DIFFICULTYTHEPATHTOGLORY。
Whenyouchooseanarduousandslipperypath,Godforbidthatanyweakfeelingsofmydecliningage,whichcallsforsoothingsandsupports,andwhichcanhavenonebutfromyou,shouldmakemewishthatyoushouldabandonwhatyouareabout,orshouldtriflewithit。Inthishousewesubmit,thoughwithtroubledminds,tothatorderwhichhasconnectedallgreatdutieswithtoilsandwithperils,whichhasconductedtheroadtoglorythroughtheregionsofobloquyandreproach,andwhichwillneversufferthedisparagingallianceofspurious,false,andfugitivepraisewithgenuineandpermanentreputation。WeknowthatthePowerwhichhassettledthatorder,andsubjectedyoutoitbyplacingyouinthesituationyouarein,isabletobringyououtofitwithcreditandwithsafety。Hiswillbedone。Allmustcomeright。Youmayopenthewaywithpain,andunderreproach。Otherswillpursueitwitheaseandwithapplause。
ROBESPIERREANDHISCOUNTERPARTS。
TheyhavemurderedoneRobespierre。ThisRobespierretheytelluswasacrueltyrant,andnowthatheisputoutoftheway,allwillgowellinFrance。Astraeawillagainreturntothatearthfromwhichshehasbeenanemigrant,andallnationswillresorttohergoldenscales。Itisveryextraordinary,thattheveryinstantthemodeofParisisknownhere,itbecomesallthefashioninLondon。Thisistheirjargon。Itistheoldbontonofrobbers,whocasttheircommoncrimesonthewickednessoftheirdepartedassociates。IcarelittleaboutthememoryofthissameRobespierre。Iamsurehewasanexecrablevillain。IrejoicedathispunishmentneithermorenorlessthanIshouldattheexecutionofthepresentDirectory,oranyofitsmembers。ButwhogaveRobespierrethepowerofbeingatyrant?
andwhoweretheinstrumentsofhistyranny?Thepresentvirtuousconstitution-mongers。Hewasatyrant,theywerehissatellitesandhishangmen。Theirsolemeritisinthemurderoftheircolleague。
Theyhaveexpiatedtheirothermurdersbyanewmurder。Ithasalwaysbeenthecaseamongthisbanditti。Theyhavealwayshadtheknifeateachother’sthroats,aftertheyhadalmostblunteditatthethroatsofeveryhonestman。Thesepeoplethoughtthat,inthecommerceofmurder,hewasliketohavethebetterofthebargainifanytimewaslost;theythereforetookoneoftheirshortrevolutionarymethods,andmassacredhiminamannersoperfidiousandcruel,aswouldshockallhumanity,ifthestrokewasnotstruckbythepresentrulersononeoftheirownassociates。Butthislastactofinfidelityandmurderistoexpiatealltherest,andtoqualifythemfortheamityofahumaneandvirtuoussovereignandcivilizedpeople。IhaveheardthataTartarbelieves,whenhehaskilledaman,thatallhisestimablequalitiespasswithhisclothesandarmstothemurderer:
butIhaveneverheardthatitwastheopinionofanysavageScythian,that,ifhekillsabrothervillain,heis,ipsofacto,absolvedofallhisownoffences。TheTartariandoctrineisthemosttenableopinion。ThemurderersofRobespierre,besideswhattheyareentitledtobybeingengagedinthesametontineofinfamy,arehisrepresentatives,haveinheritedallhismurderousqualitiesinadditiontotheirownprivatestock。Butitseemswearealwaystobeofapartywiththelastandvictoriousassassins。IconfessIamofadifferentmind,andamratherinclined,ofthetwo,tothinkandspeaklesshardlyofadeadruffian,thantoassociatewiththeliving。Icouldbetterbearthestenchofthegibbetedmurdererthanthesocietyofthebloodyfelonswhoyetannoytheworld。Whilsttheywaittherecompenseduetotheirancientcrimes,theymeritnewpunishmentbythenewoffencestheycommit。ThereisaperiodtotheoffencesofRobespierre。Theysurviveinhisassassins。Betteralivingdog,saystheoldproverb,thanadeadlion;notsohere。
Murderersandhogsneverlookwelltilltheyarehanged。Fromvillanynogoodcanarise,butintheexampleofitsfate。SoIleavethemtheirdeadRobespierre,eithertogibbethismemory,ortodeifyhimintheirPantheonwiththeirMaratandtheirMirabeau。
ACCUMULATION,ASTATEPRINCIPLE。
Theremustbesomeimpulsebesidespublicspirittoputprivateinterestintomotionalongwithit。Moniedmenoughttobeallowedtosetavalueontheirmoney;iftheydidnot,therecouldbenomoniedmen。Thisdesireofaccumulationisaprinciplewithoutwhichthemeansoftheirservicetothestatecouldnotexist。Theloveoflucre,thoughsometimescarriedtoaridiculous,sometimestoaviciousexcess,isthegrandcauseofprosperitytoallstates。Inthisnatural,thisreasonable,thispowerful,thisprolificprinciple,itisforthesatiristtoexposetheridiculous:itisforthemoralisttocensurethevicious;itisforthesympathetichearttoreprobatethehardandcruel;itisforthejudgetoanimadvertonthefraud,theextortion,andtheoppression;butitisforthestatesmantoemployitashefindsit,withallitsconcomitantexcellencies,withallitsimperfectionsonitshead。Itishispart,inthiscase,asitisinallothercaseswhereheistomakeuseofthegeneralenergiesofnature,totakethemashefindsthem。
WARNINGFORANATION。
Withallthesecausesofcorruption,wemaywelljudgewhatthegeneralfashionofmindwillbethroughbothsexesandallconditions。Suchspectaclesandsuchexampleswilloverbearallthelawsthateverblackenedthecumbrousvolumesofourstatutes。Whenroyaltyshallhavedisavoweditself;whenitshallhaverelaxedalltheprinciplesofitsownsupport;whenithasrenderedthesystemofregicidefashionable,andreceiveditastriumphantintheverypersonswhohaveconsolidatedthatsystembytheperpetrationofeverycrime;whohavenotonlymassacredtheprince,buttheverylawsandmagistrateswhichwerethesupportofroyalty,andslaughtered,withanindiscriminateproscription,withoutregardtoeithersexorage,everypersonthatwassuspectedofaninclinationtoking,law,ormagistracy,——Isay,willanyonedaretobeloyal?Willanyonepresume,againstbothauthorityandopinion,toholdupthisunfashionable,antiquated,explodedconstitution?TheJacobinfactioninEnglandmustgrowinstrengthandaudacity;itwillbesupportedbyotherintrigues,andsuppliedbyotherresourcesthanyetwehaveseeninaction。Confoundedatitsgrowth,thegovernmentmayflytoparliamentforitssupport。Butwhowillanswerforthetemperofahouseofcommonselectedunderthesecircumstances?
Whowillanswerforthecourageofahouseofcommonstoarmthecrownwiththeextraordinarypowersthatitmaydemand?Buttheministerswillnotventuretoaskhalfofwhattheyknowtheywant。Theywilllosehalfofthathalfinthecontest:andwhentheyhaveobtainedtheirnothing,theywillbedrivenbythecriesoffactioneithertodemolishthefeebleworkstheyhavethrownupinahurry,or,ineffect,toabandonthem。AstotheHouseofLords,itisnotworthmentioning。Thepeersoughtnaturallytobethepillarsofthecrown;butwhentheirtitlesarerenderedcontemptible,andtheirpropertyinvidious,andapartoftheirweakness,andnotoftheirstrength,theywillbefoundsomanydegradedandtremblingindividuals,whowillseekbyevasiontoputofftheevildayoftheirruin。Bothhouseswillbeinperpetualoscillationbetweenabortiveattemptsatenergy,andstillmoreunsuccessfulattemptsatcompromise。Youwillbeimpatientofyourdisease,andabhorrentofyourremedy。Aspiritofsubterfugeandatoneofapologywillenterintoallyourproceedings,whetheroflaworlegislation。
Yourjudges,whonowsustainsomasculineanauthority,willappearmoreontheirtrialthantheculpritstheyhavebeforethem。Theawfulfrownofcriminaljusticewillbesmoothedintothesillysmileofseduction。
Judgeswillthinktoinsinuateandsoothetheaccusedintoconvictionandcondemnation,andtowheedletothegallowsthemostartfulofalldelinquents。Buttheywillnotbesowheedled。Theywillnotsubmiteventotheappearanceofpersonsontheirtrial。Theirclaimtothisexceptionwillbeadmitted。Theplaceinwhichsomeofthegreatestnameswhicheverdistinguishedthehistoryofthiscountryhavestood,willappearbeneaththeirdignity。Thecriminalwillclimbfromthedocktotheside-bar,andtakehisplaceandhisteawiththecounsel。Fromthebarofthecounsel,byanaturalprogress,hewillascendtothebench,whichlongbeforehadbeenvirtuallyabandoned。Theywhoescapefromjusticewillnotsufferaquestionuponreputation。Theywilltakethecrownofthecauseway:theywillbereveredasmartyrs;theywilltriumphasconquerors。Nobodywilldaretocensurethatpopularpartofthetribunal,whoseonlyrestraintonmisjudgmentisthecensureofthepublic。Theywhofindfaultwiththedecisionwillberepresentedasenemiestotheinstitution。Juriesthatconvictforthecrownwillbeloadedwithobloquy。Thejurieswhoacquitwillbeheldupasmodelsofjustice。Ifparliamentordersaprosecution,andfails(asfailitwill),itwillbetreatedtoitsfaceasguiltyofaconspiracymaliciouslytoprosecute。Itscareindiscoveringaconspiracyagainstthestatewillbetreatedasaforgedplottodestroythelibertyofthesubject;everysuchdiscovery,insteadofstrengtheninggovernment,willweakenitsreputation。
Inthisstatethingswillbesufferedtoproceed,lestmeasuresofvigourshouldprecipitateacrisis。Thetimidwillactthusfromcharacter;thewisefromnecessity。Ourlawshaddoneallthattheoldconditionofthingsdictatedtorenderourjudgeserectandindependent;
buttheywillnaturallyfailonthesideuponwhichtheyhadtakennoprecautions。Thejudicialmagistrateswillfindthemselvessafeasagainstthecrown,whosewillisnottheirtenure;thepowerofexecutingtheirofficewillbeheldatthepleasureofthosewhodealoutfameorabuseastheythinkfit。Theywillbeginrathertoconsulttheirownreposeandtheirownpopularity,thanthecriticalandperiloustrustthatisintheirhands。Theywillspeculateonconsequenceswhentheyseeatcourtanambassadorwhoserobesarelinedwithascarletdyedinthebloodofjudges。Itisnowonder,noraretheytoblame,whentheyaretoconsiderhowtheyshallanswerfortheirconducttothecriminalofto?dayturnedintothemagistrateofto-morrow。
SANTERREANDTALLIEN。
Isitonlyanoppressivenightmarewithwhichwehavebeenloaded?Isitthenallafrightfuldream,andaretherenoregicidesintheworld?
Havewenotheardofthatprodigyofaruffian,whowouldnotsufferhisbenignantsovereign,withhishandstiedbehindhim,andstrippedforexecution,tosayonepartingwordtohisdeludedpeople;——ofSanterre,whocommandedthedrumsandtrumpetstostrikeuptostiflehisvoice,anddraggedhimbackwardtothemachineofmurder?Thisnefariousvillain(forafewdaysImaycallhimso)standshighinFrance,asinarepublicofrobbersandmurderersheought。Whathindersthismonsterfrombeingsentasambassadortoconveytohismajestythefirstcomplimentsofhisbrethren,theregicideDirectory?Theyhavenonethatcanrepresentthemmoreproperly。Ianticipatethedayofhisarrival。
HewillmakehispublicentryintoLondonononeofthepalehorsesofhisbrewery。AsheknowsthatwearepleasedwiththeParistastefortheordersofknighthood,hewillflingabloodysashacrosshisshoulderswiththeorderoftheHolyGuillotine,surmountingtheCrown,appendanttotheriband。Thusadorned,hewillproceedfromWhitechapeltothefurtherendofPallMall,allthemusicofLondonplayingtheMarseillaishymnbeforehim,andescortedbyachosendetachmentoftheLegiondel’Echaffaud。Itwereonlytobewished,thatnoill-fatedloyalistfortheimprudenceofhiszealmaystandinthepilloryatCharingCross,underthestatueofKingCharlestheFirst,atthetimeofthisgrandprocession,lestsomeoftherotteneggs,whichtheconstitutionalsocietyshallletflyathisindiscreethead,mayhitthevirtuousmurdererofhisking。Theymightsoilthestatedress,whichtheministersofsomanycrownedheadshaveadmired,andinwhichSirClementCotterelistointroducehimatSt。James’s。
IfSanterrecannotbesparedfromtheconstitutionalbutcheriesathome,Tallienmaysupplyhisplace,and,inpointoffigure,withadvantage。
Hehasbeenhabituatedtocommissions;andheisaswellqualifiedasSanterreforthis。NerowishedtheRomanpeoplehadbutoneneck。ThewishofthemoreexaltedTallien,whenhesatinjudgment,was,thathissovereignhadeighty-threeheads,thathemightsendonetoeveryoneofthedepartments。TallienwillmakeanexcellentfigureatGuildhallatthenextsheriff’sfeast。HemayopentheballwithmyLadyMayoress。
Butthiswillbeafterhehasretiredfromthepublictable,andgoneintotheprivateroomfortheenjoymentofmoresocialandunreservedconversationwiththeministersofstateandthejudgesofthebench。
TheretheseministersandmagistrateswillhearhimentertaintheworthyaldermenwithaninstructingandpleasingnarrativeofthemannerinwhichhemadetherichcitizensofBordeauxsqueak,andgentlyledthembythepubliccreditoftheguillotinetodisgorgetheiranti-revolutionarypelf。
Allthiswillbethedisplay,andthetown-talk,whenourregicideisonavisitofceremony。AthomenothingwillequalthepompandsplendouroftheHoteldelaRepublique。Thereanothersceneofgaudygrandeurwillbeopened。Whenhiscitizenexcellencykeepsthefestival,whicheverycitizenisorderedtoobserve,forthegloriousexecutionofLouistheSixteenth,andrenewshisoathofdetestationofkings,agrandball,ofcourse,willbegivenontheoccasion。Thenwhatahurly-burly;——whatacrowding;——whataglareofathousandflambeauxinthesquare;——whataclamouroffootmencontendingatthedoor;——whatarattlingofathousandcoachesofduchesses,countesses,andLadyMarys,chokingtheway,andoverturningeachother,inastrugglewhoshouldbefirsttopayhercourttotheCitoyenne,thespouseofthetwenty-firsthusband,hethehusbandofthethirty-firstwife,andtohailherintherankofhonourablematrons,beforethefourdays’durationofmarriageisexpired!——Morals,astheywere:——decorum,thegreatoutguardofthesex,andtheproudsentimentofhonour,whichmakesvirtuemorerespectablewhereitis,andconcealshumanfrailtywherevirtuemaynotbe,willbebanishedfromthislandofpropriety,modesty,andreserve。
SIRSYDNEYSMITH。
Thisofficerhavingattempted,withgreatgallantry,tocutoutavesselfromoneoftheenemy’sharbours,wastakenafteranobstinateresistance,suchasobtainedhimthemarkedrespectofthosewhowerewitnessesofhisvalour,andknewthecircumstancesinwhichitwasdisplayed。UponhisarrivalatParis,hewasinstantlythrownintoprison;wherethenatureofhissituationwillbestbeunderstood,byknowing,thatamongstitsMITIGATIONS,wasthepermissiontowalkoccasionallyinthecourt,andtoenjoytheprivilegeofshavinghimself。Ontheoldsystemoffeelingsandprinciples,hissufferingsmighthavebeenentitledtoconsideration,andeveninacomparisonwiththoseofcitizenLaFayette,toapriorityintheorderofcompassion。Iftheministershadneglectedtotakeanystepsinhisfavour,adeclarationofthesenseoftheHouseofCommonswouldhavestimulatedthemtotheirduty。Iftheyhadcausedarepresentationtobemade,suchaproceedingwouldhaveaddedforcetoit。Ifreprisalshouldbethoughtadvisable,theaddressoftheHousewouldhavegivenanadditionalsanctiontoameasurewhichwouldhavebeen,indeed,justifiablewithoutanyothersanctionthanitsownreason。
But,no。Nothingatalllikeit。Infact,themeritofSirSydneySmith,andhisclaimonBritishcompassion,wasofakindaltogetherdifferentfromthatwhichinterestedsodeeplytheauthorsofthemotioninfavourofcitizenLaFayette。Inmyhumbleopinion,CaptainSirSydneySmithhasanothersortofmeritwiththeBritishnation,andsomethingofahigherclaimonBritishhumanity,thancitizenLaFayette。Faithful,zealous,andardent,intheserviceofhiskingandcountry;fullofspirit;fullofresources;goingoutofthebeatenroad,butgoingright,becausehisuncommonenterprisewasnotconductedbyavulgarjudgment;——inhisprofession,SirSydneySmithmightbeconsideredasadistinguishedperson,ifanypersoncouldwellbedistinguishedinaserviceinwhichscarcelyacommandercanbenamedwithoutputtingyouinmindofsomeactionofintrepidity,skill,andvigilance,thathasgiventhemafairtitletocontendwithanymen,andinanyage。ButIwillsaynothingfartherofthemeritsofSirSydneySmith:themortalanimosityoftheregicideenemysupersedesallotherpanegyric。Theirhatredisajudgmentinhisfavourwithoutappeal。AtpresentheislodgedinthetoweroftheTemple,thelastprisonofLouistheSixteenth,andthelastbutoneofMariaAntoniettaofAustria;theprisonofLouistheSeventeenth;theprisonofElizabethofBourbon。Therehelies,unpitiedbythegrandphilanthropy,tomeditateuponthefateofthosewhoarefaithfultotheirkingandcountry。Whilstthisprisoner,secludedfromintercourse,wasindulginginthesecheeringreflections,hemightpossiblyhavehadthefurtherconsolationoflearning(bymeansoftheinsolentexultationofhisguards),thattherewasanEnglishambassadoratParis;hemighthavehadtheproudcomfortofhearing,thatthisambassadorhadthehonourofpassinghismorningsinrespectfulattendanceattheofficeofaregicidepettifogger;andthatintheeveningherelaxedintheamusementsoftheopera,andinthespectacleofanaudiencetotallynew;anaudienceinwhichhehadthepleasureofseeingabouthimnotasinglefacethathecouldformerlyhaveknowninParis;butintheplaceofthatcompany,oneindeedmorethanequaltoitindisplayofgaiety,splendour,andluxury;asetofabandonedwretches,squanderingininsolentriotthespoilsoftheirbleedingcountry。A
subjectofprofoundreflectionbothtotheprisonerandtotheambassador。
AMORALDISTINCTION。
Ithinkwemighthavefound,beforetherudehandofinsolentofficewasonourshoulder,andthestaffofusurpedauthoritybrandishedoverourheads,thatcontemptofthesuppliantisnotthebestforwarderofasuit;thatnationaldisgraceisnotthehighroadtosecurity,muchlesstopowerandgreatness。Patience,indeed,stronglyindicatestheloveofpeace;butmerelovedoesnotalwaysleadtoenjoyment。Itisthepowerofwinningthatpalmwhichensuresourwearingit。Virtueshavetheirplace;andoutoftheirplacetheyhardlydeservethename。Theypassintotheneighbouringvice。Thepatienceoffortitudeandtheenduranceofpusillanimityarethingsverydifferent,asintheirprinciple,sointheireffects。
INFIDELSANDTHEIRPOLICY。
IntherevolutionofFrancetwosortsofmenwereprincipallyconcernedingivingacharacteranddeterminationtoitspursuits:thephilosophersandthepoliticians。Theytookdifferentways,buttheymetinthesameend。Thephilosophershadonepredominantobject,whichtheypursuedwithafanaticalfury;thatis,theutterextirpationofreligion。Tothateveryquestionofempirewassubordinate。TheyhadratherdomineerinaparishofatheiststhanruleoveraChristianworld。Theirtemporalambitionwaswhollysubservienttotheirproselytizingspirit,inwhichtheywerenotexceededbyMahomethimself。Theywhohavemadebutsuperficialstudiesinthenaturalhistoryofthehumanmind,havebeentaughttolookonreligiousopinionsastheonlycauseofenthusiasticzealandsectarianpropagation。Butthereisnodoctrinewhatever,onwhichmencanwarm,thatisnotcapableoftheverysameeffect。Thesocialnatureofmanimpelshimtopropagatehisprinciples,asmuchasphysicalimpulsesurgehimtopropagatehiskind。Thepassionsgivezealandvehemence。
Theunderstandingbestowsdesignandsystem。Thewholemanmovesunderthedisciplineofhisopinions。Religionisamongthemostpowerfulcausesofenthusiasm。Whenanythingconcerningitbecomesanobjectofmuchmeditation,itcannotbeindifferenttothemind。Theywhodonotlovereligion,hateit。TherebelstoGodperfectlyabhortheauthoroftheirbeing。Theyhatehim“withalltheirheart,withalltheirmind,withalltheirsoul,andwithalltheirstrength。”Heneverpresentshimselftotheirthoughts,buttomenaceandalarmthem。Theycannotstrikethesunoutofheaven,buttheyareabletoraiseasmoulderingsmokethatobscureshimfromtheirowneyes。NotbeingabletorevengethemselvesonGod,theyhaveadelightinvicariouslydefacing,degrading,torturing,andtearinginpieceshisimageinman。Letnoonejudgeofthembywhathehasconceivedofthem,whentheywerenotincorporated,andhadnolead。Theywerethenonlypassengersinacommonvehicle。Theywerethencarriedalongwiththegeneralmotionofreligioninthecommunity,and,withoutbeingawareofit,partookofitsinfluence。Inthatsituation,atworst,theirnaturewasleftfreetocounter-worktheirprinciples。Theydespairedofgivinganyverygeneralcurrencytotheiropinions。Theyconsideredthemasareservedprivilegeforthechosenfew。Butwhenthepossibilityofdominion,lead,andpropagation,presenteditself,andthattheambition,whichbeforehadsooftenmadethemhypocrites,mightrathergainthanlosebyadaringavowaloftheirsentiments,thenthenatureofthisinfernalspirit,whichhas“evilforitsgood,“appearedinitsfullperfection。
Nothingindeedbutthepossessionofsomepowercanwithanycertaintydiscoverwhatatthebottomisthetruecharacterofanyman。WithoutreadingthespeechesofVergniaud,FrancianofNantes,Isnard,andsomeothersofthatsort,itwouldnotbeeasytoconceivethepassion,rancour,andmaliceoftheirtonguesandhearts。Theyworkedthemselvesuptoaperfectfrenzyagainstreligionandallitsprofessors。Theytorethereputationoftheclergytopiecesbytheirinfuriateddeclamationsandinvectives,beforetheylaceratedtheirbodiesbytheirmassacres。Thisfanaticalatheismleftout,weomittheprincipalfeatureintheFrenchrevolution,andaprincipalconsiderationwithregardtotheeffectstobeexpectedfromapeacewithit。
Theothersortofmenwerethepoliticians。Tothem,whohadlittleornotatallreflectedonthesubject,religionwasinitselfnoobjectofloveorhatred。Theydisbelievedit,andthatwasall。Neutralwithregardtothatobject,theytookthesidewhichinthepresentstateofthingsmightbestanswertheirpurposes。Theysoonfoundthattheycouldnotdowithoutthephilosophers;andthephilosopherssoonmadethemsensiblethatthedestructionofreligionwastosupplythemwithmeansofconquest,firstathome,andthenabroad。Thephilosophersweretheactiveinternalagitators,andsuppliedthespiritandprinciples:thesecondgavethepracticaldirection。Sometimestheonepredominatedinthecomposition,sometimestheother。Theonlydifferencebetweenthemwasinthenecessityofconcealingthegeneraldesignforatime,andintheirdealingwithforeignnations;thefanaticsgoingstraightforwardandopenly,thepoliticiansbythesurermodeofzigzag。Inthecourseofevents,this,amongothercauses,producedfierceandbloodycontentionsbetweenthem。Butatthebottomtheythoroughlyagreedinalltheobjectsofambitionandirreligion,andsubstantiallyinallthemeansofpromotingtheseends。
WHATAMINISTERSHOULDATTEMPT。
Aftersuchanelaboratedisplayhadbeenmadeoftheinjusticeandinsolenceofanenemy,whoseemstohavebeenirritatedbyeveryoneofthemeanswhichhadbeencommonlyusedwitheffecttosoothetherageofintemperatepower,thenaturalresultwouldbe,thatthescabbard,inwhichweinvainattemptedtoplungeoursword,shouldhavebeenthrownawaywithscorn。Itwouldhavebeennaturalthat,risinginthefulnessoftheirmight,insultedmajesty,despiseddignity,violatedjustice,rejectedsupplication,patiencegoadedintofury,wouldhavepouredoutallthelengthofthereinsuponallthewrathwhichtheyhadsolongrestrained。Itmighthavebeenexpectedthat,emulousofthegloryoftheyouthfulheroinalliancewithhim,touchedbytheexampleofwhatoneman,wellformedandwellplaced,maydointhemostdesperatestateofaffairs,convincedthereisacourageofthecabinetfullaspowerful,andfarlessvulgarthanthatofthefield,ourministerwouldhavechangedthewholelineofthatuseless,prosperousprudence,whichhadhithertoproducedalltheeffectsoftheblindesttemerity。Ifhefoundhissituationfullofdanger(andIdonotdenythatitisperilousintheextreme),hemustfeelthatitisalsofullofglory;andthatheisplacedonastage,thanwhichnomuseoffirethathadascendedthehighestheavenofinventioncouldimagineanythingmoreawfulandaugust。Itwashopedthat,inthisswellingsceneinwhichhemovedwithsomeofthefirstpotentatesofEuropeforhisfellow-actors,andwithsomanyoftherestfortheanxiousspectatorsofapart,which,asheplaysit,determinesforevertheirdestinyandhisown,likeUlyssesintheunravellingpointoftheepicstory,hewouldhavethrownoffhispatienceandhisragstogether;and,strippedofunworthydisguises,hewouldhavestoodforthintheformandintheattitudeofahero。OnthatdayitwasthoughthewouldhaveassumedtheportofMars;thathewouldbidtobebroughtforthfromtheirhideouskennel(wherehisscrupuloustendernesshadtoolongimmuredthem)thoseimpatientdogsofwar,whosefierceregardsaffrighteventheministerofvengeancethatfeedsthem;thathewouldletthemloose,infamine,fever,plagues,anddeath,uponaguiltyrace,towhoseframe,andtoallwhosehabit,order,peace,religion,andvirtuearealienandabhorrent。Itwasexpectedthathewouldatlasthavethoughtofactiveandeffectualwar;thathewouldnolongeramusetheBritishlioninthechaseofmiceandrats;thathewouldnolongeremploythewholenavalpowerofGreatBritain,oncetheterroroftheworld,topreyuponthemiserableremainsofapeddlingcommerce,whichtheenemydidnotregard,andfromwhichnonecouldprofit。Itwasexpectedthathewouldhavere-assertedthejusticeofhiscause;thathewouldhavere-animatedwhateverremainedtohimofhisallies,andendeavouredtorecoverthosewhomtheirfearshadledastray;thathewouldhaverekindledthemartialardourofhiscitizens;thathewouldhaveheldouttothemtheexampleoftheirancestry,theassertorofEurope,andthescourgeofFrenchambition;
thathewouldhaveremindedthemofaposterity,which,ifthisnefariousrobberyunderthefraudulentnameandfalsecolourofagovernment,shouldinfullpowerbeseatedintheheartofEurope,mustforeverbeconsignedtovice,impiety,barbarism,andthemostignominiousslaveryofbodyandmind。Insoholyacauseitwaspresumedthathewould(asinthebeginningofthewarhedid)haveopenedallthetemples;andwithprayer,withfasting,andwithsupplication(betterdirectedthantothegrimMolochofregicideinFrance),havecalleduponustoraisethatunitedcrywhichhassooftenstormedheaven,andwithapiousviolenceforceddownblessingsuponarepentantpeople。ItwashopedthatwhenhehadinvokeduponhisendeavoursthefavourableregardoftheProtectorofthehumanrace,itwouldbeseenthathismenacestotheenemy,andhisprayerstotheAlmighty,werenotfollowed,butaccompanied,withcorrespondentaction。Itwashopedthathisshrillingtrumpetshouldbeheard,nottoannounceashow,buttosoundacharge。
LAWOFVICINITY。
ThisviolentbreachinthecommunityofEuropewemustconcludetohavebeenmade(eveniftheyhadnotexpresslydeclareditoverandoveragain)eithertoforcemankindintoanadoptionoftheirsystem,ortoliveinperpetualenmitywithacommunitythemostpotentwehaveeverknown。Cananypersonimagine,that,inofferingtomankindthisdesperatealternative,thereisnoindicationofahostilemind,becausemeninpossessionoftherulingauthorityaresupposedtohavearighttoactwithoutcoercionintheirownterritories。Astotherightofmentoactanywhereaccordingtotheirpleasure,withoutanymoraltie,nosuchrightexists。MenareneverinastateofTOTALindependenceofeachother。Itisnottheconditionofournature:norisitconceivablehowanymancanpursueaconsiderablecourseofactionwithoutitshavingsomeeffectuponothers;or,ofcourse,withoutproducingsomedegreeofresponsibilityforhisconduct。TheSITUATIONSinwhichmenrelativelystandproducetherulesandprinciplesofthatresponsibility,andafforddirectionstoprudenceinexactingit。
Distanceofplacedoesnotextinguishthedutiesortherightsofmen;
butitoftenrenderstheirexerciseimpracticable。Thesamecircumstanceofdistancerendersthenoxiouseffectsofanevilsysteminanycommunitylesspernicious。Buttherearesituationswherethisdifficultydoesnotoccur;andinwhich,therefore,thesedutiesareobligatory,andtheserightsaretobeasserted。Ithaseverbeenthemethodofpublicjuriststodrawagreatpartoftheanalogies,onwhichtheyformthelawofnations,fromtheprinciplesoflawwhichprevailincivilcommunity。Civillawsarenotallofthemmerelypositive。
Those,whichareratherconclusionsoflegalreasonthanmattersofstatutableprovision,belongtouniversalequity,andareuniversallyapplicable。Almostthewholepraetorianlawissuch。Thereisa“LawofNeighbourhood“whichdoesnotleaveamanperfectlymasteronhisownground。WhenaneighbourseesaNEWERECTION,inthenatureofanuisance,setupathisdoor,hehasarighttorepresentittothejudge;who,onhispart,hasarighttoordertheworktobestayed;or,ifestablished,toberemoved。Onthisheadtheparentlawisexpressandclear,andhasmademanywiseprovisions,which,withoutdestroying,regulateandrestraintherightofOWNERSHIP,bytherightofVICINAGE。
NoINNOVATIONispermittedthatmayredound,evensecondarily,totheprejudiceofaneighbour。Thewholedoctrineofthatimportantheadofpraetorianlaw,“Denovioperisnunciatione,“isfoundedontheprinciple,thatnoNEWuseshouldbemadeofaman’sprivatelibertyofoperatinguponhisprivateproperty,fromwhenceadetrimentmaybejustlyapprehendedbyhisneighbour。Thislawofdenunciationisprospective。Itistoanticipatewhatiscalleddamnuminfectum,ordamnumnondumfactum,thatis,adamagejustlyapprehended,butnotactuallydone。Evenbeforeitisclearlyknownwhethertheinnovationbedamageableornot,thejudgeiscompetenttoissueaprohibitiontoinnovate,untilthepointcanbedetermined。Thispromptinterferenceisgroundedonprinciplesfavourabletobothparties。Itispreventiveofmischiefdifficulttoberepaired,andofillblooddifficulttobesoftened。Theruleoflaw,therefore,whichcomesbeforetheevil,isamongsttheverybestpartsofequity,andjustifiesthepromptnessoftheremedy;because,asitiswellobserved,Resdamniinfecticeleritatemdesiderat,etpericulosaestdilatio。Thisrightofdenunciationdoesnothold,whenthingscontinue,howeverinconvenientlytotheneighbourhood,accordingtotheANCIENTmode。Forthereisasortofpresumptionagainstnovelty,drawnoutofadeepconsiderationofhumannature,andhumanaffairs;andthemaximofjurisprudenceiswelllaiddown,Vetustasprolegesemperhabetur。
Suchisthelawofcivilvicinity。Nowwherethereisnoconstitutedjudge,asbetweenindependentstatesthereisnot,thevicinageitselfisthenaturaljudge。Itis,preventively,theassertorofitsownrights,orremedially,theiravenger。Neighboursarepresumedtotakecognizanceofeachother’sacts。“Vicinivicinorumfactapraesumunturscire。”Thisprinciple,which,liketherest,isastrueofnationsasofindividualmen,hasbestowedonthegrandvicinageofEuropeadutytoknow,andarighttoprevent,anycapitalinnovationwhichmayamounttotheerectionofadangerousnuisance。
EUROPEANCOMMUNITY。
Theoperationofdangerousanddelusivefirstprinciplesobligesustohaverecoursetothetrueones。Intheintercoursebetweennations,weareapttorelytoomuchontheinstrumentalpart。Welaytoomuchweightupontheformalityoftreatiesandcompacts。Wedonotactmuchmorewiselywhenwetrusttotheinterestsofmenasguaranteesoftheirengagements。Theinterestsfrequentlyteartopiecestheengagements;
andthepassionstrampleuponboth。Entirelytotrusttoeither,istodisregardourownsafety,ornottoknowmankind。Menarenottiedtooneanotherbypapersandseals。Theyareledtoassociatebyresemblances,byconformities,bysympathies。Itiswithnationsaswithindividuals。Nothingissostrongatieofamitybetweennationandnationascorrespondenceinlaws,customs,manners,andhabitsoflife。
Theyhavemorethantheforceoftreatiesinthemselves。Theyareobligationswrittenintheheart。Theyapproximatementomen,withouttheirknowledge,andsometimesagainsttheirintentions。Thesecret,unseen,butirrefragablebondofhabitualintercourseholdsthemtogether,evenwhentheirperverseandlitigiousnaturesetsthemtoequivocate,scuffle,andfight,aboutthetermsoftheirwrittenobligations。Astowar,ifitbethemeansofwrongandviolence,itisthesolemeansofjusticeamongstnations。Nothingcanbanishitfromtheworld。Theywhosayotherwise,intendingtoimposeuponus,donotimposeuponthemselves。Butitisoneofthegreatestobjectsofhumanwisdomtomitigatethoseevilswhichweareunabletoremove。TheconformityandanalogyofwhichIspeak,incapable,likeeverythingelse,ofpreservingperfecttrustandtranquillityamongmen,hasastrongtendencytofacilitateaccommodation,andtoproduceagenerousoblivionoftherancouroftheirquarrels。Withthissimilitude,peaceismoreofpeace,andwarislessofwar。Iwillgofurther。Therehavebeenperiodsoftimeinwhichcommunities,apparentlyinpeacewitheachother,havebeenmoreperfectlyseparatedthan,inlattertimes,manynationsinEuropehavebeeninthecourseoflongandbloodywars。ThecausemustbesoughtinthesimilitudethroughoutEuropeofreligion,laws,andmanners。Atbottom,theseareallthesame。ThewritersonpubliclawhaveoftencalledthisAGGREGATEofnationsacommonwealth。
Theyhadreason。Itisvirtuallyonegreatstatehavingthesamebasisofgenerallaw,withsomediversityofprovincialcustomsandlocalestablishments。ThenationsofEuropehavehadtheverysameChristianreligion,agreeinginthefundamentalparts,varyingalittleintheceremoniesandinthesubordinatedoctrines。ThewholeofthepolityandeconomyofeverycountryinEuropehasbeenderivedfromthesamesources。ItwasdrawnfromtheoldGermanicorGothiccustumary,fromthefeudalinstitutionswhichmustbeconsideredasanemanationfromthatcustumary;andthewholehasbeenimprovedanddigestedintosystemanddisciplinebytheRomanlaw。Fromhencearosetheseveralorders,withorwithoutamonarch(whicharecalledstates),ineveryEuropeancountry;thestrongtracesofwhich,wheremonarchypredominated,wereneverwhollyextinguishedormergedindespotism。Inthefewplaceswheremonarchywascastoff,thespiritofEuropeanmonarchywasstillleft。Thosecountriesstillcontinuedcountriesofstates;thatis,ofclasses,orders,anddistinctionssuchashadbeforesubsisted,ornearlyso。Indeed,theforceandformoftheinstitutioncalledstatescontinuedingreaterperfectioninthoserepublicancommunitiesthanundermonarchies。Fromallthosesourcesaroseasystemofmannersandofeducationwhichwasnearlysimilarinallthisquarteroftheglobe;
andwhichsoftened,blended,andharmonizedthecoloursofthewhole。
PERILSOFJACOBINPEACE。
ThesametemperwhichbringsustosolicitaJacobinpeace,willinduceustotemporizewithalltheevilsofit。Bydegreesourmindswillbemadetoourcircumstances。Thenoveltyofsuchthings,whichproduceshalfthehorror,andallthedisgust,willbewornoff。Ourruinwillbedisguisedinprofit,andthesaleofafewwretchedbaubleswillbribeadegeneratepeopletobarterawaythemostpreciousjeweloftheirsouls。Ourconstitutionisnotmadeforthiskindofwarfare。Itprovidesgreatlyforourhappiness,——itfurnishesfewmeansforourdefence。Itisformed,inagreatmeasure,upontheprincipleofjealousyofthecrown;and,asthingsstoodwhenittookthatturn,withverygreatreason。Igofurther;itmustkeepalivesomepartofthatfireofjealousyeternallyandchastelyburning,oritcannotbetheBritishconstitution。Atvariousperiodswehavehadtyrannyinthiscountry,morethanenough。Wehavehadrebellions,withmoreorlessjustification。Someofourkingshavemadeadulterousconnectionsabroad,andtruckedawayforforeigngoldtheinterestsandgloryoftheircrown。Butbeforethistimeourlibertyhasneverbeencorrupted。Imeantosay,thatithasneverbeendebauchedfromitsdomesticrelations。TothistimeithasbeenEnglishliberty,andEnglishlibertyonly。Ourloveoflibertyandourloveofourcountrywerenotdistinctthings。Libertyisnow,itseems,putuponalargerandmoreliberalbottom。Wearemen,andasmen,undoubtedlynothinghumanisforeigntous。Wecannotbetooliberalinourgeneralwishesforthehappinessofourkind。Butinallquestionsonthemodeofprocuringitforanyparticularcommunity,weoughttobefearfulofadmittingthosewhohavenointerestinit,orwhohave,perhaps,aninterestagainstit,intotheconsultation。Aboveall,wecannotbetoocautiousinourcommunicationwiththosewhoseektheirhappinessbyotherroadsthanthoseofhumanity,morals,andreligion,andwhoselibertyconsists,andconsistsalone,inbeingfreefromthoserestraintswhichareimposedbythevirtuesuponthepassions。
Whenweinvitedangerfromaconfidenceindefensivemeasures,weought,firstofall,tobesurethatitisaspeciesofdangeragainstwhichanydefensivemeasuresthatcanbeadoptedwillbesufficient。Nextweoughttoknowthatthespiritofourlaws,orthatourowndispositions,whicharestrongerthanlaws,aresusceptibleofallthosedefensivemeasureswhichtheoccasionmayrequire。Athirdconsiderationis,whetherthesemeasureswillnotbringmoreodiumthanstrengthtogovernment;andthelast,whethertheauthoritythatmakesthem,inageneralcorruptionofmannersandprinciples,caninsuretheirexecution?Letnoonearguefromthestateofthings,asheseesthematpresent,concerningwhatwillbethemeansandcapacitiesofgovernment,whenthetimearrives,whichshallcallforremediescommensuratetoenormousevils。
Itisanobvioustruththatnoconstitutioncandefenditself:itmustbedefendedbythewisdomandfortitudeofmen。Thesearewhatnoconstitutioncangive:theyarethegiftsofGod;andhealoneknowswhetherweshallpossesssuchgiftsatthetimewhenwestandinneedofthem。Constitutionsfurnishthecivilmeansofgettingatthenatural;
itisallthatinthiscasetheycando。Butourconstitutionhasmoreimpedimentsthanhelps。Itsexcellencies,whentheycometobeputtothissortofproof,maybefoundamongitsdefects。
Nothinglooksmoreawfulandimposingthananancientfortification。Itslofty,embattledwalls,itsbold,projecting,roundedtowers,thatpiercethesky,striketheimagination,andpromiseinexpugnablestrength。Buttheyaretheverythingsthatmakeitsweakness。YoumayaswellthinkofopposingoneoftheseoldfortressestothemassofartillerybroughtbyaFrenchirruptionintothefield,astothinkofresisting,byyouroldlaws,andyouroldforms,thenewdestructionwhichthecorpsofJacobinengineersofto-dayprepareforallsuchformsandallsuchlaws。Besidesthedebilityandfalseprincipleoftheirconstructiontoresistthepresentmodesofattack,thefortressitselfisinruinousrepair,andthereisapracticablebreachineverypartofit。
Suchisthework。Butmiserableworkshavebeendefendedbytheconstancyofthegarrison。Weather-beatenshipshavebeenbroughtsafetoportbythespiritandalertnessofthecrew。Butitisherethatweshalleminentlyfail。Thedaythat,bytheirconsent,theseatofregicidehasitsplaceamongthethronesofEurope,thereisnolongeramotiveforzealintheirfavour;itwillatbestbecold,unimpassioned,dejected,melancholyduty。Theglorywillseemallontheotherside。
Thefriendsofthecrownwillappear,notaschampions,butasvictims;
discountenanced,mortified,lowered,defeated,theywillfallintolistlessnessandindifference。Theywillleavethingstotaketheircourse;enjoythepresenthour,andsubmittothecommonfate。
PARLIAMENTARYANDREGALPREROGATIVE。
Yourthronecannotstandsecureupontheprinciplesofunconditionalsubmissionandpassiveobedience;onpowersexercisedwithouttheconcurrenceofthepeopletobegoverned;onactsmadeindefianceoftheirprejudicesandhabits;onacquiescenceprocuredbyforeignmercenarytroops,andsecuredbystandingarmies。Thesemaypossiblybethefoundationofotherthrones:,theymustbethesubversionofyours。Itwasnottopassiveprinciplesinourancestorsthatweowethehonourofappearingbeforeasovereign,whocannotfeelthatheisaprince,withoutknowingthatweoughttobefree。Therevolutionisadeparturefromtheancientcourseofthedescentofthismonarchy。Thepeopleatthattimere-enteredintotheiroriginalrights;anditwasnotbecauseapositivelawauthorizedwhatwasthendone,butbecausethefreedomandsafetyofthesubject,theoriginandcauseofalllaws,requiredaproceedingparamountandsuperiortothem。Atthatever-memorableandinstructiveperiod,theletterofthelawwassupersededinfavourofthesubstanceofliberty。Tothefreechoice,therefore,ofthepeople,withouteitherkingorparliament,weowethathappyestablishment,outofwhichbothkingandparliamentwereregenerated。Fromthatgreatprincipleoflibertyhaveoriginatedthestatutes,confirmingandratifyingtheestablishment,fromwhichyourmajestyderivesyourrighttoruleoverus。Thosestatuteshavenotgivenusourliberties;ourlibertieshaveproducedthem。Everyhourofyourmajesty’sreignyourtitlestandsupontheverysamefoundationonwhichitwasatfirstlaid;andwedonotknowabetteronwhichitcanpossiblybeplaced。
Convinced,sir,thatyoucannothavedifferentrightsandadifferentsecurityindifferentpartsofyourdominions,wewishtolayanevenplatformforyourthrone;andtogiveitanunmovablestability,bylayingitonthegeneralfreedomofyourpeople;andbysecuringtoyourmajestythatconfidenceandaffectioninallpartsofyourdominions,whichmakesyourbestsecurityanddearesttitleinthisthechiefseatofyourempire。
Such,sir,beingamongstusthefoundationofmonarchyitself,muchmoreclearlyandmuchmorepeculiarlyisitthegroundofallparliamentarypower。Parliamentisasecurityprovidedfortheprotectionoffreedom,andnotasubtilefiction,contrivedtoamusethepeopleinitsplace。
Theauthorityofbothhousescan,stilllessthanthatofthecrown,besupportedupondifferentprinciplesindifferentplaces,soastobe,foronepartofyoursubjects,aprotectorofliberty,andforanotherafundofdespotism,throughwhichprerogativeisextendedbyoccasionalpowers,wheneveranarbitrarywillfindsitselfstraitenedbytherestrictionsoflaw。Haditseemedgoodtoparliamenttoconsideritselfastheindulgentguardianandstrongprotectorofthefreedomofthesubordinatepopularassemblies,insteadofexercisingitspowertotheirannihilation,thereisnodoubtthatitnevercouldhavebeentheirinclination,becausenottheirinterest,toraisequestionsontheextentofparliamentaryrights,ortoenfeebleprivilegeswhichwerethesecurityoftheirown。Powersevidentfromnecessity,andnotsuspiciousfromanalarmingmodeorpurposeintheexertion,would,asformerlytheywere,becheerfullysubmittedto;andthesewouldhavebeenfullysufficientforconservationofunityintheempire,andfordirectingitswealthtoonecommoncentre。Anotherusehasproducedotherconsequences;andapowerwhichrefusestobelimitedbymoderationmusteitherbelost,orfindothermoredistinctandsatisfactorylimitations。
BURKE’SDESIGNINHISGREATESTWORK。
Hehadundertakentodemonstratebyargumentswhichhethoughtcouldnotberefuted,andbydocumentswhichhewassurecouldnotbedenied,thatnocomparisonwastobemadebetweentheBritishgovernmentandtheFrenchusurpation。Thattheywhoendeavouredmadlytocomparethem,werebynomeansmakingthecomparisonofonegoodsystemwithanothergoodsystem,whichvariedonlyinlocalandcircumstantialdifferences;muchless,thattheywereholdingouttousasuperiorpatternoflegalliberty,whichwemightsubstituteintheplaceofourold,and,astheydescribedit,superannuatedconstitution。HemeanttodemonstratethattheFrenchschemewasnotacomparativegood,butapositiveevil。Thatthequestiondidnotatallturn,ashadbeenstated,onaparallelbetweenamonarchyandarepublic。HedeniedthatthepresentschemeofthingsinFrancedidatalldeservetherespectablenameofarepublic:hehadthereforenocomparisonbetweenmonarchiesandrepublicstomake。ThatwhatwasdoneinFrancewasawildattempttomethodizeanarchy;toperpetuateandfixdisorder。Thatitwasafoul,impious,monstrousthing,whollyoutofthecourseofmoralnature。Heundertooktoprovethatitwasgeneratedintreachery,fraud,falsehood,hypocrisy,andunprovokedmurder。Heofferedtomakeoutthatthosewhohadledinthatbusinesshadconductedthemselveswiththeutmostperfidytotheircolleaguesinfunction,andwiththemostflagrantperjurybothtowardstheirkingandtheirconstituents;totheoneofwhomtheAssemblyhadswornfealty,andtotheother,whenundernosortofviolenceorconstraint,theyhadswornafullobediencetoinstructions——That,bytheterrorofassassination,theyhaddrivenawayaverygreatnumberofthemembers,soastoproduceafalseappearanceofamajority——Thatthisfictitiousmajorityhadfabricatedaconstitution,which,asnowitstands,isatyrannyfarbeyondanyexamplethatcanbefoundinthecivilizedEuropeanworldofourage;thatthereforetheloversofitmustbelovers,notofliberty,butiftheyreallyunderstanditsnature,ofthelowestandbasestofallservitude。
HeproposedtoprovethatthepresentstateofthingsinFranceisnotatransientevil,productive,assomehavetoofavourablyrepresentedit,ofalastinggood;butthatthepresentevilisonlythemeansofproducingfutureand(ifthatwerepossible)worseevils——Thatitisnotanundigested,imperfect,andcrudeschemeofliberty,whichmaygraduallybemellowedandripenedintoanorderlyandsocialfreedom;
butthatitissofundamentallywrong,astobeutterlyincapableofcorrectingitselfbyanylengthoftime,orofbeingformedintoanymodeofpolityofwhichamemberoftheHouseofCommonscouldpubliclydeclarehisapprobation。
LORDKEPPEL。
IeverlookedonLordKeppelasoneofthegreatestandbestmenofhisage;andIlovedandcultivatedhimaccordingly。Hewasmuchinmyheart,andIbelieveIwasinhistotheverylastbeat。ItwasathistrialatPortsmouththathegavemethispicture。WithwhatzealandanxiousaffectionIattendedhimthroughthathisagonyofglory,whatpartmysontookintheearlyflushandenthusiasmofhisvirtue,andthepiouspassionwithwhichheattachedhimselftoallmyconnections,withwhatprodigalitywebothsquanderedourselvesincourtingalmosteverysortofenmityforhissake,Ibelievehefelt,justasIshouldhavefeltsuchfriendshiponsuchanoccasion。Ipartookindeedofthishonourwithseveralofthefirst,andbest,andablestinthekingdom,butIwasbehindhandwithnoneofthem;andIamsure,thatiftotheeternaldisgraceofthisnation,andtothetotalannihilationofeverytraceofhonourandvirtueinit,thingshadtakenadifferentturnfromwhattheydid,Ishouldhaveattendedhimtothequarter-deckwithnolessgood-willandmorepride,thoughwithfarotherfeelings,thanI
partookofthegeneralflowofnationaljoythatattendedthejusticethatwasdonetohisvirtue。
Pardon,mylord,thefeeblegarrulityofage,whichlovestodiffuseitselfindiscourseofthedepartedgreat。Atmyyearsweliveinretrospectalone;and,whollyunfittedforthesocietyofvigorouslife,weenjoy,thebestbalmtoallwounds,theconsolationoffriendshipinthoseonlywhomwehavelostforever。FeelingthelossofLordKeppelatalltimes,atnotimedidIfeelitsomuchasonthefirstdaywhenIwasattackedintheHouseofLords。
Hadhelived,thatreverendformwouldhaveriseninitsplace,and,withamild,parentalreprehensiontohisnephewthedukeofBedford,hewouldhavetoldhimthatthefavourofthatgraciousprince,whohadhonouredhisvirtueswiththegovernmentofthenavyofGreatBritain,andwithaseatinthehereditarygreatcouncilofhiskingdom,wasnotundeservedlyshowntothefriendofthebestportionofhislife,andhisfaithfulcompanionandcounsellorunderhisrudesttrials。Hewouldhavetoldhim,thattowhomeverelsethesereproachesmightbebecoming,theywerenotdecorousinhisnearkindred。Hewouldhavetoldhimthatwhenmeninthatranklosedecorumtheyloseeverything。OnthatdayI
hadalossinLordKeppel;butthepubliclossofhiminthisawfulcrisis——!Ispeakfrommuchknowledgeoftheperson,heneverwouldhavelistenedtoanycompromisewiththerabbleroutofthissans-culotterieofFrance。Hisgoodnessofheart,hisreason,histaste,hispublicduty,hisprinciples,hisprejudices,wouldhaverepelledhimforeverfromallconnectionwiththathorridmedleyofmadness,vice,impiety,andcrime。
LordKeppelhadtwocountries;oneofdescent,andoneofbirth。Theirinterestandtheirgloryarethesame;andhismindwascapaciousofboth。Hisfamilywasnoble,anditwasDutch:thatis,hewastheoldestandpurestnobilitythatEuropecanboast,amongapeoplerenownedaboveallothersforloveoftheirnativeland。Thoughitwasnevershownininsulttoanyhumanbeing,LordKeppelwassomethinghigh。Itwasawildstockofpride,onwhichthetenderestofallheartshadgraftedthemildervirtues。Hevaluedancientnobility;andhewasnotdisinclinedtoaugmentitwithnewhonours。Hevaluedtheoldnobilityandthenew,notasanexcuseforinglorioussloth,butasanincitementtovirtuousactivity。Heconsidereditasasortofcureforselfishnessandanarrowmind;conceivingthatamanborninanelevatedplaceinhimselfwasnothing,buteverythinginwhatwentbefore,andwhatwastocomeafterhim。Withoutmuchspeculation,butbythesureinstinctofingenuousfeelings,andbythedictatesofplain,unsophisticated,naturalunderstanding,hefeltthatnogreatcommonwealthcouldbyanypossibilitylongsubsistwithoutabodyofsomekindorotherofnobility,decoratedwithhonour,andfortifiedbyprivilege。Thisnobilityformsthechainthatconnectstheagesofanation,whichotherwise(withMr。Paine)wouldsoonbetaughtthatnoonegenerationcanbindanother。Hefeltthatnopoliticalfabriccouldbewellmadewithoutsomesuchorderofthingsasmight,throughaseriesoftime,affordarationalhopeofsecuringunity,coherence,consistency,andstabilitytothestate。Hefeltthatnothingelsecanprotectitagainstthelevityofcourts,andthegreaterlevityofthemultitude。Thattotalkofhereditarymonarchy,withoutanythingelseofhereditaryreverenceinthecommonwealth,wasalow-mindedabsurdity,fitonlyforthosedetestable“foolsaspiringtobeknaves,“whobegantoforgein1789thefalsemoneyoftheFrenchconstitution——ThatitisonefatalobjectiontoallNEWfanciedandNEWFABRICATEDrepublics(amongapeoplewho,oncepossessingsuchanadvantage,havewickedlyandinsolentlyrejectedit),thatthePREJUDICEofanoldnobilityisathingthatCANNOTbemade。Itmaybeimproved,itmaybecorrected,itmaybereplenished:menmaybetakenfromitoraggregatedtoit,buttheTHINGITSELFismatterofINVETERATEopinion,andthereforeCANNOT
bematterofmerepositiveinstitution。Hefeltthatthisnobilityinfactdoesnotexistinwrongofotherordersofthestate,butbythem,andforthem。
“LABOURINGPOOR。”
Letgovernmentprotectandencourageindustry,secureproperty,repressviolence,anddiscountenancefraud,itisallthattheyhavetodo。Inotherrespects,thelesstheymeddleintheseaffairsthebetter;therestisinthehandsofourMasterandtheirs。Weareinaconstitutionofthingswherein——“Modosolnimius,modocorripitimber。”ButIwillpushthismatternofurther。AsIhavesaidagooddealuponitatvarioustimesduringmypublicservice,andhavelatelywrittensomethingonitwhichmayyetseethelight,Ishallcontentmyselfnowwithobserving,thatthevigorousandlaboriousclassoflifehaslatelygot,fromthebontonofthehumanityofthisday,thenameofthe“labouringpoor。”Wehaveheardmanyplansforthereliefofthe“labouringpoor。”Thispulingjargonisnotasinnocentasitisfoolish。Inmeddlingwithgreataffairs,weaknessisneverinnoxious。
Hithertothenameofpoor(inthesenseinwhichitisusedtoexcitecompassion)hasnotbeenusedforthosewhocan,butforthosewhocannot,labour——forthesickandinfirm,fororphaninfancy,forlanguishinganddecrepitage:butwhenweaffecttopity,aspoor,thosewhomustlabour,ortheworldcannotexist,wearetriflingwiththeconditionofmankind。Itisthecommondoomofmanthathemusteathisbreadbythesweatofhisbrow,thatis,bythesweatofhisbody,orthesweatofhismind。Ifthistoilwasinflictedasacurse,itis,asmightbeexpectedfromthecursesoftheFatherofallblessings——itistemperedwithmanyalleviations,manycomforts。Everyattempttoflyfromit,andtorefusetheverytermsofourexistence,becomesmuchmoretrulyacurse;andheavierpainsandpenaltiesfalluponthosewhowouldeludethetaskswhichareputuponthembythegreatMasterWorkmanoftheworld,who,inhisdealingswithhiscreatures,sympathizeswiththeirweakness,andspeakingofacreationwroughtbymerewilloutofnothing,speaksofsixdaysofLABOURandoneofREST。
Idonotcallahealthyyoungman,cheerfulinhismind,andvigorousinhisarms,IcannotcallsuchamanPOOR;Icannotpitymykindasakind,merelybecausetheyaremen。Thisaffectedpityonlytendstodissatisfythemwiththeircondition,andtoteachthemtoseekresourceswherenoresourcesaretobefound,insomethingelsethantheirownindustry,andfrugality,andsobriety。Whatevermaybetheintention(which,becauseIdonotknow,Icannotdispute)ofthosewhowoulddiscontentmankindbythisstrangepity,theyacttowardsus,intheconsequences,asiftheywereourworstenemies。
STATECONSECRATEDBYTHECHURCH。
Ibegleavetospeakofourchurchestablishment,whichisthefirstofourprejudices,notaprejudicedestituteofreason,butinvolvinginitprofoundandextensivewisdom。Ispeakofitfirst。Itisfirst,andlast,andmidstinourminds。For,takinggroundonthatreligioussystem,ofwhichwearenowinpossession,wecontinuetoactontheearlyreceivedanduniformlycontinuedsenseofmankind。Thatsensenotonly,likeawisearchitect,hathbuiltuptheaugustfabricofstates,butlikeaprovidentproprietor,topreservethestructurefromprofanationandruin,asasacredtemplepurgedfromalltheimpuritiesoffraud,andviolence,andinjustice,andtyranny,hathsolemnlyandforeverconsecratedthecommonwealth,andallthatofficiateinit。
Thisconsecrationismade,thatallwhoadministerinthegovernmentofmen,inwhichtheystandinthepersonofGodhimself,shouldhavehighandworthynotionsoftheirfunctionanddestination;thattheirhopeshouldbefullofimmortality;thattheyshouldnotlooktothepaltrypelfofthemoment,nortothetemporaryandtransientpraiseofthevulgar,buttoasolid,permanentexistence,inthepermanentpartoftheirnature,andtoapermanentfameandglory,intheexampletheyleaveasarichinheritancetotheworld。
Suchsublimeprinciplesoughttobeinfusedintopersonsofexaltedsituations;andreligiousestablishmentsprovided,thatmaycontinuallyreviveandenforcethem。Everysortofmoral,everysortofcivil,everysortofpoliticinstitution,aidingtherationalandnaturaltiesthatconnectthehumanunderstandingandaffectionstothedivine,arenotmorethannecessary,inordertobuildupthatwonderfulstructure,Man;
whoseprerogativeitis,tobeinagreatdegreeacreatureofhisownmaking;andwho,whenmadeasheoughttobemade,isdestinedtoholdnotrivialplaceinthecreation。Butwhenevermanisputovermen,asthebetternatureoughtevertopreside,inthatcasemoreparticularly,heshouldasnearlyaspossiblebeapproximatedtohisperfection。
Theconsecrationofthestate,byastatereligiousestablishment,isnecessaryalsotooperatewithawholesomeaweuponfreecitizens;
becauseinordertosecuretheirfreedom,theymustenjoysomedeterminateportionofpower。Tothemthereforeareligionconnectedwiththestate,andwiththeirdutytowardsit,becomesevenmorenecessarythaninsuchsocieties,wherethepeople,bythetermsoftheirsubjection,areconfinedtoprivatesentiments,andthemanagementoftheirownfamilyconcerns。Allpersonspossessinganyportionofpoweroughttobestronglyandawfullyimpressedwithanideathattheyactintrust;andthattheyaretoaccountfortheirconductinthattrusttotheonegreatMaster,Author,andFounderofsociety。Thisprincipleoughteventobemorestronglyimpresseduponthemindsofthosewhocomposethecollectivesovereignty,thanuponthoseofsingleprinces。Withoutinstruments,theseprincescandonothing。Whoeverusesinstruments,infindinghelps,findsalsoimpediments。Theirpoweristhereforebynomeanscomplete;noraretheysafeinextremeabuse。Suchpersons,howeverelevatedbyflattery,arrogance,andself-opinion,mustbesensiblethatwhethercoveredornotbypositivelaw,insomewayorothertheyareaccountableevenherefortheabuseoftheirtrust。Iftheyarenotcutoffbyarebellionoftheirpeople,theymaybestrangledbytheveryjanissarieskeptfortheirsecurityagainstallotherrebellion。ThuswehaveseenthekingofFrancesoldbyhissoldiersforanincreaseofpay。Butwherepopularauthorityisabsoluteandunrestrained,thepeoplehaveaninfinitelygreater,becauseafarbetterfounded,confidenceintheirownpower。Theyarethemselves,inagreatmeasure,theirowninstruments。Theyarenearertotheirobjects。
Besides,theyarelessunderresponsibilitytooneofthegreatestcontrollingpowersonearth,thesenseoffameandestimation。Theshareofinfamy,thatislikelytofalltothelotofeachindividualinpublicacts,issmallindeed;theoperationofopinionbeingintheinverseratiotothenumberofthosewhoabusepower。Theirownapprobationoftheirownactshastothemtheappearanceofapublicjudgmentintheirfavour。Aperfectdemocracyisthereforethemostshamelessthingintheworld。Asitisthemostshameless,itisalsothemostfearless。Nomanapprehendsinhispersonthathecanbemadesubjecttopunishment。Certainlythepeopleatlargeneverought:forasallpunishmentsareforexampletowardstheconservationofthepeopleatlarge,thepeopleatlargecanneverbecomethesubjectofpunishmentbyanyhumanhand。(Quicquidmultispeccaturinultum。)Itisthereforeofinfiniteimportancethattheyshouldnotbesufferedtoimaginethattheirwill,anymorethanthatofkings,isthestandardofrightandwrong。Theyoughttobepersuadedthattheyarefullaslittleentitled,andfarlessqualified,withsafetytothemselves,touseanyarbitrarypowerwhatsoever;thatthereforetheyarenot,underafalseshowofliberty,butintruth,toexerciseanunnatural,inverteddomination,tyranicallytoexactfromthosewhoofficiateinthestate,notanentiredevotiontotheirinterest,whichistheirright,butanabjectsubmissiontotheiroccasionalwill;extinguishingthereby,inallthosewhoservethem,allmoralprinciple,allsenseofdignity,alluseofjudgment,andallconsistencyofcharacter;whilstbytheverysameprocesstheygivethemselvesupaproper,asuitable,butamostcontemptiblepreytotheservileambitionofpopularsycophants,orcourtlyflatterers。
FATEOFLOUISXVIII。
Letthosewhohavethetrustofpoliticalorofnaturalauthorityeverkeepwatchagainstthedesperateenterprisesofinnovation:leteventheirbenevolencebefortifiedandarmed。Theyhavebeforetheireyestheexampleofamonarch,insulted,degraded,confined,deposed;
hisfamilydispersed,scattered,imprisoned;hiswifeinsultedtohisfacelikethevilestofthesex,bythevilestofallpopulace;
himselfthreetimesdraggedbythesewretchesinaninfamoustriumph;
hischildrentornfromhim,inviolationofthefirstrightofnature,andgivenintothetuitionofthemostdesperateandimpiousoftheleadersofdesperateandimpiousclubs;hisrevenuesdilapidatedandplundered;hismagistratesmurdered;hisclergyproscribed,persecuted,famished;hisnobilitydegradedintheirrank,undoneintheirfortunes,fugitivesintheirpersons;hisarmiescorruptedandruined;hiswholepeopleimpoverished,disunited,dissolved;whilstthroughthebarsofhisprison,andamidstthebayonetsofhiskeepers,hehearsthetumultoftwoconflictingfactions,equallywickedandabandoned,whoagreeinprinciples,indispositions,andinobjects,butwhoteareachothertopiecesaboutthemosteffectualmeansofobtainingtheircommonend;theonecontendingtopreserveforawhilehisname,andhisperson,themoreeasilytodestroytheroyalauthority——theotherclamouringtocutoffthename,theperson,andthemonarchytogether,byonesacrilegiousexecution。Allthisaccumulationofcalamity,thegreatestthateverfellupononeman,hasfallenuponhishead,becausehehadlefthisvirtuesunguardedbycaution;
becausehewasnottaughtthat,wherepowerisconcerned,hewhowillconferbenefitsmusttakesecurityagainstingratitude。
NOBILITY。
AllthisviolentcryagainstthenobilityItaketobeamereworkofart。Tobehonouredandevenprivilegedbythelaws,opinions,andinveterateusagesofourcountry,growingoutoftheprejudiceofages,hasnothingtoprovokehorrorandindignationinanyman。Eventobetootenaciousofthoseprivilegesisnotabsolutelyacrime。Thestrongstruggleineveryindividualtopreservepossessionofwhathehasfoundtobelongtohim,andtodistinguishhim,isoneofthesecuritiesagainstinjusticeanddespotismimplantedinournature。Itoperatesasaninstincttosecureproperty,andtopreservecommunitiesinasettledstate。Whatistheretoshockinthis?Nobilityisagracefulornamenttothecivilorder。ItistheCorinthiancapitalofpolishedsociety。
Omnesboninobilitatisemperfavemus,wasthesayingofawiseandgoodman。Itisindeedonesignofaliberalandbenevolentmindtoinclinetoitwithsomesortofpartialpropensity。Hefeelsnoennoblingprincipleinhisownheartwhowishestolevelalltheartificialinstitutionswhichhavebeenadoptedforgivingabodytoopinion,andpermanencetofugitiveesteem。Itisasour,malignant,enviousdisposition,withouttasteforthereality,orforanyimageorrepresentationofvirtue,thatseeswithjoytheunmeritedfallofwhathadlongflourishedinsplendourandinhonour。Idonotliketoseeanythingdestroyed;anyvoidproducedinsociety;anyruinonthefaceoftheland。ItwasthereforewithnodisappointmentordissatisfactionthatmyinquiriesandobservationsdidnotpresenttomeanyincorrigiblevicesinthenoblesseofFrance,oranyabusewhichcouldnotberemovedbyareformveryshortofabolition。Yournoblessedidnotdeservepunishment:buttodegradeistopunish。
ItwaswiththesamesatisfactionIfoundthattheresultofmyinquiryconcerningyourclergywasnotdissimilar。Itisnosoothingnewstomyears,thatgreatbodiesofmenareincurablycorrupt。ItisnotwithmuchcredulityIlistentoanywhentheyspeakevilofthosewhomtheyaregoingtoplunder。Irathersuspectthatvicesarefeignedorexaggeratedwhenprofitislookedforintheirpunishment。Anenemyisabadwitness;arobberisaworse。Vicesandabusestherewereundoubtedlyinthatorder,andmustbe。Itwasanoldestablishment,andnotfrequentlyrevised。ButIsawnocrimesintheindividualsthatmeritedconfiscationoftheirsubstance,northosecruelinsultsanddegradations,andthatunnaturalpersecution,whichhavebeensubstitutedintheplaceofmelioratingregulation。
Iftherehadbeenanyjustcauseforthisnewreligiouspersecution,theatheisticlibellers,whoactastrumpeterstoanimatethepopulacetoplunder,donotloveanybodysomuchasnottodwellwithcomplacenceonthevicesoftheexistingclergy。Thistheyhavenotdone。Theyfindthemselvesobligedtorakeintothehistoriesofformerages(whichtheyhaveransackedwithamalignantandprofligateindustry)foreveryinstanceofoppressionandpersecutionwhichhasbeenmadebythatbodyorinitsfavour,inordertojustify,uponveryiniquitous,becauseveryillogical,principlesofretaliation,theirownpersecutionsandtheirowncruelties。Afterdestroyingallothergenealogiesandfamilydistinctions,theyinventasortofpedigreeofcrimes。Itisnotveryjusttochastisemenfortheoffencesoftheirnaturalancestors:buttotakethefictionofancestryinacorporatesuccessionasagroundforpunishingmenwhohavenorelationtoguiltyacts,exceptinnamesandgeneraldescriptions,isasortofrefinementininjusticebelongingtothephilosophyofthisenlightenedage。TheAssemblypunishesmen,many,ifnotmost,ofwhomabhortheviolentconductofecclesiasticsinformertimesasmuchastheirpresentpersecutorscando,andwhowouldbeasloudandasstrongintheexpressionofthatsense,iftheywerenotwellawareofthepurposesforwhichallthisdeclamationisemployed。Corporatebodiesareimmortalforthegoodofthemembers,butnotfortheirpunishment。Nationsthemselvesaresuchcorporations。AswellmightweinEnglandthinkofwaginginexpiablewaruponallFrenchmenfortheevilswhichtheyhavebroughtuponusintheseveralperiodsofourmutualhostilities。Youmight,onyourpart,thinkyourselvesjustifiedinfallinguponallEnglishmenonaccountoftheunparalleledcalamitiesbroughtuponthepeopleofFrancebytheunjustinvasionsofourHenriesandourEdwards。Indeed,weshouldbemutuallyjustifiedinthisexterminatorywaruponeachother,fullasmuchasyouareintheunprovokedpersecutionofyourpresentcountrymen,onaccountoftheconductofmenofthesamenameinothertimes。
LEGISLATIONANDREPUBLICANS。
Thelegislatorswhoframedtheancientrepublicsknewthattheirbusinesswastooarduoustobeaccomplishedwithnobetterapparatusthanthemetaphysicsofanundergraduate,andthemathematicsandarithmeticofanexciseman。Theyhadtodowithmen,andtheywereobligedtostudyhumannature。Theyhadtodowithcitizens,andtheywereobligedtostudytheeffectsofthosehabitswhicharecommunicatedbythecircumstancesofcivillife。Theyweresensiblethattheoperationofthissecondnatureonthefirstproducedanewcombination;
andthencearosemanydiversitiesamongstmen,accordingtotheirbirth,theireducation,theirprofessions,theperiodsoftheirlives,theirresidenceintownsorinthecountry,theirseveralwaysofacquiringandoffixingproperty,andaccordingtothequalityofthepropertyitself,allwhichrenderedthemasitweresomanydifferentspeciesofanimals。Fromhencetheythoughtthemselvesobligedtodisposetheircitizensintosuchclasses,andtoplacetheminsuchsituationsinthestateastheirpeculiarhabitsmightqualifythemtofill,andtoallottothemsuchappropriatedprivilegesasmightsecuretothemwhattheirspecificoccasionsrequired,andwhichmightfurnishtoeachdescriptionsuchforceasmightprotectitintheconflictcausedbythediversityofintereststhatmustexist,andmustcontend,inallcomplexsociety;
forthelegislatorwouldhavebeenashamedthatthecoarsehusbandmanshouldwellknowhowtoassortandtousehissheep,horses,andoxen,andshouldhaveenoughofcommonsensenottoabstractandequalizethemallintoanimals,withoutprovidingforeachkindanappropriatefood,care,andemployment;whilsthe,theeconomist,disposer,andshepherdofhisownkindred,subliminghimselfintoanairymetaphysician,wasresolvedtoknownothingofhisflocksbutasmeningeneral。ItisforthisreasonthatMontesquieuobserved,veryjustly,thatintheirclassificationofthecitizens,thegreatlegislatorsofantiquitymadethegreatestdisplayoftheirpowers,andevensoaredabovethemselves。
Itisherethatyourmodernlegislatorshavegonedeepintothenegativeseries,andsunkevenbelowtheirownnothing。Asthefirstsortoflegislatorsattendedtothedifferentkindsofcitizens,andcombinedthemintoonecommonwealth,theothers,themetaphysicalandalchemisticallegislators,havetakenthedirectlycontrarycourse。Theyhaveattemptedtoconfoundallsortsofcitizens,aswellastheycould,intoonehomogeneousmass;andthentheydividedthistheiramalgamaintoanumberofincoherentrepublics。Theyreducementoloosecounters,merelyforthesakeofsimpletelling,andnottofigureswhosepoweristoarisefromtheirplaceinthetable。Theelementsoftheirownmetaphysicsmighthavetaughtthembetterlessons。ThetrolloftheircategoricaltablemighthaveinformedthemthattherewassomethingelseintheintellectualworldbesidesSUBSTANCEandQUANTITY。
Theymightlearnfromthecatechismofmetaphysicsthattherewereeightheadsmore,ineverycomplexdeliberation,whichtheyhaveneverthoughtof;thoughthese,ofalltheten,arethesubjectsonwhichtheskillofmancanoperateanythingatall。Sofarfromthisabledispositionofsomeoftheoldrepublicanlegislators,whichfollowswithasolicitousaccuracythemoralconditionsandpropensitiesofmen,theyhaveleveledandcrushedtogetheralltheorderswhichtheyfound,evenunderthecoarse,unartificialarrangementofthemonarchy,inwhichmodeofgovernmenttheclassingofthecitizensisnotofsomuchimportanceasinarepublic。Itistrue,however,thateverysuchclassification,ifproperlyordered,isgoodinallformsofgovernment;andcomposesastrongbarrieragainsttheexcessesofdespotism,aswellasitisthenecessarymeansofgivingeffectandpermanencetoarepublic。Forwantofsomethingofthiskind,ifthepresentprojectofarepublicshouldfail,allsecuritiestoamoderatedfreedomfailalongwithit;alltheindirectrestraintswhichmitigatedespotismareremoved;insomuchthatifmonarchyshouldeveragainobtainanentireascendancyinFrance,underthisorunderanyotherdynasty,itwillprobablybe,ifnotvoluntarilytemperedatsettingoutbythewiseandvirtuouscounselsoftheprince,themostcompletelyarbitrarypowerthathaseverappearedonearth。Thisistoplayamostdesperategame。
PRINCIPLEOFSTATE-CONSECRATION。
Butoneofthefirstandmostleadingprinciplesonwhichthecommonwealthandthelawsareconsecrated,islestthetemporarypossessorsandlife-rentersinit,unmindfulofwhattheyhavereceivedfromtheirancestors,orofwhatisduetotheirposterity,shouldactasiftheyweretheentiremasters;thattheyshouldnotthinkitamongsttheirrightstocutofftheentail,orcommitwasteontheinheritance,bydestroyingattheirpleasurethewholeoriginalfabricoftheirsociety;hazardingtoleavetothosewhocomeafterthemaruininsteadofanhabitation——andteachingthesesuccessorsaslittletorespecttheircontrivances,astheyhadthemselvesrespectedtheinstitutionsoftheirforefathers。Bythisunprincipledfacilityofchangingthestateasoften,andasmuch,andinasmanyways,astherearefloatingfanciesorfashions,thewholechainandcontinuityofthecommonwealthwouldbebroken。Noonegenerationcouldlinkwiththeother。Menwouldbecomelittlebetterthanthefliesofasummer。
Andfirstofall,thescienceofjurisprudence,theprideofthehumanintellect,which,withallitsdefects,redundancies,anderrors,isthecollectedreasonofages,combiningtheprinciplesoforiginaljusticewiththeinfinitevarietyofhumanconcerns,asaheapofoldexplodederrors,wouldbenolongerstudied。Personalself-sufficiencyandarrogance(thecertainattendantsuponallthosewhohaveneverexperiencedawisdomgreaterthantheirown)wouldusurpthetribunal。
Ofcoursenocertainlaws,establishinginvariablegroundsofhopeandfear,wouldkeeptheactionsofmeninacertaincourse,ordirectthemtoacertainend。Nothingstableinthemodesofholdingproperty,orexercisingfunction,couldformasolidgroundonwhichanyparentcouldspeculateintheeducationofhisoffspring,orinachoicefortheirfutureestablishmentintheworld。Noprincipleswouldbeearlyworkedintothehabits。Assoonasthemostableinstructorhadcompletedhislaboriouscourseofinstitution,insteadofsendingforthhispupil,accomplishedinavirtuousdiscipline,fittedtoprocurehimattentionandrespectinhisplaceinsociety,hewouldfindeverythingaltered;
andthathehadturnedoutapoorcreaturetothecontemptandderisionoftheworld,ignorantofthetruegroundsofestimation。Whowouldinsureatenderanddelicatesenseofhonourtobeatalmostwiththefirstpulsesoftheheart,whennomancouldknowwhatwouldbethetestofhonourinanation,continuallyvaryingthestandardofitscoin?Nopartoflifewouldretainitsacquisitions。Barbarismwithregardtoscienceandliterature,unskilfulnesswithregardtoartsandmanufactures,wouldinfalliblysucceedtothewantofasteadyeducationandsettledprinciple;andthusthecommonwealthitselfwould,inafewgenerations,crumbleaway,bedisconnectedintothedustandpowderofindividuality,andatlengthdispersedtoallthewindsofheaven。Toavoidthereforetheevilsofinconstancyandversatility,tenthousandtimesworsethanthoseofobstinacyandtheblindestprejudice,wehaveconsecratedthestate,thatnomanshouldapproachtolookintoitsdefectsorcorruptionsbutwithduecaution;thatheshouldneverdreamofbeginningitsreformationbyitssubversion;thatheshouldapproachtothefaultsofthestateastothewoundsofafather,withpiousawe,andtremblingsolicitude。Bythiswiseprejudicewearetaughttolookwithhorroronthosechildrenoftheircountry,whoarepromptrashlytohackthatagedparentinpieces,andputhimintothekettleofmagicians,inhopesthatbytheirpoisonousweeds,andwildincantations,theymayregeneratethepaternalconstitution,andrenovatetheirfather’slife。
BRITISHSTABILITY。
Fourhundredyearshavegoneoverus;butIbelievewearenotmateriallychangedsincethatperiod。Thankstooursullenresistancetoinnovation,thankstothecoldsluggishnessofournationalcharacter,westillbearthestampofourforefathers。Wehavenot(asIconceive)
lostthegenerosityanddignityofthinkingofthefourteenthcentury;
norasyethavewesubtilizedourselvesintosavages。WearenottheconvertsofRousseau;wearenotthedisciplesofVoltaire;Helvetiushasmadenoprogressamongstus。Atheistsarenotourpreachers;madmenarenotourlawgivers。WeknowthatWEhavemadenodiscoveries;andwethinkthatnodiscoveriesaretobemadeinmorality;normanyinthegreatprinciplesofgovernment,norintheideasofliberty;whichwereunderstoodlongbeforewewereborn,altogetheraswellastheywillbeafterthegravehasheapeditsmoulduponourpresumption,andthesilenttombshallhaveimposeditslawonourpertloquacity。InEnglandwehavenotyetbeencompletelyembowelledofournaturalentrails;westillfeelwithinus,andwecherishandcultivate,thoseinbredsentimentswhicharethefaithfulguardians,theactivemonitorsofourduty,thetruesupportersofallliberalandmanlymorals。Wehavenotbeendrawnandtrussed,inorderthatwemaybefilled,likestuffedbirdsinamuseum,withchaffandragsandpaltryblurredshredsofpaperabouttherightsofman。Wepreservethewholeofourfeelingsstillnativeandentire,unsophisticatedbypedantryandinfidelity。Wehaverealheartsoffleshandbloodbeatinginourbosoms。WefearGod;
welookupwithawetokings;withaffectiontoparliaments;withdutytomagistrates;withreverencetopriests;andwithrespecttonobility。
Why?Becausewhensuchideasarebroughtbeforeourminds,itisNATURAL
tobesoaffected;becauseallotherfeelingsarefalseandspurious,andtendtocorruptourminds,tovitiateourprimarymorals,torenderusunfitforrationalliberty;andbyteachingusaservile,licentious,andabandonedinsolence,tobeourlowsportforafewholidays,tomakeusperfectlyfitfor,andjustlydeservingof,slavery,throughthewholecourseofourlives。
Yousee,sir,thatinthisenlightenedageIamboldenoughtoconfess,thatwearegenerallymenofuntaughtfeelings;thatinsteadofcastingawayallouroldprejudices,wecherishthemtoaveryconsiderabledegree,and,totakemoreshametoourselves,wecherishthembecausetheyareprejudices;andthelongertheyhavelasted,andthemoregenerallytheyhaveprevailed,themorewecherishthem。Weareafraidtoputmentoliveandtradeeachonhisownprivatestockofreason;
becausewesuspectthatthestockineachmanissmall,andthattheindividualswoulddobettertoavailthemselvesofthegeneralbankandcapitalofnationsandofages。Manyofourmenofspeculation,insteadofexplodinggeneralprejudices,employtheirsagacitytodiscoverthelatentwisdomwhichprevailsinthem。Iftheyfindwhattheyseek,andtheyseldomfail,theythinkitmorewisetocontinuetheprejudice,withthereasoninvolved,thantocastawaythecoatofprejudice,andtoleavenothingbutthenakedreason;becauseprejudice,withitsreason,hasamotivetogiveactiontothatreason,andanaffectionwhichwillgiveitpermanence。Prejudiceisofreadyapplicationtotheemergency;itpreviouslyengagesthemindinasteadycourseofwisdomandvirtue,anddoesnotleavethemanhesitatinginthemomentofdecision,sceptical,puzzled,andunresolved。Prejudicerendersaman’svirtuehishabit;andnotaseriesofunconnectedacts。Throughjustprejudice,hisdutybecomesapartofhisnature。