,havecoalescedintoasortofbody,anattempttowardsacompulsoryequalityinallcircumstances,andanexactpracticaldefinitionofthesupremerightsineverycase,isthemostdangerousandchimericalofallenterprises。
Theoldbuildingstandswellenough,thoughpartGothic,partGrecian,andpartChinese,untilanattemptismadetosquareitintouniformity。
Thenitmaycomedownuponourheadsaltogether,inmuchuniformityofruin;andgreatwillbethefallthereof。
AVISIONARY。
Enoughofthisvisionaryunion;inwhichmuchextravaganceappearswithoutanyfancy,andthejudgmentisshockedwithoutanythingtorefreshtheimagination。Itlooksasiftheauthorhaddroppeddownfromthemoon,withoutanyknowledgeofthegeneralnatureofthisglobe,ofthegeneralnatureofitsinhabitants,withouttheleastacquaintancewiththeaffairsofthiscountry。
PARTYDIVISIONS。
Partydivisions,whetheronthewholeoperatingforgoodorevil,arethingsinseparablefromfreegovernment。Thisisatruthwhich,I
believe,admitslittledispute,havingbeenestablishedbytheuniformexperienceofallages。Thepartagoodcitizenoughttotakeinthesedivisionshasbeenamatterofmuchdeepercontroversy。ButGodforbidthatanycontroversyrelatingtoouressentialmoralsshouldadmitofnodecision。Itappearstome,thatthisquestion,likemostoftheotherswhichregardourdutiesinlife,istobedeterminedbyourstationinit。Privatemenmaybewhollyneutral,andentirelyinnocent;buttheywhoarelegallyinvestedwithpublictrust,orstandonthehighgroundofrankanddignity,whichistrustimplied,canhardlyinanycaseremainindifferent,withoutthecertaintyofsinkingintoinsignificance;andtherebyineffectdesertingthatpostinwhich,withthefullestauthority,andforthewisestpurposes,thelawsandinstitutionsoftheircountryhavefixedthem。However,ifitbetheofficeofthosewhoarethuscircumstanced,totakeadecidedpart,itisnolesstheirdutythatitshouldbeasoberone。
DECORUMINPARTY。
Itoughttobecircumscribedbythesamelawsofdecorum,andbalancedbythesametemper,whichboundandregulateallthevirtues。Inaword,weoughttoactinpartywithallthemoderationwhichdoesnotabsolutelyenervatethatvigour,andquenchthatfervencyofspirit,withoutwhichthebestwishesforthepublicgoodmustevaporateinemptyspeculation。
NOTSOBADASWESEEM。
Ourcircumstancesareindeedcritical;butthentheyarethecriticalcircumstancesofastrongandmightynation。Ifcorruptionandmeannessaregreatlyspread,theyarenotspreaduniversally。Manypublicmenarehithertoexamplesofpublicspiritandintegrity。Wholeparties,asfaraslargebodiescanbeuniform,havepreservedcharacter。Howevertheymaybedeceivedinsomeparticulars,Iknowofnosetofmenamongstuswhichdoesnotcontainpersonsonwhomthenation,inadifficultexigence,maywellvalueitself。Privatelife,whichisthenurseryofthecommonwealth,isyetingeneralpure,andonthewholedisposedtovirtue;andthepeopleatlargewantneithergenerositynorspirit。Nosmallpartofthatveryluxury,whichissomuchthesubjectoftheauthor’sdeclamation,butwhich,inmostpartsoflife,bybeingwellbalancedanddiffused,isonlydecencyandconvenience,hasperhapsasmanyormoregoodthanevilconsequencesattendingit。Itcertainlyexcitesindustry,nourishesemulation,andinspiressomesenseofpersonalvalueintoallranksofpeople。Whatwewantistoestablishmorefullyanopinionofuniformity,andconsistencyofcharacter,intheleadingmenofthestate;suchaswillrestoresomeconfidencetoprofessionandappearance,suchaswillfixsubordinationuponesteem。
Withoutthisallschemesarebegunatthewrongend。
POLITICSWITHOUTPRINCIPLE。
Peoplenotverywellgroundedintheprinciplesofpublicmoralityfindasetofmaximsinofficereadymadeforthem,whichtheyassumeasnaturallyandinevitably,asanyoftheinsigniaorinstrumentsofthesituation。Acertaintoneofthesolidandpracticalisimmediatelyacquired。Everyformerprofessionofpublicspiritistobeconsideredasadebauchofyouth,or,atbest,asavisionaryschemeofunattainableperfection。Theveryideaofconsistencyisexploded。Theconvenienceofthebusinessofthedayistofurnishtheprinciplefordoingit。Thenthewholeministerialcantisquicklygotbyheart。Theprevalenceoffactionistobelamented。Alloppositionistoberegardedastheeffectofenvyanddisappointedambition。Alladministrationsaredeclaredtobealike。Thesamenecessityjustifiesalltheirmeasures。Itisnolongeramatterofdiscussion,whoorwhatadministrationis;butthatadministrationistobesupported,isageneralmaxim。Flatteringthemselvesthattheirpowerisbecomenecessarytothesupportofallorderandgovernment,everythingwhichtendstothesupportofthatpowerissanctified,andbecomesapartofthepublicinterest。
MORALDEBASEMENTPROGRESSIVE。
Ibelievetheinstancesareexceedinglyrareofmenimmediatelypassingoveraclear,markedlineofvirtueintodeclaredviceandcorruption。
Thereareasortofmiddletintsandshadesbetweenthetwoextremes;
thereissomethinguncertainontheconfinesofthetwoempireswhichtheyfirstpassthrough,andwhichrendersthechangeeasyandimperceptible。Thereareevenasortofsplendidimpositionssowellcontrived,that,attheverytimethepathofrectitudeisquittedforever,menseemtobeadvancingintosomehigherandnoblerroadofpublicconduct。Notthatsuchimpositionsarestrongenoughinthemselves;butapowerfulinterest,oftenconcealedfromthosewhomitaffects,worksatthebottom,andsecurestheoperation。Menarethusdebauchedawayfromthoselegitimateconnexions,whichtheyhadformedonajudgment,earlyperhapsbutsufficientlymature,andwhollyunbiassed。
DESPOTISM。
Itisthenatureofdespotismtoabhorpowerheldbyanymeansbutitsownmomentarypleasure;andtoannihilateallintermediatesituationsbetweenboundlessstrengthonitsownpart,andtotaldebilityonthepartofthepeople。
JUDGMENTANDPOLICY。
Nothingcanrenderthisapointofindifferencetothenation,butwhatmusteitherrenderustotallydesperate,orsoothusintothesecurityofidiots。Wemustsoftenintoacredulitybelowthemilkinessofinfancy,tothinkallmenvirtuous。Wemustbetaintedwithamalignitytrulydiabolical,tobelievealltheworldtobeequallywickedandcorrupt。Menareinpublicasinprivate,somegood,someevil。Theelevationoftheone,andthedepressionoftheother,arethefirstobjectsofalltruepolicy。Butthatformofgovernment,which,neitherinitsdirectinstitutions,norintheirimmediatetendency,hascontrivedtothrowitsaffairsintothemosttrustworthyhands,buthasleftitswholeexecutorysystemtobedisposedofagreeablytotheuncontrolledpleasuresofanyoneman,howeverexcellentorvirtuous,isaplanofpolitydefectivenotonlyinthatmember,butconsequentiallyerroneousineverypartofit。
POPULARDISCONTENT。
Tocomplainoftheagewelivein,tomurmuratthepresentpossessorsofpower,tolamentthepast,toconceiveextravaganthopesofthefuture,arethecommondispositionsofthegreatestpartofmankind;
indeed,thenecessaryeffectsoftheignoranceandlevityofthevulgar。
Suchcomplaintsandhumourshaveexistedinalltimes;yetasalltimeshaveNOTbeenalike,truepoliticalsagacitymanifestsitselfindistinguishingthatcomplaintwhichonlycharacterisesthegeneralinfirmityofhumannature,fromthosewhicharesymptomsoftheparticulardistemperatureofourownairandseason。
THEPEOPLEANDTHEIRRULERS。
Iamnotoneofthosewhothinkthatthepeopleareneverinthewrong。
Theyhavebeenso,frequentlyandoutrageously,bothinothercountriesandinthis。ButIdosay,thatinalldisputesbetweenthemandtheirrulers,thepresumptionisatleastuponaparinfavourofthepeople。
Experiencemayperhapsjustifymeingoingfarther。Whenpopulardiscontentshavebeenveryprevalent,itmaywellbeaffirmedandsupported,thattherehasbeengenerallysomethingfoundamissintheconstitution,orintheconductofgovernment。Thepeoplehavenointerestindisorder。Whentheydowrong,itistheirerror,andnottheircrime。
GOVERNMENTFAVOURITISM。
Itisthisunnaturalinfusionofagovernmentwhichinagreatpartofitsconstitutionispopular,thathasraisedthepresentfermentinthenation。Thepeople,withoutenteringdeeplyintoitsprinciples,couldplainlyperceiveitseffects,inmuchviolence,inagreatspiritofinnovation,andageneraldisorderinallthefunctionsofgovernment。I
keepmyeyesolelyonthissystem;ifIspeakofthosemeasureswhichhavearisenfromit,itwillbesofaronlyastheyillustratethegeneralscheme。Thisisthefountainofallthosebitterwaters,ofwhich,throughanhundreddifferentconduits,wehavedrunkuntilwearereadytoburst。ThediscretionarypoweroftheCrownintheformationofministry,abusedbybadorweakmen,hasgivenrisetoasystemwhich,withoutdirectlyviolatingtheletterofanylaw,operatesagainstthespiritofthewholeconstitution。
Aplanoffavouritismforourexecutorygovernmentisessentiallyatvariancewiththeplanofourlegislature。Onegreatendundoubtedlyofamixedgovernmentlikeours,composedofmonarchy,andofcontrols,onthepartofthehigherpeopleandthelower,isthattheprinceshallnotbeabletoviolatethelaws。Thisisusefulindeedandfundamental。
Butthis,evenatfirstview,innomorethananegativeadvantage;anarmourmerelydefensive。Itisthereforenextinorder,andequalinimportance,THATTHEDISCRETIONARYPOWERSWHICHARENECESSARILYVESTED
INTHEMONARCH,WHETHERFORTHEEXECUTIONOFTHELAWS,ORFORTHE
NOMINATIONTOMAGISTRACYANDOFFICE,ORFORCONDUCTINGTHEAFFAIRSOF
PEACEANDWAR,ORFORORDERINGTHEREVENUE,SHOULDALLBEEXERCISEDUPON
PUBLICPRINCIPLESANDNATIONALGROUNDS,ANDNOTONTHELIKINGSOR
PREJUDICES,THEINTRIGUESORPOLICIES,OFACOURT。
ADMINISTRATIONANDLEGISLATION。
Inarbitrarygovernments,theconstitutionoftheministryfollowstheconstitutionofthelegislature。Boththelawandthemagistratearethecreaturesofwill。Itmustbeso。Nothing,indeed,willappearmorecertain,onanytolerableconsiderationofthismatter,thanthatEVERY
SORTOFGOVERNMENTOUGHTTOHAVEITSADMINISTRATIONCORRESPONDENTTOITS
LEGISLATURE。Ifitshouldbeotherwise,thingsmustfallintoahideousdisorder。Thepeopleofafreecommonwealth,whohavetakensuchcarethattheirlawsshouldbetheresultofgeneralconsent,cannotbesosenselessastosuffertheirexecutorysystemtobecomposedofpersonsonwhomtheyhavenodependence,andwhomnoproofsofthepublicloveandconfidencehaverecommendedtothosepowers,upontheuseofwhichtheverybeingofthestatedepends。
INFLUENCEOFTHECROWN。
ThepoweroftheCrown,almostdeadandrottenasPrerogative,hasgrownupanew,withmuchmorestrength,andfarlessodium,underthenameofInfluence。Aninfluence,whichoperatedwithoutnoiseandwithoutviolence;aninfluencewhichconvertedtheveryantagonistintotheinstrumentofpower;whichcontainedinitselfaperpetualprincipleofgrowthandrenovation;andwhichthedistressesandtheprosperityofthecountryequallytendtoaugment,wasanadmirablesubstituteforaprerogative,that,beingonlytheoffspringofantiquatedprejudices,hadmouldedintoitsoriginalstaminairresistibleprinciplesofdecayanddissolution。Theignoranceofthepeopleisabottombutforatemporarysystem;theinterestofactivemeninthestateisafoundationperpetualandinfallible。
VOICEOFTHEPEOPLE。
Governmentisdeeplyinterestedineverythingwhich,eventhroughthemediumofsometemporaryuneasiness,maytendfinallytocomposethemindsofthesubjects,andtoconciliatetheiraffections。Ihavenothingtodoherewiththeabstractvalueofthevoiceofthepeople。
Butaslongasreputation,themostpreciouspossessionofeveryindividual,andaslongasopinion,thegreatsupportofthestate,dependentirelyuponthatvoice,itcanneverbeconsideredasathingoflittleconsequenceeithertoindividualsortogovernments。Nationsarenotprimarilyruledbylaws;lessbyviolence。Whateveroriginalenergymaybesupposedeitherinforceorregulation,theoperationofbothis,intruth,merelyinstrumental。Nationsaregovernedbythesamemethods,andonthesameprinciples,bywhichanindividualwithoutauthorityisoftenabletogovernthosewhoarehisequalsorhissuperiors——byaknowledgeoftheirtemper,andbyajudiciousmanagementofit;Imean,whenpublicaffairsaresteadilyandquietlyconducted;
andwhengovernmentisnothingbutacontinuedscufflebetweenthemagistrateandthemultitude;inwhichsometimestheoneandsometimestheotherisuppermost;inwhichtheyalternatelyyieldandprevail,inaseriesofcontemptiblevictories,andscandaloussubmissions。Thetemperofthepeopleamongstwhomhepresidesoughtthereforetobethefirststudyofastatesman。Andtheknowledgeofthistemperitisbynomeansimpossibleforhimtoattain,ifhehasnotaninterestinbeingignorantofwhatitishisdutytolearn。
FALLACYOFEXTREMES。
Itisafallacyinconstantusewiththosewhowouldlevelallthings,andconfoundrightwithwrong,toinsistupontheinconvenienceswhichareattachedtoeverychoice,withouttakingintoconsiderationthedifferentweightandconsequenceofthoseinconveniences。ThequestionisnotconcerningABSOLUTEdiscontentorPERFECTsatisfactioningovernment;neitherofwhichcanbepureandunmixedatanytime,oruponanysystem。Thecontroversyisaboutthatdegreeofgoodhumourinthepeople,whichmaypossiblybeattained,andoughtcertainlytobelookedfor。Whilesomepoliticiansmaybewaitingtoknowwhetherthesenseofeveryindividualbeagainstthem,accuratelydistinguishingthevulgarfromthebettersort,drawinglinesbetweentheenterprisesofafactionandtheeffortsofapeople,theymaychancetoseethegovernment,whichtheyaresonicelyweighing,anddividing,anddistinguishing,tumbletothegroundinthemidstoftheirwisedeliberation。Prudentmen,whensogreatanobjectasthesecurityofgovernment,orevenitspeace,isatstake,willnotruntheriskofadecisionwhichmaybefataltoit。Theywhocanreadthepoliticalskywillseeahurricaneinacloudnobiggerthanahandattheveryedgeofthehorizon,andwillrunintothefirstharbour。Nolinescanbelaiddownforcivilorpoliticalwisdom。Theyareamatterincapableofexactdefinition。But,thoughnomancandrawastrokebetweentheconfinesofdayandnight,yetlightanddarknessare,uponthewhole,tolerablydistinguishable。Norwillitbeimpossibleforaprincetofindoutsuchamodeofgovernment,andsuchpersonstoadministerit,aswillgiveagreatdegreeofcontenttohispeople;withoutanycuriousandanxiousresearchforthatabstract,universal,perfectharmony,which,whileheisseeking,heabandonsthosemeansofordinarytranquillitywhichareinhispowerwithoutanyresearchatall。
PRIVATECHARACTERABASISFORPUBLICCONFIDENCE。
Beforemenareputforwardintothegreattrustsofthestate,theyought,bytheirconduct,tohaveobtainedsuchadegreeofestimationintheircountry,asmaybesomesortofpledgeandsecuritytothepublic,thattheywillnotabusethosetrusts。Itisnomeansecurityforaproperuseofpower,thatamanhasshownbythegeneraltenorofhisactions,thattheaffection,thegoodopinion,theconfidenceofhisfellowcitizens,havebeenamongtheprincipalobjectsofhislife;andthathehasowednoneofthedegradationsofhispowerorfortunetoasettledcontempt,oroccasionalforfeitureoftheiresteem。
Thatmanwhobeforehecomesintopowerhasnofriends,orwhocomingintopowerisobligedtodeserthisfriends,orwholosingithasnofriendstosympathisewithhim;hewhohasnoswayamonganypartofthelandedorcommercialinterest,butwhosewholeimportancehasbegunwithhisoffice,andissuretoendwithit;isapersonwhooughtnevertobesufferedbyacontrollingparliamenttocontinueinanyofthosesituationswhichconfertheleadanddirectionofallourpublicaffairs;becausesuchamanHASNOCONNECTIONWITHTHEINTERESTOFTHE
PEOPLE。Thoseknotsorcabalsofmenwhohavegottogetheravowedlywithoutanypublicprinciple,inordertoselltheirconjunctiniquityatthehigherrate,andarethereforeuniversallyodious,oughtnevertobesufferedtodomineerinthestate;becausetheyhaveNOCONNECTION
WITHTHESENTIMENTSANDOPINIONSOFTHEPEOPLE。
PREVENTION。
Everygoodpoliticalinstitutionmusthaveapreventiveoperationaswellasaremedial。Itoughttohaveanaturaltendencytoexcludebadmenfromgovernment,andnottotrustforthesafetyofthestatetosubsequentpunishmentalone:punishment,whichhaseverbeentardyanduncertain,andwhich,whenpowerissufferedinbadhands,maychancetofallratherontheinjuredthanthecriminal。
CONFIDENCEINTHEPEOPLE。
Theymaybeassured,thathowevertheyamusethemselveswithavarietyofprojectsforsubstitutingsomethingelseintheplaceofthatgreatandonlyfoundationofgovernment,theconfidenceofthepeople,everyattemptwillbutmaketheirconditionworse。Whenmenimaginethattheirfoodisonlyacoverforpoison,andwhentheyneitherlovenortrustthehandthatservesit,itisnotthenameoftheroastbeefofOldEngland,thatwillpersuadethemtositdowntothetablethatisspreadforthem。Whenthepeopleconceivethatlaws,andtribunals,andevenpopularassemblies,arepervertedfromtheendsoftheirinstitution,theyfindinthosenamesofdegeneratedestablishmentsonlynewmotivestodiscontent。Thosebodieswhich,whenfulloflifeandbeauty,layintheirarms,andweretheirjoyandcomfort,whendeadandputrid,becomebutthemoreloathsomefromremembranceofformerendearments。Asullengloomandfuriousdisorderprevailbyfits:thenationlosesitsrelishforpeaceandprosperity;asitdidinthatseasonoffulnesswhichopenedourtroublesinthetimeofCharlestheFirst。Aspeciesofmentowhomastateoforderwouldbecomeasentenceofobscurity,arenourishedintoadangerousmagnitudebytheheatofintestinedisturbances;anditisnowonderthat,byasortofsinisterpiety,theycherish,intheirturn,thedisorderswhicharetheparentsofalltheirconsequence。
FALSEMAXIMSASSUMEDASFIRSTPRINCIPLES。
Itisanadvantagetoallnarrowwisdomandnarrowmorals,thattheirmaximshaveaplausibleair;and,onacursoryview,appearequaltofirstprinciples。Theyarelightandportable。Theyareascurrentascoppercoin;andaboutasvaluable。Theyserveequallythefirstcapacitiesandthelowest;andtheyare,atleast,asusefultotheworstmenastothebest。OfthisstampisthecantofNOTMEN,BUT
MEASURES;asortofcharmbywhichmanypeoplegetloosefromeveryhonourableengagement。WhenIseeamanactingthisdesultoryanddisconnectedpart,withasmuchdetrimenttohisownfortuneasprejudicetothecauseofanyparty,Iamnotpersuadedthatheisright;butIamreadytobelieveheisinearnest。Irespectvirtueinallitssituations;evenwhenitisfoundintheunsuitablecompanyofweakness。Ilamenttoseequalitiesrareandvaluable,squanderedawaywithoutanypublicutility。Butwhenagentlemanwithgreatvisibleemolumentsabandonsthepartyinwhichhehaslongacted,andtellsyou,itisbecauseheproceedsuponhisownjudgment;thatheactsonthemeritsoftheseveralmeasuresastheyarise;andthatheisobligedtofollowhisownconscience,andnotthatofothers;hegivesreasonswhichitisimpossibletocontrovert,anddiscoversacharacterwhichitisimpossibletomistake。Whatshallwethinkofhimwhoneverdifferedfromacertainsetofmenuntilthemomenttheylosttheirpower,andwhoneveragreedwiththeminasingleinstanceafterwards?Wouldnotsuchacoincidenceofinterestandopinionberatherfortunate?Woulditnotbeanextraordinarycastuponthedice,thataman’sconnexionsshoulddegenerateintofaction,preciselyatthecriticalmomentwhentheylosetheirpower,orheacceptsaplace?Whenpeopledeserttheirconnexions,thedesertionisamanifestFACT,uponwhichadirectsimpleissuelies,triablebyplainmen。WhetheraMEASUREofgovernmentberightorwrong,ISNOMATTEROFFACT,butamereaffairofopinion,onwhichmenmay,astheydo,disputeandwranglewithoutend。ButwhethertheindividualTHINKSthemeasurerightorwrong,isapointatstillagreaterdistancefromthereachofallhumandecision。Itisthereforeveryconvenienttopoliticians,nottoputthejudgmentoftheirconductonovertacts,cognizableinanyordinarycourt,butuponsuchmatterascanbetriableonlyinthatsecrettribunal,wheretheyaresureofbeingheardwithfavour,orwhereatworstthesentencewillbeonlyprivatewhipping。
LORDCHATHAM。
Anotherscenewasopened,andotheractorsappearedonthestage。TheState,intheconditionIhavedescribedit,wasdeliveredintothehandsofLordChatham——agreatandcelebratedname;anamethatkeepsthenameofthiscountryrespectableineveryotherontheglobe。Itmaybetrulycalled——
ClarumetvenerabilenomenGentibus,etmultumnostraequodproderaturbi。
Sir,thevenerableageofthisgreatman,hismeritedrank,hissuperioreloquence,hissplendidqualities,hiseminentservices,thevastspacehefillsintheeyeofmankind;and,morethanalltherest,hisfallfrompower,which,likedeath,canonizesandsanctifiesagreatcharacter,willnotsuffermetocensureanypartofhisconduct。Iamafraidtoflatterhim;IamsureIamnotdisposedtoblamehim。Letthose,whohavebetrayedhimbytheiradulation,insulthimwiththeirmalevolence。ButwhatIdonotpresumetocensure,Imayhaveleavetolament。Forawiseman,heseemedtomeatthattimetobegovernedtoomuchbygeneralmaxims。Ispeakwiththefreedomofhistory,andIhopewithoutoffence。Oneortwoofthesemaxims,flowingfromanopinionnotthemostindulgenttoourunhappyspecies,andsurelyalittletoogeneral,ledhimintomeasuresthatweregreatlymischievoustohimself;
andforthatreason,amongothers,perhapsfataltohiscountry;
measures,theeffectsofwhich,Iamafraid,areforeverincurable。Hemadeanadministration,socheckeredandspeckled;heputtogetherapieceofjoinery,socrosslyindentedandwhimsicallydove-tailed;acabinetsovariouslyinlaid;suchapieceofdiversifiedmosaic;suchatesselatedpavementwithoutcement;hereabitofblackstone,andthereabitofwhite;patriotsandcourtiers,king’sfriendsandrepublicans;
WhigsandTories;treacherousfriendsandopenenemies;thatitwasindeedaverycuriousshow;bututterlyunsafetotouch,andunsuretostandon。Thecolleagueswhomhehadassortedatthesameboards,staredateachother,andwereobligedtoask,“Sir,yourname?——Sir,youhavetheadvantageofme——Mr。Such-a-one——Ibegathousandpardons——“I
venturetosay,itdidsohappen,thatpersonshadasingleofficedividedbetweenthem,whohadneverspokentoeachotherintheirlives,untiltheyfoundthemselves,theyknewnothow,piggingtogether,headsandpoints,inthesametruckle-bed。
Sir,inconsequenceofthisarrangement,havingputsomuchthelargerpartofhisenemiesandopposersintopower,theconfusionwassuch,thathisownprinciplescouldnotpossiblyhaveanyeffectorinfluenceintheconductofaffairs。Ifeverhefellintoafitofthegout,orifanyothercausewithdrewhimfrompubliccares,principlesdirectlythecontraryweresuretopredominate。Whenhehadexecutedhisplan,hehadnotaninchofgroundtostandupon。Whenhehadaccomplishedhisschemeofadministration,hewasnolongeraminister。Whenhisfacewashidbutforamoment,hiswholesystemwasonawidesea,withoutchartorcompass。Thegentlemen,hisparticularfriends,who,withthenamesofvariousdepartmentsofministry,wereadmittedtoseemasiftheyactedapartunderhim,withamodestythatbecomesallmen,andwithaconfidenceinhim,whichwasjustifiedeveninitsextravagancebyhissuperiorabilities,hadnever,inanyinstance,presumeduponanyopinionoftheirown。Deprivedofhisguidinginfluence,theywerewhirledabout,thesportofeverygust,andeasilydrivenintoanyport;
andasthosewhojoinedwiththeminmanningthevesselwerethemostdirectlyoppositetohisopinions,measures,andcharacter,andfarthemostartfulandmostpowerfuloftheset,theyeasilyprevailed,soastoseizeuponthevacant,unoccupied,andderelictmindsofhisfriends;
andinstantlytheyturnedthevesselwhollyoutofthecourseofhispolicy。Asifitweretoinsultaswellastobetrayhim,evenlongbeforethecloseofthefirstsessionofhisadministration,wheneverythingwaspubliclytransacted,andwithgreatparade,inhisname,theymadeanact,declaringithighlyjustandexpedienttoraisearevenueinAmerica。Foreventhen,Sir,evenbeforethissplendidorbwasentirelyset,andwhilethewesternhorizonwasinablazewithhisdescendingglory,ontheoppositequarteroftheheavensaroseanotherluminary,and,forhishour,becamelordoftheascendant。
GRENVILLE。
Mr。Grenvillewasafirst-ratefigureinthiscountry。Withamasculineunderstanding,andastoutandresoluteheart,hehadanapplicationundissipatedandunwearied。Hetookpublicbusinessnotasadutywhichhewastofulfil,butasapleasurehewastoenjoy;andheseemedtohavenodelightoutofthishouse,exceptinsuchthingsassomewayrelatedtothebusinessthatwastobedonewithinit。Ifhewasambitious,Iwillsaythisforhim,hisambitionwasofanobleandgenerousstrain。Itwastoraisehimself,notbythelow,pimpingpoliticsofacourt,buttowinhiswaytopower,throughthelaboriousgradationsofpublicservice;andtosecurehimselfawell-earnedrankinParliament,byathoroughknowledgeofitsconstitution,andaperfectpracticeinallitsbusiness。
Sir,ifsuchamanfellintoerrors,itmustbefromdefectsnotintrinsical;theymustberathersoughtintheparticularhabitsofhislife;whichthoughtheydonotaltertheground-workofcharacter,yettingeitwiththeirownhue。Hewasbredinaprofession。Hewasbredtothelaw,whichis,inmyopinion,oneofthefirstandnoblestofhumansciences;asciencewhichdoesmoretoquickenandinvigoratetheunderstanding,thanalltheotherkindsoflearningputtogether;butitisnotapt,exceptinpersonsveryhappilyborn,toopenandtoliberalizethemindexactlyinthesameproportion。Passingfromthatstudyhedidnotgoverylargelyintotheworld;butplungedintobusiness;Imeanintothebusinessofoffice;andthelimitedandfixedmethodsandformsestablishedthere。Muchknowledgeistobehadundoubtedlyinthatline;andthereisnoknowledgewhichisnotvaluable。Butitmaybetrulysaid,thatmentoomuchconversantinofficearerarelymindsofremarkableenlargement。Theirhabitsofofficeareapttogivethematurntothinkthesubstanceofbusinessnottobemuchmoreimportantthantheformsinwhichitisconducted。
Theseformsareadaptedtoordinaryoccasions;andthereforepersonswhoarenurturedinofficedoadmirablywellaslongasthingsgoonintheircommonorder;butwhenthehighroadsarebrokenup,andthewatersout,whenanewandtroubledsceneisopened,andthefileaffordsnoprecedent,thenitisthatagreaterknowledgeofmankind,andafarmoreextensivecomprehensionofthings,isrequisite,thaneverofficegave,orthanofficecanevergive。
CHARLESTOWNSHEND。
Thislighttooispassedandsetforever。Youunderstand,tobesure,thatIspeakofCharlesTownshend,officiallythereproducerofthisfatalscheme;whomIcannotevennowrememberwithoutsomedegreeofsensibility。Intruth,Sir,hewasthedelightandornamentofthishouse,andthecharmofeveryprivatesocietywhichhehonouredwithhispresence。Perhapsthereneveraroseinthiscountry,norinanycountry,amanofamorepointedandfinishedwit;and(wherehispassionswerenotconcerned)ofamorerefined,exquisite,andpenetratingjudgment。
Ifhehadnotsogreatastock,assomehavehadwhoflourishedformerly,ofknowledgelongtreasuredup,heknewbetterbyfar,thananymanIeverwasacquaintedwith,howtobringtogetherwithinashorttime,allthatwasnecessarytoestablish,toillustrate,andtodecoratethatsideofthequestionhesupported。Hestatedhismatterskilfullyandpowerfully。Heparticularlyexcelledinamostluminousexplanationanddisplayofhissubject。Hisstyleofargumentwasneithertriteandvulgar,norsubtleandabstruse。Hehitthehousejustbetweenwindandwater。Andnotbeingtroubledwithtooanxiousazealforanymatterinquestion,hewasnevermoretedious,ormoreearnest,thanthepre-conceivedopinionsandpresenttemperofhishearersrequired;towhomhewasalwaysinperfectunison。Heconformedexactlytothetemperofthehouse;andheseemedtoguide,becausehewasalwayssuretofollowit。
PARTYANDPLACE。
Partyisabodyofmenunited,forpromotingbytheirjointendeavoursthenationalinterest,uponsomeparticularprincipleinwhichtheyareallagreed。Formypart,Ifinditimpossibletoconceivethatanyonebelievesinhisownpolitics,orthinksthemtobeofanyweight,whorefusestoadoptthemeansofhavingthemreducedintopractice。Itisthebusinessofthespeculativephilosophertomarktheproperendsofgovernment。Itisthebusinessofthepolitician,whoisthephilosopherinaction,tofindoutpropermeanstowardsthoseends,andtoemploythemwitheffect。Thereforeeveryhonourableconnectionwillavowitistheirfirstpurposetopursueeveryjustmethodtoputthemenwhoholdtheiropinionsintosuchaconditionasmayenablethemtocarrytheircommonplansintoexecution,withallthepowerandauthorityofthestate。Asthispowerisattachedtocertainsituations,itistheirdutytocontendforthesesituations。Withoutaproscriptionofothers,theyareboundtogivetotheirownpartythepreferenceinallthings;andbynomeans,forprivateconsiderations,toacceptanyoffersofpowerinwhichthewholebodyisnotincluded;nortosufferthemselvestobeled,ortobecontrolled,ortobeoverbalanced,inofficeorincouncil,bythosewhocontradicttheveryfundamentalprinciplesonwhichtheirpartyisformed,andeventhoseuponwhicheveryfairconnectionmuststand。Suchagenerouscontentionforpower,onsuchmanlyandhonourablemaxims,willeasilybedistinguishedfromthemeanandinterestedstruggleforplaceandemolument。Theverystyleofsuchpersonswillservetodiscriminatethemfromthosenumberlessimposterswhohavedeludedtheignorantwithprofessionsincompatiblewithhumanpractice,andhaveafterwardsincensedthembypracticesbelowthelevelofvulgarrectitude。
POLITICALCONNECTIONS。
Everyprofession,notexceptingthegloriousoneofasoldier,orthesacredoneofapriest,isliabletoitsownparticularvices,which,however,formnoargumentagainstthosewaysoflife;norarethevicesthemselvesinevitabletoeveryindividualinthoseprofessions。Ofsuchanatureareconnectionsinpolitics;essentiallynecessaryforthefullperformanceofourpublicduty,accidentallyliabletodegenerateintofaction。Commonwealthsaremadeoffamilies,freecommonwealthsofpartiesalso;andwemayaswellaffirm,thatournaturalregardsandtiesofbloodtendinevitablytomakemenbadcitizens,asthatthebondsofourpartyweakenthosebywhichweareheldtoourcountry。
Somelegislatorswentsofarastomakeneutralityinpartyacrimeagainstthestate。Idonotknowwhetherthismightnothavebeenrathertooverstraintheprinciple。Certainitis,thebestpatriotsinthegreatestcommonwealthshavealwayscommendedandpromotedsuchconnections。Idemsentirederepublica,waswiththemaprincipalgroundoffriendshipandattachment;nordoIknowanyothercapableofformingfirmer,dearer,morepleasing,morehonourable,andmorevirtuoushabitudes。TheRomanscarriedthisprincipleagreatway。Eventheholdingofofficestogether,thedispositionofwhicharosefromchance,notselection,gaverisetoarelationwhichcontinuedforlife。Itwascallednecessitudosortis;anditwaslookeduponwithasacredreverence。Breachesofanyofthesekindsofcivilrelationwereconsideredasactsofthemostdistinguishedturpitude。Thewholepeoplewasdistributedintopoliticalsocieties,inwhichtheyactedinsupportofsuchinterestsinthestateastheyseverallyaffected。Foritwasthenthoughtnocrimetoendeavour,byeveryhonestmeans,toadvancetosuperiorityandpowerthoseofyourownsentimentsandopinions。Thiswisepeoplewasfarfromimaginingthatthoseconnectionshadnotie,andobligedtonoduty;butthatmenmightquitthemwithoutshame,uponeverycallofinterest。Theybelievedprivatehonourtobethegreatfoundationofpublictrust;thatfriendshipwasnomeansteptowardspatriotism;thathewho,inthecommonintercourseoflife,showedheregardedsomebodybesideshimself,whenhecametoactinapublicsituation,mightprobablyconsultsomeotherinterestthanhisown。
NEUTRALITY。
Theywerearaceofmen(IhopeinGodthespeciesisextinct)who,whentheyroseintheirplace,nomanlivingcoulddivine,fromanyknownadherencetoparties,toopinions,ortoprinciples,fromanyorderorsystemintheirpolitics,orfromanysequelorconnectionintheirideas,whatparttheyweregoingtotakeinanydebate。Itisastonishinghowmuchthisuncertainty,especiallyatcriticaltimes,calledtheattentionofallpartiesonsuchmen。Alleyeswerefixedonthem,allearsopentohearthem;eachpartygaped,andlookedalternatelyfortheirvote,almosttotheendoftheirspeeches。Whilethehousehungonthisuncertainty,nowtheHEARHIMSrosefromthisside——nowtheyrebellowedfromtheother;andthatparty,towhomtheyfellatlengthfromtheirtremulousanddancingbalance,alwaysreceivedtheminatempestofapplause。Thefortuneofsuchmenwasatemptationtoogreattoberesistedbyonetowhomasinglewhiffofincensewithheldgavemuchgreaterpainthanhereceiveddelightinthecloudsofitwhichdailyroseabouthimfromtheprodigalsuperstitionofinnumerableadmirers。Hewasacandidateforcontradictoryhonours;andhisgreataimwastomakethoseagreeinadmirationofhimwhoneveragreedinanythingelse。
WEAKNESSINGOVERNMENT。
Letuslearnfromourexperience。Itisnotsupportthatiswantingtogovernment,butreformation。Whenministryrestsuponpublicopinion,itisnotindeedbuiltuponarockofadamant;ithas,however,somestability。Butwhenitstandsuponprivatehumour,itsstructureisofstubble,anditsfoundationisonquicksand。Irepeatitagain——Hethatsupportseveryadministrationsubvertsallgovernment。Thereasonisthis:Thewholebusinessinwhichacourtusuallytakesaninterestgoesonatpresentequallywell,inwhateverhands,whetherhighorlow,wiseorfoolish,scandalousorreputable;thereisnothing,therefore,toholditfirmtoanyonebodyofmen,ortoanyoneconsistentschemeofpolitics。Nothinginterposestopreventthefulloperationofallthecapricesandallthepassionsofacourtupontheservantsofthepublic。Thesystemofadministrationisopentocontinualshocksandchanges,upontheprinciplesofthemeanestcabal,andthemostcontemptibleintrigue。Nothingcanbesolidandpermanent。Allgoodmenatlengthflywithhorrorfromsuchaservice。Menofrankandability,withthespiritwhichoughttoanimatesuchmeninafreestate,whiletheydeclinethejurisdictionofdarkcabalontheiractionsandtheirfortunes,will,forboth,cheerfullyputthemselvesupontheircountry。
Theywilltrustaninquisitiveanddistinguishingparliament;becauseitdoesinquire,anddoesdistinguish。Iftheyactwell,theyknowthat,insuchaparliament,theywillbesupportedagainstanyintrigue;iftheyactill,theyknowthatnointriguecanprotectthem。Thissituation,howeverawful,ishonourable。Butinonehour,andintheself-sameassembly,withoutanyassignedorassignablecause,tobeprecipitatedfromthehighestauthoritytothemostmarkedneglect,possiblyintothegreatestperiloflifeandreputation,isasituationfullofdanger,anddestituteofhonour。Itwillbeshunnedequallybyeverymanofprudence,andeverymanofspirit。
AMERICANPROGRESS。
Nothinginthehistoryofmankindisliketheirprogress。Formypart,I
nevercastaneyeontheirflourishingcommerce,andtheircultivatedandcommodiouslife,buttheyseemtomeratherancientnationsgrowntoperfectionthroughalongseriesoffortunateevents,andatrainofsuccessfulindustry,accumulatingwealthinmanycenturies,thanthecoloniesofyesterday;thanasetofmiserableoutcasts,afewyearsago,notsomuchsentasthrownout,onthebleakandbarrenshoreofadesolatewilderness,threethousandmilesfromallcivilizedintercourse。
COMBINATION,NOTFACTION。
Thatconnectionandfactionareequivalentterms,isanopinionwhichhasbeencarefullyinculcatedatalltimesbyunconstitutionalstatesmen。Thereasonisevident。Whilstmenarelinkedtogether,theyeasilyandspeedilycommunicatethealarmofanyevildesign。Theyareenabledtofathomitwithcommoncounsel,andtoopposeitwithunitedstrength。Whereas,whentheyliedispersed,withoutconcert,order,ordiscipline,communicationisuncertain,counseldifficult,andresistanceimpracticable。Wheremenarenotacquaintedwitheachother’sprinciples,norexperiencedineachother’stalents,noratallpractisedintheirmutualhabitudesanddispositionsbyjointeffortsinbusiness;nopersonalconfidence,nofriendship,nocommoninterest,subsistingamongthem;itisevidentlyimpossiblethattheycanactapublicpartwithuniformity,perseverance,orefficacy。Inaconnection,themostinconsiderableman,byaddingtotheweightofthewhole,hashisvalue,andhisuse;outofit,thegreatesttalentsarewhollyunserviceabletothepublic。Noman,whoisnotinflamedbyvain-gloryintoenthusiasm,canflatterhimselfthathissingle,unsupported,desultory,unsystematicendeavours,areofpowertodefeatthesubtledesignsandunitedcabalsofambitiouscitizens。Whenbadmencombine,thegoodmustassociate;elsetheywillfall,onebyone,anunpitiedsacrificeinacontemptiblestruggle。
GREATMEN。
Greatmenaretheguide-postsandland-marksinthestate。Thecreditofsuchmenatcourt,orinthenation,isthesolecauseofallthepublicmeasures。Itwouldbeaninvidiousthing(mostforeign,Itrust,towhatyouthinkmydisposition)toremarktheerrorsintowhichtheauthorityofgreatnameshasbroughtthenation,withoutdoingjusticeatthesametimetothegreatqualitieswhencethatauthorityarose。Thesubjectisinstructivetothosewhowishtoformthemselvesonwhateverofexcellencehasgonebeforethem。Therearemanyyoungmembersinthehouse(suchoflatehasbeentherapidsuccessionofpublicmen)whoneversawthatprodigy,CharlesTownshend;norofcourseknowwhatafermenthewasabletoexciteineverythingbytheviolentebullitionofhismixedvirtuesandfailings。Forfailingshehadundoubtedly——manyofusrememberthem;wearethisdayconsideringtheeffectofthem。Buthehadnofailingswhichwerenotowingtoanoblecause;toanardent,generous,perhapsanimmoderate,passionforfame;apassionwhichistheinstinctofallgreatsouls。
POWEROFCONSTITUENTS。
Thepowerofthepeople,withinthelaws,mustshowitselfsufficienttoprotecteveryrepresentativeintheanimatedperformanceofhisduty,orthatdutycannotbeperformed。TheHouseofCommonscanneverbeacontrolonotherpartsofgovernment,unlesstheyarecontrolledthemselvesbytheirconstituents;andunlesstheseconstituentspossesssomerightinthechoiceofthathouse,whichitisnotinthepowerofthathousetotakeaway。Iftheysufferthispowerofarbitraryincapacitationtostand,theyhaveutterlypervertedeveryotherpoweroftheHouseofCommons。ThelateproceedingIwillnotsayIScontrarytolaw,itMUSTbeso;forthepowerwhichisclaimedcannot,byanypossibility,bealegalpowerinanylimitedmemberofgovernment。
INFLUENCEOFPLACEINGOVERNMENT。
Itisnoinconsiderablepartofwisdom,toknowhowmuchofaneviloughttobetolerated;lest,byattemptingadegreeofpurityimpracticableindegeneratetimesandmanners,insteadofcuttingoffthesubsistingillpractices,newcorruptionsmightbeproducedfortheconcealmentandsecurityoftheold。Itwerebetter,undoubtedly,thatnoinfluenceatallcouldaffectthemindofamemberofParliament。Butofallmodesofinfluence,inmyopinion,aplaceunderthegovernmentistheleastdisgracefultothemanwhoholdsit,andbyfarthemostsafetothecountry。Iwouldnotshutoutthatsortofinfluencewhichisopenandvisible,whichisconnectedwiththedignityandtheserviceofthestate,whenitisnotinmypowertopreventtheinfluenceofcontracts,ofsubscriptions,ofdirectbribery,andthoseinnumerablemethodsofclandestinecorruption,whichareabundantlyinthehandsofthecourt,andwhichwillbeappliedaslongasthesemeansofcorruption,andthedispositiontobecorrupted,haveexistenceamongus。Ourconstitutionstandsonaniceequipoise,withsteepprecipicesanddeepwatersuponallsidesofit。Inremovingitfromadangerousleaningtowardsoneside,theremaybeariskofoversettingitontheother。Everyprojectofamaterialchangeinagovernmentsocomplicatedasours,combinedatthesametimewithexternalcircumstances,stillmorecomplicated,isamatterfullofdifficulties:inwhichaconsideratemanwillnotbetooreadytodecide;aprudentmantooreadytoundertake;oranhonestmantooreadytopromise。Theydonotrespectthepublicnorthemselves,whoengageformorethantheyaresurethattheyoughttoattempt,orthattheyareabletoperform。
TAXATIONINVOLVESPRINCIPLE。
Nomaneverdoubtedthatthecommodityofteacouldbearanimpositionofthreepence。Butnocommoditywillbearthreepence,orwillbearapenny,whenthegeneralfeelingsofmenareirritated,andtwomillionsofpeopleareresolvednottopay。ThefeelingsofthecolonieswereformerlythefeelingsofGreatBritain。TheirswereformerlythefeelingsofMr。Hampdenwhencalleduponforthepaymentoftwentyshillings。WouldtwentyshillingshaveruinedMr。Hampden’sfortune?No!
butthepaymentofhalftwentyshillings,ontheprincipleitwasdemanded,wouldhavemadehimaslave。
GOODMEMBEROFPARLIAMENT。
Tobeagoodmemberofparliamentis,letmetellyou,noeasytask;
especiallyatthistime,whenthereissostrongadispositiontorunintotheperilousextremesofservilecomplianceorwildpopularity。Tounitecircumspectionwithvigourisabsolutelynecessary;butitisextremelydifficult。WearenowmembersforarichcommercialCITY;thiscity,however,isbutapartofarichcommercialNATION,theinterestsofwhicharevarious,multiform,andintricate。Wearemembersforthatgreatnation,whichhoweverisitselfbutpartofagreatEMPIRE,extendedbyourvirtueandourfortunetothefarthestlimitsoftheeastandofthewest。Allthesewide-spreadinterestsmustbeconsidered;mustbecompared;mustbereconciled,ifpossible。WearemembersforaFREEcountry;andsurelyweallknow,thatthemachineofafreeconstitutionisnosimplething;butasintricateandasdelicateasitisvaluable。WearemembersinagreatandancientMONARCHY;andwemustpreservereligiouslythetruelegalrightsofthesovereign,whichformthekey-stonethatbindstogetherthenobleandwell-constructedarchofourempireandourconstitution。
FISHERIESOFNEWENGLAND。
Astothewealthwhichthecolonieshavedrawnfromtheseabytheirfisheries,youhadallthatmatterfullyopenedatyourbar。Yousurelythoughtthoseacquisitionsofvalue,fortheyseemedeventoexciteyourenvy;andyetthespiritbywhichthatenterprisingemploymenthasbeenexercisedoughtrather,inmyopinion,tohaveraisedyouresteemandadmiration。Andpray,Sir,whatintheworldisequaltoit!Passbytheotherparts,andlookatthemannerinwhichthepeopleofNewEnglandhaveoflatecarriedonthewhalefishery。Whilstwefollowthemamongthetumblingmountainsofice,andbeholdthempenetratingintothedeepestfrozenrecessesofHudson’sBayandDavis’sStraits,whilstwearelookingforthembeneaththearcticcircle,wehearthattheyhavepiercedintotheoppositeregionofpolarcold,thattheyareattheantipodes,andengagedunderthefrozenserpentofthesouth。FalklandIsland,whichseemedtooremoteandromanticanobjectforthegraspofnationalambition,isbutastageandresting-placeintheprogressoftheirvictoriousindustry。Noristheequinoctialheatmorediscouragingtothem,thantheaccumulatedwinterofboththepoles。WeknowthatwhilstsomeofthemdrawthelineandstriketheharpoononthecoastofAfrica,othersrunthelongitude,andpursuetheirgiganticgamealongthecoastofBrazil。Noseabutwhatisvexedbytheirfisheries。Noclimatethatisnotwitnesstotheirtoils。NeithertheperseveranceofHolland,northeactivityofFrance,northedexterousandfirmsagacityofEnglishenterprise,evercarriedthismostperilousmodeofhardindustrytotheextenttowhichithasbeenpushedbythisrecentpeople;apeoplewhoarestill,asitwere,butinthegristle,andnotyethardenedintotheboneofmanhood。
PREPARATIONFORPARLIAMENT。
WhenIfirstdevotedmyselftothepublicservice,IconsideredhowI
shouldrendermyselffitforit;andthisIdidbyendeavouringtodiscoverwhatitwasthatgavethiscountrytherankitholdsintheworld。Ifoundthatourprosperityanddignityaroseprincipally,ifnotsolely,fromtwosources;——ourconstitutionandcommerce。BoththeseI
havesparednostudytounderstand,andnoendeavourtosupport。
Thedistinguishingpartofourconstitutionisitsliberty。Topreservethatlibertyinviolate,seemstheparticulardutyandpropertrustofamemberoftheHouseofCommons。Buttheliberty,theonlylibertyI
mean,isalibertyconnectedwithorder;thatnotonlyexistsalongwithorderandvirtue,butwhichcannotexistatallwithoutthem。Itinheresingoodandsteadygovernment,asinitssubstanceandvitalprinciple。
Theothersourceofourpoweriscommerce,ofwhichyouaresolargeapart,andwhichcannotexist,nomorethanyourliberty,withoutaconnectionwithmanyvirtues。Ithaseverbeenaveryparticularandaveryfavouriteobjectofmystudy,initsprinciples,andinitsdetails。IthinkmanyhereareacquaintedwiththetruthofwhatIsay。
ThisIknow,thatIhaveeverhadmyhouseopen,andmypoorservicesready,fortradersandmanufacturersofeverydenomination。Myfavouriteambitionistohavethoseservicesacknowledged。Inowappearbeforeyoutomaketrial,whethermyearnestendeavourshavebeensowhollyoppressedbytheweaknessofmyabilitiesastoberenderedinsignificantintheeyesofagreattradingcity;orwhetheryouchoosetogiveaweighttohumbleabilities,forthesakeofthehonestexertionswithwhichtheyareaccompanied。Thisismytrialto?day。Myindustryisnotontrial。OfmyindustryIamsure,asfarasmyconstitutionofmindandbodyadmitted。
BATHURSTANDAMERICA’SFUTURE。
Letus,however,beforewithdescendfromthisnobleeminence,reflectthatthisgrowthofournationalprosperityhashappenedwithintheshortperiodofthelifeofman。Ithashappenedwithinsixty-eightyears。Therearethosealivewhosememorymighttouchthetwoextremities。Forinstance,myLordBathurstmightrememberallthestagesoftheprogress。Hewas,in1704,ofanageatleasttobemadetocomprehendsuchthings。Hewasthenoldenough“actaparentumjamlegere,etquaesitpoteritcognoscerevirtus。”Suppose,Sir,thattheangelofthisauspiciousyouth,foreseeingthemanyvirtueswhichmadehimoneofthemostamiable,asheisoneofthemostfortunate,menofhisage,hadopenedtohiminvision,thatwhen,inthefourthgeneration,thethirdprinceofthehouseofBrunswickhadsattwelveyearsonthethroneofthatnation,which(bythehappyissueofmoderateandhealingcouncils)wastobemadeGreatBritain,heshouldseehisson,lordchancellorofEngland,turnbackthecurrentofhereditarydignitytoitsfountain,andraisehimtoahigherrankofpeerage,whilstheenrichedthefamilywithanewone。Ifamidstthesebrightandhappyscenesofdomestichonourandprosperity,thatangelshouldhavedrawnupthecurtain,andunfoldedtherisinggloriesofhiscountry,andwhilsthewasgazingwithadmirationonthethencommercialgrandeurofEngland,thegeniusshouldpointouttohimalittlespeck,scarcevisibleinthemassofthenationalinterest,asmallseminalprinciple,ratherthanaformedbody,andshouldtellhim——“Youngman,thereisAmerica——whichatthisdayservesforlittlemorethantoamuseyouwithstoriesofsavagemen,anduncouthmanners;yetshall,beforeyoutasteofdeath,showitselfequaltothewholeofthatcommercewhichnowattractstheenvyoftheworld。WhateverEnglandhasbeengrowingtobyaprogressiveincreaseofimprovement,broughtinbyvarietiesofpeople,bysuccessionofcivilizingconquestsandcivilizingsettlementsinaseriesofseventeenhundredyears,youshallseeasmuchaddedtoherbyAmericainthecourseofasinglelife!”Ifthisstateofhiscountryhadbeenforetoldtohim,woulditnotrequireallthesanguinecredulityofyouth,andallthefervidglowofenthusiasm,tomakehimbelieveit?Fortunateman,hehaslivedtoseeit!Fortunate,indeed,ifhelivestoseenothingthatshallvarytheprospect,andcloudthesettingofhisday!
CANDIDPOLICY。
Refinedpolicyeverhasbeentheparentofconfusion;andeverwillbeso,aslongastheworldendures。Plaingoodintention,whichisaseasilydiscoveredatthefirstview,asfraudissurelydetectedatlast,is,letmesay,ofnomeanforceinthegovernmentofmankind。
Genuinesimplicityofheartisahealingandcementingprinciple。Myplan,therefore,beingformeduponthemostsimplegroundsimaginable,maydisappointsomepeople,whentheyhearit。Ithasnothingtorecommendittothepruriencyofcuriousears。Thereisnothingatallnewandcaptivatinginit。Ithasnothingofthesplendouroftheprojectwhichhasbeenlatelylaiduponyourtablebythenoblelordintheblueriband。Itdoesnotproposetofillyourlobbywithsquabblingcolonyagents,whowillrequiretheinterpositionofyourmace,ateveryinstant,tokeepthepeaceamongstthem。Itdoesnotinstituteamagnificentauctionoffinance,wherecaptivatedprovincescometogeneralransombybiddingagainsteachother,untilyouknockdownthehammer,anddetermineaproportionofpaymentsbeyondallthepowersofalgebratoequalizeandsettle。
WISDOMOFCONCESSION。
Peaceimpliesreconciliation;andwheretherehasbeenamaterialdispute,reconciliationdoesinamanneralwaysimplyconcessionontheonepartortheother。InthisstateofthingsImakenodifficultyinaffirmingthattheproposaloughttooriginatefromus。Greatandacknowledgedforceisnotimpaired,eitherineffectorinopinion,byanunwillingnesstoexertitself。Thesuperiorpowermayofferpeacewithhonourandwithsafety。Suchanofferfromsuchapowerwillbeattributedtomagnanimity。Buttheconcessionsoftheweakaretheconcessionsoffear。Whensuchaoneisdisarmed,heiswhollyatthemercyofhissuperior;andhelosesforeverthattimeandthosechanceswhich,astheyhappentoallmen,arethestrengthandresourcesofallinferiorpower。
MAGNANIMITY。
Asforthetriflingpetulancewhichtherageofpartystirsupinlittleminds,thoughitshouldshowitselfeveninthiscourt,ithasnotmadetheslightestimpressiononme。Thehighestflightofsuchclamorousbirdsiswingedinaninferiorregionoftheair。Wehearthem,andwelookuponthem,justasyou,gentlemen,whenyouenjoythesereneaironyourloftyrocks,lookdownuponthegullsthatskimthemudofyourriver,whenitisexhaustedofitstide。
DUTYOFREPRESENTATIVES。
Itoughttobethehappinessandgloryofarepresentativetoliveinthestrictestunion,theclosestcorrespondence,andthemostunreservedcommunicationwithhisconstituents。Theirwishesoughttohavegreatweightwithhim;theiropinionhighrespect;theirbusinessunremittedattention。Itishisdutytosacrificehisrepose,hispleasures,hissatisfactions,totheirs;andaboveall,ever,andinallcases,toprefertheirinteresttohisown。But,hisunbiassedopinion,hismaturejudgment,hisenlightenedconscience,heoughtnottosacrificetoyou,toanyman,ortoanysetofmenliving。Thesehedoesnotderivefromyourpleasure;no,norfromthelawandtheconstitution。TheyareatrustfromProvidence,fortheabuseofwhichheisdeeplyanswerable。
Yourrepresentativeowesyou,nothisindustryonly,buthisjudgment;
andhebetrays,insteadofservingyou,ifhesacrificesittoyouropinion。
PRUDENTIALSILENCE。
ThoughIgavesofarintohisopinion,thatIimmediatelythrewmythoughtsintoasortofparliamentaryform,Iwasbynomeansequallyreadytoproducethem。Itgenerallyarguessomedegreeofnaturalimpotenceofmind,orsomewantofknowledgeoftheworld,tohazardplansofgovernmentexceptfromaseatofauthority。Propositionsaremade,notonlyineffectually,butsomewhatdisreputably,whenthemindsofmenarenotproperlydisposedfortheirreception:andformypart,I
amnotambitiousofridicule;notabsolutelyacandidatefordisgrace。
COLONIALTIES。
Theyare“ourchildren;“butwhenchildrenaskforbread,wearenottogiveastone。Isitbecausethenaturalresistanceofthings,andthevariousmutationsoftime,hindersourgovernment,oranyschemeofgovernment,frombeinganymorethanasortofapproximationtotheright,isitthereforethatthecoloniesaretorecedefromitinfinitely?Whenthischildofourswishestoassimilatetoitsparent,andtoreflectwithatruefilialresemblancethebeauteouscountenanceofBritishliberty,arewetoturntothemtheshamefulpartsofourconstitution?arewetogivethemourweaknessfortheirstrength?ouropprobriumfortheirglory?andthesloughofslavery,whichwearenotabletoworkoff,toservethemfortheirfreedom?
GOVERNMENTANDLEGISLATION。
Ifgovernmentwereamatterofwilluponanyside,yours,withoutquestion,oughttobesuperior。Butgovernmentandlegislationaremattersofreasonandjudgment,andnotofinclination;andwhatsortofreasonisthat,inwhichthedeterminationprecedesthediscussion;inwhichonesetofmendeliberate,andanotherdecide;andwherethosewhoformtheconclusionareperhapsthreehundredmilesdistantfromthosewhohearthearguments?
PARLIAMENT。
ParliamentisnotaCONGRESSofambassadorsfromdifferentandhostileinterests,whichinterestseachmustmaintain,asanagentandadvocate,againstotheragentsandadvocates;butparliamentisaDELIBERATIVE
assemblyofONEnation,withONEinterest,thatofthewhole;where,notlocalpurposes,notlocalprejudices,oughttoguide,butthegeneralgood,resultingfromthegeneralreasonofthewhole。Youchooseamemberindeed;butwhenyouhavechosenhim,heisnotmemberofBristol,butheisamemberofPARLIAMENT。
MORALLEVELLERS。
ThismorallevellingisaSERVILEPRINCIPLE。Itleadstopracticalpassiveobediencefarbetterthanallthedoctrineswhichthepliantaccommodationoftheologytopowerhaseverproduced。Itcutsupbytheroots,notonlyallideaofforcibleresistance,butevenofcivilopposition。Itdisposesmentoanabjectsubmission,notbyopinion,whichmaybeshakenbyargumentoralteredbypassion,butbythestrongtiesofpublicandprivateinterest。Forifallmenwhoactinapublicsituationareequallyselfish,corrupt,andvenal,whatreasoncanbegivenfordesiringanysortofchange,which,besidestheevilswhichmustattendallchanges,canbeproductiveofnopossibleadvantage?Theactivemeninthestatearetruesamplesofthemass。Iftheyareuniversallydepraved,thecommonwealthitselfisnotsound。Wemayamuseourselveswithtalkingasmuchaswepleaseofthevirtueofmiddleorhumblelife;thatis,wemayplaceourconfidenceinthevirtueofthosewhohaveneverbeentried。Butifthepersonswhoarecontinuallyemergingoutofthatspherebenobetterthanthosewhombirthhasplacedaboveit,whathopesarethereintheremainderofthebody,whichistofurnishtheperpetualsuccessionofthestate?Allwhohaveeverwrittenongovernmentareunanimous,thatamongapeoplegenerallycorrupt,libertycannotlongexist。Andindeedhowisitpossible?whenthosewhoaretomakethelaws,toguard,toenforce,ortoobeythem,are,byatacitconfederacyofmanners,indisposedtothespiritofallgenerousandnobleinstitutions。
PUBLICSALARYANDPATRIOTICSERVICE。
Iamnotpossessedofanexactcommonmeasurebetweenrealserviceanditsreward。Iamverysurethatstatesdosometimesreceiveserviceswhichitishardlyintheirpowertorewardaccordingtotheirworth。IfIweretogivemyjudgmentwithregardtothiscountry,Idonotthinkthegreatefficientofficesofthestatetobeoverpaid。Theserviceofthepublicisathingwhichcannotbeputtoauction,andstruckdowntothosewhowillagreetoexecuteitthecheapest。Whentheproportionbetweenrewardandserviceisourobject,wemustalwaysconsiderofwhatnaturetheserviceis,andwhatsortofmentheyarethatmustperformit。Whatisjustpaymentforonekindoflabour,andfullencouragementforonekindoftalents,isfraudanddiscouragementtoothers。Manyofthegreatofficeshavemuchdutytodo,andmuchexpenseofrepresentationtomaintain。Asecretaryofstate,forinstance,mustnotappearsordidintheeyesoftheministersofothernations;neitheroughtourministersabroadtoappearcontemptibleinthecourtswheretheyreside。Inallofficesofduty,thereis,almostnecessarily,agreatneglectofalldomesticaffairs。Apersoninhighofficecanrarelytakeaviewofhisfamilyhouse。Ifheseesthatthestatetakesnodetriment,thestatemustseethathisaffairsshouldtakeaslittle。
Iwillevengosofarastoaffirm,thatifmenwerewillingtoserveinsuchsituationswithoutsalary,theyoughtnottobepermittedtodoit。
Ordinaryservicemustbesecuredbythemotivestoordinaryintegrity。I
donothesitatetosay,thatthatstatewhichlaysitsfoundationsinrareandheroicvirtues,willbesuretohaveitssuperstructureinthebasestprofligacyandcorruption。Anhonourableandfairprofitisthebestsecurityagainstavariceandrapacity;asinallthingselse,alawfulandregulatedenjoymentisthebestsecurityagainstdebaucheryandexcess。Foraswealthispower,soallpowerwillinfalliblydrawwealthtoitselfbysomemeansorother:andwhenmenareleftnowayofascertainingtheirprofitsbutbytheirmeansofobtainingthem,thosemeanswillbeincreasedtoinfinity。Thisistrueinallthepartsofadministration,aswellasinthewhole。Ifanyindividualweretodeclinehisappointments,itmightgiveanunfairadvantagetoostentatiousambitionoverunpretendingservice;itmightbreedinvidiouscomparisons;itmighttendtodestroywhateverlittleunityandagreementmaybefoundamongministers。And,afterall,whenanambitiousmanhadrundownhiscompetitorsbyafallaciousshowofdisinterestedness,andfixedhimselfinpowerbythatmeans,whatsecurityistherethathewouldnotchangehiscourse,andclaimasanindemnitytentimesmorethanhehasgivenup?
RATIONALLIBERTY。
Liberty,too,mustbelimitedinordertobepossessed。Thedegreeofrestraintitisimpossibleinanycasetosettleprecisely。Butitoughttobetheconstantaimofeverywisepubliccounciltofindoutbycautiousexperiments,andrational,coolendeavours,withhowlittle,nothowmuch,ofthisrestraintthecommunitycansubsist。Forlibertyisagoodtobeimproved,andnotaneviltobelessened。Itisnotonlyaprivateblessingofthefirstorder,butthevitalspringandenergyofthestateitself,whichhasjustsomuchlifeandvigourasthereislibertyinit。Butwhetherlibertybeadvantageousornot(forIknowitisafashiontodecrytheveryprinciple),nonewilldisputethatpeaceisablessing;andpeacemustinthecourseofhumanaffairsbefrequentlyboughtbysomeindulgenceandtolerationatleasttoliberty。
Forasthesabbath(thoughofDivineinstitution)wasmadeforman,notmanforthesabbath,government,whichcanclaimnohigheroriginorauthority,initsexerciseatleast,oughttoconformtotheexigenciesofthetime,andthetemperandcharacterofthepeoplewithwhomitisconcerned;andnotalwaystoattemptviolentlytobendthepeopletotheirtheoriesofsubjection。Thebulkofmankindontheirpartarenotexcessivelycuriousconcerninganytheorieswhilsttheyarereallyhappy;andonesuresymptomofanill-conductedstateisthepropensityofthepeopletoresorttothem。
IRELANDANDMAGNACHARTA。
Thefeudalbaronageandthefeudalknighthood,therootsofourprimitiveconstitution,wereearlytransplantedintothatsoil,andgrewandflourishedthere。MagnaCharta,ifitdidnotgiveusoriginallytheHouseofCommons,gaveusatleastahouseofcommonsofweightandconsequence。ButyourancestorsdidnotchurlishlysitdownalonetothefeastofMagnaCharta。Irelandwasmadeimmediatelyapartaker。ThisbenefitofEnglishlawsandliberties,Iconfess,wasnotatfirstextendedtoALLIreland。Marktheconsequence。EnglishauthorityandEnglishlibertyhadexactlythesameboundaries。Yourstandardcouldneverbeadvancedaninchbeyondyourprivileges。SirJohnDavisshows,beyondadoubt,thattherefusalofageneralcommunicationoftheserightswasthetruecausewhyIrelandwasfivehundredyearsinsubduing;andafterthevainprojectsofamilitarygovernment,attemptedinthereignofQueenElizabeth,itwassoondiscoveredthatnothingcouldmakethatcountryEnglish,incivilityandallegiance,butyourlawsandyourformsoflegislature。ItwasnotEnglisharms,buttheEnglishconstitution,thatconqueredIreland。FromthattimeIrelandhaseverhadageneralparliament,asshehadbeforeapartialparliament。Youchangedthepeople;youalteredthereligion;butyounevertouchedtheformorthevitalsubstanceoffreegovernmentinthatkingdom。Youdeposedkings;yourestoredthem;youalteredthesuccessiontotheirs,aswellastoyourowncrown;butyouneveralteredtheirconstitution;theprincipleofwhichwasrespectedbyusurpation;restoredwiththerestorationofmonarchy,andestablished,Itrust,forever,bythegloriousRevolution。
COLONIESANDBRITISHCONSTITUTION。
Forthatservice,forallservice,whetherofrevenue,trade,orempire,mytrustisinherinterestintheBritishconstitution。Myholdofthecoloniesisinthecloseaffectionwhichgrowsfromcommonnames,fromkindredblood,fromsimilarprivileges,andequalprotection。Theseareties,which,thoughlightasair,areasstrongaslinksofiron。Letthecoloniesalwayskeeptheideaoftheircivilrightsassociatedwithyourgovernment;——theywillclingandgrappletoyou;andnoforceunderheavenwillbeofpowertotearthemfromtheirallegiance。Butletitbeonceunderstoodthatyourgovernmentmaybeonething,andtheirprivilegesanother;thatthesetwothingsmayexistwithoutanymutualrelation;thecementisgone;thecohesionisloosened;andeverythinghastenstodecayanddissolution。Aslongasyouhavethewisdomtokeepthesovereignauthorityofthiscountryasthesanctuaryofliberty,thesacredtempleconsecratedtoourcommonfaith,whereverthechosenraceandsonsofEnglandworshipfreedom,theywillturntheirfacestowardsyou。Themoretheymultiply,themorefriendsyouwillhave;themoreardentlytheyloveliberty,themoreperfectwillbetheirobedience。
Slaverytheycanhaveanywhere。Itisaweedthatgrowsineverysoil。
TheymayhaveitfromSpain,theymayhaveitfromPrussia。But,untilyoubecomelosttoallfeelingofyourtrueinterestandyournaturaldignity,freedomtheycanhavefromnonebutyou。Thisisthecommodityofprice,ofwhichyouhavethemonopoly。Thisisthetrueactofnavigation,whichbindstoyouthecommerceofthecolonies,andthroughthemsecurestoyouthewealthoftheworld。Denythemthisparticipationoffreedom,andyoubreakthatsolebond,whichoriginallymade,andmuststillpreserve,theunityoftheempire。Donotentertainsoweakanimagination,asthatyourregistersandyourbonds,youraffidavitsandyoursufferances,yourcocketsandyourclearances,arewhatformthegreatsecuritiesofyourcommerce。Donotdreamthatyourlettersofoffice,andyourinstructions,andyoursuspendingclauses,arethethingsthatholdtogetherthegreatcontextureofthismysteriouswhole。Thesethingsdonotmakeyourgovernment。Deadinstruments,passivetoolsastheyare,itisthespiritoftheEnglishcommunionthatgivesalltheirlifeandefficacytothem。ItisthespiritoftheEnglishconstitution,which,infusedthroughthemightymass,pervades,feeds,unites,invigorates,vivifieseverypartoftheempire,evendowntotheminutestmember。
RECIPROCALCONFIDENCE。
Atthefirstfatalopeningofthiscontest,thewisestcourseseemedtobetoputanendassoonaspossibletotheimmediatecausesofthedispute;andtoquietadiscussion,noteasilysettleduponclearprinciples,andarisingfromclaims,whichpridewouldpermitneitherpartytoabandon,byresortingasnearlyaspossibletotheold,successfulcourse。Amererepealoftheobnoxioustax,withadeclarationofthelegislativeauthorityofthiskingdom,wasthenfullysufficienttoprocurepeacetoBOTHSIDES。Manisacreatureofhabit,and,thefirstbreachbeingofveryshortcontinuance,thecoloniesfellbackexactlyintotheirancientstate。Thecongresshasusedanexpressionwithregardtothispacification,whichappearstometrulysignificant。AftertherepealoftheStampAct,“thecoloniesfell,“
saysthisassembly,“intotheirancientstateofUNSUSPECTINGCONFIDENCE
INTHEMOTHERCOUNTRY。”Thisunsuspectingconfidenceisthetruecentreofgravityamongstmankind,aboutwhichallthepartsareatrest。ItisthisUNSUSPECTINGCONFIDENCEthatremovesalldifficulties,andreconcilesallthecontradictionswhichoccurinthecomplexityofallancient,puzzled,politicalestablishments。Happyaretherulerswhichhavethesecretofpreservingit!
PENSIONSANDTHECROWN。
WhenmenreceiveobligationsfromtheCrown,throughthepioushandsoffathers,orofconnectionsasvenerableasthepaternal,thedependencieswhicharisefromthencearetheobligationsofgratitude,andnotthefettersofservility。Suchtiesoriginateinvirtue,andtheypromoteit。Theycontinuemeninthosehabitudesoffriendship,thosepoliticalconnexions,andthosepoliticalprinciples,inwhichtheybeganlife。Theyareantidotesagainstacorruptlevity,insteadofcausesofit。Whatanunseemlyspectaclewoulditafford,whatadisgracewoulditbetothecommonwealththatsufferedsuchthings,toseethehopefulsonofameritoriousministerbegginghisbreadatthedoorofthattreasury,fromwhencehisfatherdispensedtheeconomyofanempire,andpromotedthehappinessandgloryofhiscountry!Whyshouldhebeobligedtoprostratehishonour,andtosubmithisprinciplesattheleveeofsomeproudfavourite,shoulderedandthrustasidebyeveryimpudentpretender,ontheveryspotwhereafewdaysbeforehesawhimselfadored?——obligedtocringetotheauthorofthecalamitiesofhishouse,andtokissthehandsthatareredwithhisfather’sblood。
COLONIALPROGRESS。
Butnothinginprogressioncanrestonitsoriginalplan。Wemayaswellthinkofrockingagrownmaninthecradleofaninfant。Thereforeasthecoloniesprosperedandincreasedtoanumerousandmightypeople,spreadingoveraverygreattractoftheglobe;itwasnaturalthattheyshouldattributetoassemblies,sorespectableintheirformalconstitution,somepartofthedignityofthegreatnationswhichtheyrepresented。Nolongertiedtoby-laws,theseassembliesmadeactsofallsortsandinallcaseswhatsoever。Theyleviedmoney,notforparochialpurposes,butuponregulargrantstotheCrown,followingalltherulesandprinciplesofaparliamenttowhichtheyapproachedeverydaymoreandmorenearly。ThosewhothinkthemselveswiserthanProvidence,andstrongerthanthecourseofnature,maycomplainofallthisvariation,ontheonesideortheother,astheirseveralhumoursandprejudicesmayleadthem。Butthingscouldnotbeotherwise;andEnglishcoloniesmustbehadontheseterms,ornothadatall。