第10章

类别:其他 作者:Burke, Edmund字数:40056更新时间:18/12/20 11:23:24
Itisonthisdarkenedtheatrethatsomeoldwritershaveintroducedthosecharactersandactions,whichhaveaffordedsuchamplemattertopoets,andsomuchperplexitytohistorians。Thisisthefabulousandheroicageofournation。AfterthenaturalandjustrepresentationsoftheRomanscene,thestageisagaincrowdedwithenchanters,giants,andalltheextravagantimagesofthewildestandmostremoteantiquity。NopersonagemakessoconspicuousafigureinthesestoriesasKingArthur; aprince,whetherofBritishorRomanorigin,whetherbornonthisislandorinArmorica,isuncertain;butitappearsthatheopposedtheSaxonswithremarkablevirtue,andnosmalldegreeofsuccess,whichhasrenderedhimandhisexploitssolargeanargumentofromance,thatbotharealmostdisclaimedbyhistory。LightscarcebeginstodawnuntiltheintroductionofChristianity,which,bringingwithittheuseofletters,andtheartsofcivillife,affordsatonceajusteraccountofthingsandfactsthataremoreworthyofrelation;noristhere,indeed,anyrevolutionsoremarkableintheEnglishstory。 ThebishopsofRomehadforsometimemeditatedtheconversionoftheAnglo-Saxons。PopeGregory,whoissurnamedtheGreat,affectedthatpiousdesignwithanuncommonzeal;andheatlengthfoundacircumstancehighlyfavourabletoitinthemarriageofadaughterofCharibert,akingoftheFranks,tothereiningmonarchofKent。ThisopportunityinducedPopeGregorytocommissionAugustin,amonkofRheims,andamanofdistinguishedpiety,toundertakethisarduousenterprise。 ItwasintheyearofChrist600,and150yearsafterthecomingofthefirstSaxoncoloniesintoEngland,thatEthelbert,kingofKent,receivedintelligenceofthearrivalinhisdominionsofanumberofmeninaforeigngarb,practisingseveralstrangeandunusualceremonies,whodesiredtobeconductedtotheking’spresence,declaringthattheyhadthingstocommunicatetohimandtohispeopleoftheutmostimportancetotheireternalwelfare。ThiswasAugustin,withfortyoftheassociatesofhismission,whonowlandedintheIsleofThanet,thesameplacebywhichtheSaxonshadbeforeentered,whentheyextirpatedChristianity。 MINISTERIALRESPONSIBILITY。 Itisnoexcuseatallforaminister,whoatourdesiretakesameasurecontrarytooursafety,thatitisourownact。Hewhodoesnotstaythehandofsuicide,isguiltyofmurder。Onourpart,Isay,thattobeinstructed,isnottobedegradedorenslaved。Informationisanadvantagetous;andwehavearighttodemandit。Hethatisboundtoactinthedarkcannotbesaidtoactfreely。Whenitappearsevidenttoourgovernorsthatourdesiresandourinterestsareatvariance,theyoughtnottogratifytheformerattheexpenseofthelatter。Statesmenareplacedonaneminence,thattheymayhavealargerhorizonthanwecanpossiblycommand。Theyhaveawholebeforethem,whichwecancontemplateonlyintheparts,andoftenwithoutthenecessaryrelations。Ministersarenotonlyournaturalrulersbutournaturalguides。Reasonclearlyandmanfullydelivered,hasinitselfamightyforce:butreasoninthemouthoflegalauthority,is,Imayfairlysay,irresistible。Iadmitthatreasonofstatewillnot,inmanycircumstances,permitthedisclosureofthetruegroundofapublicproceeding。Inthatcasesilenceismanlyanditiswise。Itisfairtocallfortrustwhentheprincipleofreasonitselfsuspendsitspublicuse。Itakethedistinctiontobethis:Thegroundofaparticularmeasure,makingapartofaplan,itisrarelypropertodivulge;allthebroadergroundsofpolicy,onwhichthegeneralplanistobeadopted,oughtasrarelytobeconcealed。They,whohavenotthewholecausebeforethem,callthempoliticians,callthempeople,callthemwhatyouwill,arenojudges。Thedifficultiesofthecase,aswellasitsfairside,oughttobepresented。Thisoughttobedone;anditisallthatcanbedone。Whenwehaveourtruesituationdistinctlypresentedtous,ifthenweresolve,withablindandheadlongviolence,toresisttheadmonitionsofourfriends,andtocastourselvesintothehandsofourpotentandirreconcilablefoes,then,andnottillthen,theministersstandacquittedbeforeGodandman,forwhatevermaycome。 MONASTICINSTITUTIONSANDTHEIRRESULTS。 Inthechangeofreligion,carewastakentorenderthetransitfromfalsehoodtotruthaslittleviolentaspossible。Thoughthefirstproselyteswerekings,itdoesnotappearthattherewasanypersecution。ItwasapreceptofPopeGregory,underwhoseauspicesthismissionwasconducted,thattheheathentemplesshouldnotbedestroyed,especiallywheretheywerewellbuilt;butthat,firstremovingtheidols,theyshouldbeconsecratedanewbyholierrites,andtobetterpurposes(Bed。Hist。Eccl。l。i。c。30。),inorderthattheprejudicesofthepeoplemightnotbetoorudelyshockedbyadeclaredprofanationofwhattheyhadsolongheldsacred;andthateverywherebeholdingthesameplaces,towhichtheyhadformerlyresortedforreligiouscomfort,theymightbegraduallyreconciledtothenewdoctrinesandceremonieswhichwerethereintroduced;andasthesacrificesusedinthePaganworshipwerealwaysattendedwithfeasting,andconsequentlywerehighlygratefultothemultitude,thepopeordered,thatoxenshouldasusualbeslaughterednearthechurch,andthepeopleindulgedintheirancientfestivity。(Id。c。eod。)WhateverpopularcustomsofheathenismwerefoundtobeabsolutelynotincompatiblewithChristianitywereretained; andsomeofthemwerecontinuedtoaverylateperiod。DeerwereatacertainseasonbroughtintoSt。Paul’sChurchinLondon,andlaidonthealtar(Dugdale’sHistoryofSt。Paul’s。);andthiscustomsubsisteduntiltheReformation。Thenamesofsomeofthechurchfestivalswere,withasimilardesign,takenfromthoseoftheheathen,whichhadbeencelebratedatthesametimeoftheyear。Nothingcouldhavebeenmoreprudentthantheseregulations;theywereindeedformedfromaperfectunderstandingofhumannature。 Whilsttheinferiorpeoplewerethusinsensiblyledintoabetterorder,theexampleandcountenanceofthegreatcompletedthework。FortheSaxonkingsandrulingmenembracedreligionwithsosignal,andintheirranksounusual,azeal,thatinmanyinstancestheyevensacrificedtoitsadvancementtheprimeobjectsoftheirambition。 Wulfere,kingoftheWestSaxons,bestowedtheIsleofWightonthekingofSussex,topersuadehimtoembraceChristianity。(Bed。Hist。Eccl。l。 iv。c。13。)Thiszealoperatedinthesamemannerinfavouroftheirinstructors。Thegreatestkingsandconquerorsfrequentlyresignedtheircrowns,andshutthemselvesupinmonasteries。Whenkingsbecamemonks,ahighlustrewasreflecteduponthemonasticstate,andgreatcreditaccruedtothepoweroftheirdoctrine,whichwasabletoproducesuchextraordinaryeffectsuponpersons,overwhomreligionhascommonlytheslightestinfluence。 Thezealofthemissionarieswasalsomuchassistedbytheirsuperiorityintheartsofcivillife。AttheirfirstpreachinginSussex,thatcountrywasreducedtothegreatestdistressfromadrought,whichhadcontinuedforthreeyears。Thebarbarousinhabitants,destituteofanymeanstoalleviatethefamine,inanepidemictransportofdespairfrequentlyunitedfortyandfiftyinabody,andjoiningtheirhands,precipitatedthemselvesfromthecliffs,andwereeitherdrownedordashedtopiecesontherocks。Thoughamaritimepeople,theyknewnothowtofish;andthisignoranceprobablyarosefromaremnantofDruidicalsuperstition,whichhadforbiddentheuseofthatsortofdiet。Inthiscalamity,BishopWilfred,theirfirstpreacher,collectingnets,attheheadofhisattendants,plungedintothesea;andhavingopenedthisgreatresourceoffood,hereconciledthedesperatepeopletolife,andtheirmindstothespiritualcareofthosewhohadshownthemselvessoattentivetotheirtemporalpreservation。(Bed。Hist。 Eccl。l。iv。c。13。)Thesameregardtothewelfareofthepeopleappearedinalltheiractions。TheChristiankingssometimesmadedonationstothechurchoflandsconqueredfromtheirheathenenemies。 Theclergyimmediatelybaptizedandmanumittedtheirnewvassals。Thustheyendearedtoallsortsofmendoctrinesandteachers,whichcouldmitigatetherigorouslawofconquest;andtheyrejoicedtoseereligionandlibertyadvancingwithanequalprogress。Norwerethemonksinthistimeinanythingmoreworthyoftheirpraisethanintheirzealforpersonalfreedom。Inthecanon,whereintheyprovidedagainstthealienationoftheirlands,amongothercharitableexceptionstothisrestraint,theyparticularizethepurchaseofliberty。(Spelm。Concil。 Page329。)Intheirtransactionswiththegreatthesamepointwasalwaysstrenuouslylaboured。Whentheyimposedpenance,theywereremarkablyindulgenttopersonsofthatrank。Buttheyalwaysmadethempurchasetheremissionofcorporalausteritybyactsofbeneficence。 Theyurgedtheirpowerfulpenitentstotheenfranchisementoftheirownslaves,andtotheredemptionofthosewhichbelongedtoothers;theydirectedthemtotherepairofhighways,andtotheconstructionofchurches,bridges,andotherworksofgeneralutility。(InstauretetiamDeiecclesiam;etinstauretviaspublicas,pontibussuperaquasprofundasetsupercaenosasvias;etmanumittatservossuosproprios,etredimatabaliishominibusservossuosadlibertatem——L。Eccl。Edgari14。)Theyextractedthefruitsofvirtueevenfromcrimes,andwheneveragreatmanexpiatedhisprivateoffences,heprovidedinthesameactforthepublichappiness。Themonasterieswerethentheonlybodiescorporateinthekingdom;andifanypersonsweredesiroustoperpetuatetheircharitybyafundforthereliefofthesickorindigent,therewasnootherwaythantoconfidethistrusttosomemonastery。Themonkswerethesolechannel,throughwhichthebountyoftherichcouldpassinanycontinuedstreamtothepoor;andthepeopleturnedtheireyestowardstheminalltheirdistresses。 Wemustobserve,thatthemonksofthattime,especiallythosefromIreland(AidanusFinametColmanusmiraesanctitatisfueruntetparsimoniae。Adeoenimsacerdoteserantilliustemporisabavaritiaimmunes,utnecterritorianisicoactiacciperent——Hen。Hunting。apudDecem。l。iii。page333。Bed。Hist。Eccl。l。iii。c。26。),whohadaconsiderableshareintheconversionofallthenorthernparts,didnotshowthatrapaciousdesireofriches,whichlongdisgraced,andfinallyruined,theirsuccessors。Notonlydidtheynotseek,butseemedeventoshun,suchdonations。Thispreventedthatalarm,whichmighthavearisenfromanearlyanddeclaredavarice。Atthistimethemostferventandholyanchoritesretiredtoplacesthefurthestthatcouldbefoundfromhumanconcourseandhelp,tothemostdesolateandbarrensituations,whichevenfromtheirhorrorseemedparticularlyadaptedtomenwhohadrenouncedtheworld。Manypersonsfollowedtheminordertopartakeoftheirinstructionsandprayers,ortoformthemselvesupontheirexample。Anopinionoftheirmiraclesaftertheirdeathdrewstillgreaternumbers。Establishmentsweregraduallymade。Themonasticlifewasfrugal,andthegovernmentmoderate。Thesecausesdrewaconstantconcourse。Sanctifieddesertsassumedanewface;themarshesweredrained,andthelandscultivated。Andasthisrevolutionseemedrathertheeffectoftheholinessoftheplacethanofanynaturalcauses,itincreasedtheircredit;andeveryimprovementdrewwithitanewdonation。InthismannerthegreatabbeysofCroylandandGlastonbury,andmanyothers,fromthemostobscurebeginnings,wereadvancedtoadegreeofwealthandsplendourlittlelessthanroyal。Intheserudeages,governmentwasnotyetfixeduponsolidprinciples,andeverythingwasfulloftumultanddistraction。Asthemonasterieswerebettersecuredfromviolencebytheircharacter,thananyotherplacesbylaws,severalgreatmen,andevensovereignprinces,wereobligedtotakerefugeinconvents,who,whenbyamorehappyrevolutionintheirfortunestheywerereinstatedintheirformerdignities,thoughttheycouldnevermakeasufficientreturnforthesafetytheyhadenjoyedunderthesacredhospitalityoftheseroofs。Notcontenttoenrichthemwithamplepossessions,thatothersalsomightpartakeoftheprotectiontheyhadexperienced,theyformallyerectedintoanasylumthosemonasteries,andtheiradjacentterritory。Sothatallthrongedtothatrefuge,whowererenderedunquietbytheircrimes,theirmisfortunes,ortheseverityoftheirlords;andcontenttoliveunderagovernment,towhichtheirmindsweresubject,theyraisedtheimportanceoftheirmastersbytheirnumbers,theirlabour,andaboveall,byaninviolableattachment。 Themonasterywasalwaystheplaceofsepultureforthegreatestlordsandkings。Thisaddedtotheothercausesofreverenceasortofsanctity,which,inuniversalopinion,alwaysattendstherepositoriesofthedead;andtheyacquiredalsotherebyamoreparticularprotectionagainstthegreatandpowerful;forwhowouldviolatethetombofhisancestors,orhisown?Itwasnotanunnaturalweaknesstothink,thatsomeadvantagemightbederivedfromlyinginholyplaces,andamongstholypersons:andthissuperstitionwasfomentedwiththegreatestindustryandart。ThemonksofGlastonburyspreadanotion,thatitwasalmostimpossibleanypersonshouldbedamned,whosebodylayintheircemetery。Thismustbeconsideredascominginaidoftheamplestoftheirresources,prayerforthedead。 Buttherewasnopartoftheirpolicy,ofwhatevernature,thatprocuredtothemagreaterorjustercredit,thantheircultivationoflearningandusefularts。ForifthemonkscontributedtothefallofscienceintheRomanempire,itiscertain,thattheintroductionoflearningandcivilityintothisnorthernworldisentirelyowingtotheirlabours。Itistrue,thattheycultivatedlettersonlyinasecondaryway,andassubsidiarytoreligion。ButtheschemeofChristianityissuch,thatitalmostnecessitatesanattentiontomanykindsoflearning。FortheScriptureisbynomeansanirrelativesystemofmoralanddivinetruths;butitstandsconnectedwithsomanyhistories,andwiththelaws,opinions,andmannersofsomanyvarioussortsofpeople,andinsuchdifferenttimes,thatitisaltogetherimpossibletoarrivetoanytolerableknowledgeofit,withouthavingrecoursetomuchexteriorinquiry。Forwhichreasontheprogressofthisreligionhasalwaysbeenmarkedbythatofletters。Thereweretwoothercircumstancesatthistime,thatcontributednolesstotherevivaloflearning。Thesacredwritingshadnotbeentranslatedintoanyvernacularlanguage,andeventheordinaryserviceofthechurchwasstillcontinuedintheLatintongue;all,therefore,whoformedthemselvesfortheministry,andhopedtomakeanyfigureinit,wereinamannerdriventothestudyofthewritersofpoliteantiquity,inordertoqualifythemselvesfortheirmostordinaryfunctions。Bythismeansapractice,liableinitselftogreatobjections,hadaconsiderableshareinpreservingthewrecksofliterature;andwasonemeansofconveyingdowntoourtimesthoseinestimablemonuments,whichotherwise,inthetumultofbarbarousconfusionononehand,anduntaughtpietyontheother,mustinevitablyhaveperished。Thesecondcircumstance,thepilgrimagesofthatage,ifconsideredinitself,wasasliabletoobjectionastheformer;butitprovedofequaladvantagetothecauseofliterature。AprincipalobjectofthesepiousjourneyswasRome,whichcontainedallthelittlethatwasleftinthewesternworld,ofancientlearningandtaste。TheothergreatobjectofthosepilgrimageswasJerusalem;thisledthemintotheGrecianempire,whichstillsubsistedintheEastwithgreatmajestyandpower。HeretheGreekshadnotonlynotdiscontinuedtheancientstudies,buttheyaddedtothestockofartsmanyinventionsofcuriosityandconveniencethatwereunknowntoantiquity。When,afterwards,theSaracensprevailedinthatpartoftheworld,thepilgrimshadalso,bythesamemeans,anopportunityofprofitingfromtheimprovementsofthatlaboriouspeople;andhoweverlittlethemajorityofthesepioustravellersmighthavehadsuchobjectsintheirview,somethingusefulmustunavoidablyhavestucktothem;afewcertainlysawwithmorediscernment,andrenderedtheirtravelsserviceabletotheircountrybyimportingotherthingsbesidesmiraclesandlegends。Thusacommunicationwasopenedbetweenthisremoteislandandcountries,ofwhichitotherwisecouldthenscarcelyhaveheardmentionmade;andpilgrimagesthuspreservedthatintercourseamongstmankind,whichisnowformedbypolitics,commerce,andlearnedcuriosity。Itisnotwhollyunworthyofobservation,thatProvidence,whichstronglyappearstohaveintendedthecontinualintermixtureofmankind,neverleavesthehumanminddestituteofaprincipletoeffectit。Thispurposeissometimescarriedonbyasortofmigratoryinstinct,sometimesbythespiritofconquest;atonetimeavaricedrivesmenfromtheirhomes,atanothertheyareactuatedbyathirstofknowledge;wherenoneofthesecausescanoperate,thesanctityofparticularplacesattractsmenfromthemostdistantquarters。ItwasthismotivewhichsentthousandsinthoseagestoJerusalemandRome; andnow,inafulltide,impelshalftheworldannuallytoMecca。 Bythosevoyages,theseedsofvariouskindsofknowledgeandimprovementwereatdifferenttimesimportedintoEngland。Theywerecultivatedintheleisureandretirementofmonasteries;otherwisetheycouldnothavebeencultivatedatall:foritwasaltogethernecessarytodrawcertainmenfromthegeneralrudeandfiercesociety,andwhollytosetabarbetweenthemandthebarbarouslifeoftherestoftheworld,inordertofitthemforstudy,andthecultivationofartsandscience。Accordingly,wefindeverywhere,inthefirstinstitutionsforthepropagationofknowledgeamongstanypeople,thatthose,whofollowedit,weresetapartandsecludedfromthemassofthecommunity。 Thegreatecclesiasticalchairofthiskingdom,fornearacentury,wasfilledbyforeigners;theywerenominatedbythepopes,whowereinthatagejustorpoliticenoughtoappointpersonsofameritinsomedegreeadequatetothatimportantcharge。Throughthisseriesofforeignandlearnedprelates,continualaccessionsweremadetotheoriginallyslenderstockofEnglishliterature。ThegreatestandmostvaluableoftheseaccessionswasmadeinthetimeandbythecareofTheodorus,theseventharchbishopofCanterbury。HewasaGreekbybirth;amanofahighambitiousspirit,andofamindmoreliberal,andtalentsbettercultivated,thangenerallyfelltothelotofthewesternprelates。Hefirstintroducedthestudyofhisnativelanguageintothisisland。Hebroughtwithhimanumberofvaluablebooksinmanyfaculties;andamongstthemamagnificentcopyoftheworksofHomer;themostancientandbestofpoets,andthebestchosentoinspireapeople,justinitiatedintoletters,withanardentlove,andwithatruetasteforthesciences。UnderhisinfluenceaschoolwasformedatCanterbury;andthustheothergreatfountainofknowledge,theGreektongue,wasopenedinEnglandintheyearofourLord669。 COMMONLAWANDMAGNACHARTA。 Thecommonlaw,asitthenprevailedinEngland,wasinagreatmeasurecomposedofsomeremnantsoftheoldSaxoncustoms,joinedtothefeudalinstitutionsbroughtinattheNormanconquest。Anditisheretobeobserved,thattheconstitutionsofMagnaChartaarebynomeansarenewalofthelawsofSt。Edward,ortheancientSaxonlaws,asourhistoriansandlaw-writersgenerally,thoughverygroundlessly,assert。 Theybearnoresemblance,inanyparticular,tothelawsofSt。Edward,ortoanyothercollectionoftheseancientinstitutions。Indeed,howshouldthey?TheobjectofMagnaChartaisthecorrectionofthefeudalpolicy,whichwasfirstintroduced,atleastinanyregularform,attheConquest,anddidnotsubsistbeforeit。Itmaybefurtherobserved,thatinthepreambletotheGreatCharteritisstipulated,thatthebaronsshallHOLDtheliberties,theregrantedTOTHEMANDTHEIRHEIRS,fromTHEKINGANDHISHEIRS;whichshows,thatthedoctrineofanunalienabletenurewasalwaysuppermostintheirminds。Theirideaevenoflibertywasnot(ifImayusetheexpression)perfectlyfree;andtheydidnotclaimtopossesstheirprivilegesuponanynaturalprincipleorindependentbottom,but,justastheyheldtheirlands,fromtheking。Thisisworthyofobservation。Bythefeudallawalllandedpropertyis,byafeignedconclusion,supposedtobederived,andthereforetobemediatelyorimmediatelyheld,fromtheCrown。Ifsomeestatesweresoderived,otherswerecertainlyprocuredbythesameoriginaltitleofconquest,bywhichthecrownitselfwasacquired;andthederivationfromthekingcouldinreasononlybeconsideredasafictionoflaw。Butitsconsequentrightsbeingoncesupposed,manyrealchargesandburthensgrewfromafictionmadeonlyforthepreservationofsubordination;andinconsequenceofthis,agreatpowerwasexercisedoverthepersonsandestatesofthetenants。Thefinesonthesuccessiontoanestate,calledinthefeudallanguage“Reliefs,“werenotfixedtoanycertainty;andwerethereforefrequentlymadesoexcessive,thattheymightratherbeconsideredasredemptions,ornewpurchases,thanacknowledgmentsofsuperiorityandtenure。Withrespecttothatmostimportantarticleofmarriage,therewas,intheverynatureofthefeudalholding,agreatrestraintlaiduponit。Itwasofimportancetothelord,thattheperson,whoreceivedthefeud,shouldbesubmissivetohim;hehadthereforearighttointerfereinthemarriageoftheheiress,whoinheritedthefeud。Thisrightwascarriedfurtherthanthenecessityrequired;themaleheirhimselfwasobligedtomarryaccordingtothechoiceofhislord:andevenwidows,whohadmadeonesacrificetothefeudaltyranny,wereneithersufferedtocontinueinthewidowedstate,nortochooseforthemselvesthepartnersoftheirsecondbed。Infact,marriagewaspubliclysetuptosale。Theancientrecordsoftheexchequeraffordmanyinstanceswheresomewomenpurchased,byheavyfines,theprivilegeofasinglelife;somethefreechoiceofahusband;othersthelibertyofrejectingsomepersonparticularlydisagreeable。And,whatmayappearextraordinary,therearenotwantingexamples,whereawomanhasfinedinaconsiderablesum,thatshemightnotbecompelledtomarryacertainman;thesuitorontheotherhandhasoutbidher;andsolelybyofferingmoreforthemarriagethantheheiresscouldtopreventit,hecarriedhispointdirectlyandavowedlyagainstherinclinations。Now,asthekingclaimednorightoverhisimmediatetenants,thattheydidnotexerciseinthesame,orinamoreoppressivemannerovertheirvassals,itishardtoconceiveamoregeneralandcruelgrievancethanthisshamefulmarket,whichsouniversallyoutragedthemostsacredrelationsamongmankind。 Butthetyrannyoverwomenwasnotoverwiththemarriage。Asthekingseizedintohishandstheestateofeverydeceasedtenantinordertosecurehisrelief,thewidowwasdrivenoftenbyaheavycompositiontopurchasetheadmissiontoherdower,intowhichitshouldseemshecouldnotenterwithouttheking’sconsent。 Alltheseweremarksofarealandgrievousservitude。TheGreatCharterwasmadenottodestroytheroot,buttocutshorttheovergrownbranches,ofthefeudalservice;first,inmoderating,andinreducingtoacertainty,thereliefs,whichtheking’stenantspaidonsucceedingtotheirestateaccordingtotheirrank;andsecondly,intakingoffsomeoftheburthens,whichhadbeenlaidonmarriage,whethercompulsoryorrestrictive,andtherebypreventingthatshamefulmarket,whichhadbeenmadeinthepersonsofheirs,andthemostsacredthingsamongstmankind。 TherewereotherprovisionsmadeintheGreatCharter,thatwentdeeperthanthefeudaltenure,andaffectedthewholebodyofthecivilgovernment。Agreatpartoftheking’srevenuethenconsistedinthefinesandamercements,whichwereimposedinhiscourts。Afinewaspaidthereforlibertytocommence,ortoconcludeasuit。Thepunishmentofoffencesbyfinewasdiscretionary;andthisdiscretionarypowerhadbeenverymuchabused。ButbyMagnaChartathingsweresoordered,thatadelinquentmightbepunished,butnotruined,byafineoramercement,becausethedegreeofhisoffence,andtherankheheld,weretobetakenintoconsideration。Hisfreehold,hismerchandise,andthoseinstruments,bywhichheobtainedhislivelihood,weremadesacredfromsuchimpositions。Amoregrandreformwasmadewithregardtotheadministrationofjustice。Thekingsinthosedaysseldomresidedlonginoneplace,andtheircourtsfollowedtheirpersons。Thiserraticjusticemusthavebeenproductiveofinfiniteinconveniencetothelitigants。Itwasnowprovided,thatcivilsuits,calledCOMMONPLEAS,shouldbefixedtosomecertainplace。Thusonebranchofjurisdictionwasseparatedfromtheking’scourt,anddetachedfromhisperson。Theyhadnotyetcometothatmaturityofjurisprudenceastothinkthismightbemadetoextendtocriminallawalso;andthatthelatterwasanobjectofstillgreaterimportance。Buteventheformermaybeconsideredasagreatrevolution。Atribunal,acreatureofmerelaw,independentofpersonalpower,wasestablished,andthisseparationofaking’sauthorityfromhispersonwasamatterofvastconsequencetowardsintroducingideasoffreedom,andconfirmingthesacrednessandmajestyoflaws。 Butthegrandarticle,andthatwhichcementedallthepartsofthefabricofliberty,wasthis:“thatnofreemanshallbetakenorimprisoned,ordisseized,oroutlawed,orbanished,orinanywisedestroyed,butbyjudgmentofhispeers。” Thereisanotherarticleofnearlyasmuchconsequenceastheformer,consideringthestateofthenationatthattime,bywhichitisprovided,thatthebaronsshallgranttotheirtenantsthesamelibertieswhichtheyhadstipulatedforthemselves。Thispreventedthekingdomfromdegeneratingintotheworstimaginablegovernment,afeudalaristocracy。TheEnglishbaronswerenotintheconditionofthosegreatprinces,whohadmadetheFrenchmonarchysolowintheprecedingcentury;orlikethose,whoreducedtheimperialpowertoaname。TheyhadbeenbroughttomoderateboundsbythepolicyofthefirstandsecondHenrys,andwerenotinaconditiontosetupforpettysovereignsbyanusurpationequallydetrimentaltotheCrownandthepeople。Theywereabletoactonlyinconfederacy;andthiscommoncausemadeitnecessarytoconsultthecommongood,andtostudypopularitybytheequityoftheirproceedings。Thiswasaveryhappycircumstancestothegrowingliberty。 EUROPEANDTHENORMANINVASION。 Beforetheperiodofwhichwearegoingtotreat,EnglandwaslittleknownorconsideredinEurope。Theirsituation,theirdomesticcalamities,andtheirignorance,circumscribedtheviewsandpoliticsoftheEnglishwithintheboundsoftheirownisland。ButtheNormanconquerorthrewdownallthesebarriers。TheEnglishlaws,manners,andmaxims,weresuddenlychanged;thescenewasenlarged;andthecommunicationwiththerestofEuropebeingthusopened,hasbeenpreservedeversinceinacontinuedseriesofwarsandnegotiations。 Thatwemaythereforeentermorefullyintothematterswhichliebeforeus,itisnecessarythatweunderstandthestateoftheneighbouringcontinentatthetimewhenthisislandfirstcametobeinterestedinitsaffairs。 Thenorthernnations,whohadoverruntheRomanempire,wereatfirstratheractuatedbyavaricethanambition,andweremoreintentuponplunderthanconquest;theywerecarriedbeyondtheiroriginalpurposes,whentheybegantoformregulargovernments,forwhichtheyhadbeenpreparedbynojustideasoflegislation。Foralongtime,therefore,therewaslittleoforderintheiraffairs,orforesightintheirdesigns。TheGoths,theBurgundians,theFranks,theVandals,theSuevi,aftertheyhadprevailedovertheRomanempire,byturnsprevailedovereachotherincontinualwars,whichwerecarriedonuponnoprinciplesofadeterminatepolicy,enteredintouponmotivesofbrutalityandcaprice,andendedasfortuneandrudeviolencechancedtoprevail。 Tumult,anarchy,confusion,overspreadthefaceofEurope;andanobscurityrestsuponthetransactionsofthattime,whichsuffersustodiscovernothingbutitsextremebarbarity。 Beforethiscloudcouldbedispersed,theSaracens,anotherbodyofbarbariansfromthesouth,animatedbyafurynotunlikethat,whichgavestrengthtothenorthernirruptions,butheightenedbyenthusiasm,andregulatedbysubordinationanduniformpolicy,begantocarrytheirarms,theirmanners,andreligionintoeverypartoftheuniverse。Spainwasentirelyoverwhelmedbythetorrentoftheirarmies;Italy,andtheislands,wereharassedbytheirfleets,andallEuropealarmedbytheirvigorousandfrequententerprises。Italy,whohadsolongsatthemistressoftheworld,wasbyturnstheslaveofallnations。ThepossessionofthatfinecountrywashotlydisputedbetweentheGreekemperorandtheLombards,anditsufferedinfinitelybythatcontention。 Germany,theparentofsomanynations,wasexhaustedbytheswarmsshehadsentabroad。However,inthemidstofthischaostherewereprinciplesatwork,whichreducedthingstoacertainform,andgraduallyunfoldedasystem,inwhichthechiefmoversandmainspringswerethepapalandtheimperialpowers;theaggrandisementordiminutionofwhichhavebeenthedriftofalmostallthepolitics,intrigues,andwars,whichhaveemployedanddistractedEuropetothisday。 FromRomethewholewesternworldhadreceiveditsChristianity。Shewastheasylumofwhatlearninghadescapedthegeneraldesolation;andeveninherruinsshepreservedsomethingofthemajestyofherancientgreatness。Ontheseaccountsshehadarespectandaweight,whichincreasedeverydayamongstasimplereligiouspeople,wholookedbutalittlewayintotheconsequencesoftheiractions。Therudenessoftheworldwasveryfavourablefortheestablishmentofanempireofopinion。 Themoderationwithwhichthepopesatfirstexertedthisempire,madeitsgrowthunfeltuntilitcouldnolongerbeopposed。Andthepolicyoflaterpopes,buildingonthepietyofthefirst,continuallyincreasedit;andtheymadeuseofeveryinstrumentbutthatofforce。Theyemployedequallythevirtuesandthecrimesofthegreat;theyfavouredthelustofkingsforabsoluteauthority,andthedesireofsubjectsforliberty;theyprovokedwar,andmediatedpeace;andtookadvantageofeveryturninthemindsofmen,whetherofapublicorprivatenature,toextendtheirinfluence,andpushtheirpowerfromecclesiasticaltocivil;fromsubjectiontoindependency;fromindependencytoempire。 FrancehadmanyadvantagesovertheotherpartsofEurope。TheSaracenshadnopermanentsuccessinthatcountry。Thesamehand,whichexpelledthoseinvaders,deposedthelastofaraceofheavyanddegenerateprinces,morelikeeasternmonarchsthanGermanleaders,andwhohadneithertheforcetorepeltheenemiesoftheirkingdom,nortoasserttheirownsovereignty。Thisusurpationplacedonthethroneprincesofanothercharacter;princes,whowereobligedtosupplytheirwantoftitlebythevigouroftheiradministration。TheFrenchmonarchhadneedofsomegreatandrespectedauthoritytothrowaveiloverhisusurpation,andtosanctifyhisnewly-acquiredpowerbythosenamesandappearances,whicharenecessarytomakeitrespectabletothepeople。 Ontheotherhand,thepope,whohatedtheGrecianempire,andequallyfearedthesuccessoftheLombards,sawwithjoythisnewstarariseinthenorth,andgaveitthesanctionofhisauthority。Presentlyafterhecalledittohisassistance。PepinpassedtheAlps,relievedthepope,andinvestedhimwiththedominionofalargecountryinthebestpartofItaly。 Charlemagnepursuedthecoursewhichwasmarkedoutforhim,andputanendtotheLombardkingdom,weakenedbythepolicyofhisfather,andtheenmityofthepopes,whoneverwillinglysawastrongpowerinItaly。Thenhereceivedfromthehandofthepopetheimperialcrown,sanctifiedbytheauthorityoftheHolySee,andwithitthetitleofemperoroftheRomans;anamevenerablefromthefameoftheoldempire,andwhichwassupposedtocarrygreatandunknownprerogatives;andthustheempireroseagainoutofitsruinsintheWest;andwhatisremarkable,bymeansofoneofthosenationswhichhadhelpedtodestroyit。IfwetakeintheconquestsofCharlemagne,itwasalsoverynearasextensiveasformerly;thoughitsconstitutionwasaltogetherdifferent,asbeingentirelyonthenorthernmodelofgovernment。 FromCharlemagnethepopereceivedinreturnanenlargementandaconfirmationofhisnewterritory。Thusthepapalandimperialpowersmutuallygavebirthtoeachother。Theycontinuedforsomeages,and,insomemeasure,stillcontinuecloselyconnected,withavarietyofpretensionsuponeachother,andontherestofEurope。ThoughtheimperialpowerhaditsorigininFrance,itwassoondividedintotwobranches,theGallicandtheGerman。Thelatteralonesupportedthetitleofempire;butthepowerbeingweakenedbythisdivision,thepapalpretensionshadthegreaterweight。Thepope,becausehefirstrevivedtheimperialdignity,claimedarightofdisposingofit,oratleastofgivingvaliditytotheelectionoftheemperor。Theemperor,ontheotherhand,rememberingtherightsofthosesovereigns,whosetitlehebore,andhowlatelythepower,whichinsultedhimwithsuchdemands,hadarisenfromthebountyofhispredecessors,claimedthesameprivilegesintheelectionofapope。Theclaimsofbothweresomewhatplausible;andtheyweresupported,theonebyforceofarms,andtheotherbyecclesiasticalinfluence,powerswhichinthosedayswereverynearlybalanced。Italywasthetheatreuponwhichthisprizewasdisputed。Ineverycitythepartiesinfavourofeachoftheopponentswerenotfarfromanequalityintheirnumbersandstrength。Whilstthesepartiesdisagreedinthechoiceofamaster,bycontendingforachoiceintheirsubjection,theygrewimperceptiblyintofreedom,andpassedthroughthemediumoffactionandanarchyintoregularcommonwealths。ThusarosetherepublicsofVenice,ofGenoa,ofFlorence,Sienna,andPisa,andseveralothers。Thesecities,establishedinthisfreedom,turnedthefrugalandingeniousspiritcontractedinsuchcommunitiestonavigationandtraffic;andpursuingthemwithskillandvigour,whilstcommercewasneglectedanddespisedbytherusticgentryofthemartialgovernments,theygrewtoaconsiderabledegreeofwealth,power,andcivility。 TheDanes,whointhislattertimepreservedthespiritandthenumbersoftheancientGothicpeople,hadseatedthemselvesinEngland,intheLowCountries,andinNormandy。TheypassedfromthencetothesouthernpartofEurope,andinthisromanticagegaveriseinSicilyandNaplestoanewkingdom,andanewlineofprinces。 AllthekingdomsonthecontinentofEuropeweregovernednearlyinthesameform;fromwhencearoseagreatsimilitudeinthemannersoftheirinhabitants。Thefeodaldisciplineextendeditselfeverywhere,andinfluencedtheconductofthecourts,andthemannersofthepeople,withitsownirregularmartialspirit。Subjects,underthecomplicatedlawsofavariousandrigorousservitude,exercisedalltheprerogativesofsovereignpower。Theydistributedjustice,theymadewarandpeaceatpleasure。Thesovereign,withgreatpretensions,hadbutlittlepower; hewasonlyagreaterlordamonggreatlords,whoprofitedofthedifferencesofhispeers;thereforenosteadyplancouldbewellpursued,eitherinwarorpeace。Thisdayaprinceseemedirresistibleattheheadofhisnumerousvassals,becausetheirdutyobligedthemtowar,andtheyperformedthisdutywithpleasure。Thenextdaysawthisformidablepowervanishlikeadream,becausethisfierceundisciplinedpeoplehadnopatience,andthetimeofthefeudalservicewascontainedwithinverynarrowlimits。Itwasthereforeeasytofindanumberofpersonsatalltimesreadytofollowanystandard,butitwashardtocompleteaconsiderabledesign,whichrequiredaregularandcontinuedmovement。Thisenterprisingdispositioninthegentrywasverygeneral,becausetheyhadlittleoccupationorpleasurebutinwar;andthegreatestrewardsdidthenattendpersonalvalourandprowess。Allthatprofessedarms,becameinsomesortonanequality。Aknightwasthepeerofaking;andmenhadbeenusedtoseethebraveryofprivatepersonsopeningaroadtothatdignity。Thetemerityofadventurerswasmuchjustifiedbytheillorderofeverystate,whichleftitapreytoalmostanywhoshouldattackitwithsufficientvigour。Thus,littlecheckedbyanysuperiorpower,fulloffire,impetuosity,andignorance,theylongedtosignalizethemselveswhereveranhonourabledangercalledthem;andwhereverthatinvited,theydidnotweighverydeliberatelytheprobabilityofsuccess。Theknowledgeofthisgeneraldispositioninthemindsofmenwillnaturallyremoveagreatdealofourwonderatseeinganattempt,foundedonsuchslenderappearancesofright,andsupportedbyapowersolittleproportionedtotheundertakingasthatofWilliam,sowarmlyembracedandsogenerallyfollowed,notonlybyhisownsubjects,butbyalltheneighbouringpotentates。ThecountsofAnjou,Bretagne,Ponthieu,Boulogne,andPoictou,sovereignprinces; adventurersfromeveryquarterofFrance,theNetherlands,andtheremotestpartsofGermany,layingasidetheirjealousiesandenmitiestooneanother,aswellastoWilliam,ranwithaninconceivableardourintothisenterprise;captivatedwiththesplendouroftheobject,whichobliteratedallthoughtsoftheuncertaintyoftheevent。Williamkeptupthisfervourbypromisesoflargeterritoriestoallhisalliesandassociatesinthecountrytobereducedbytheirunitedefforts。Butafterallitbecameequallynecessarytoreconciletohisenterprisethethreegreatpowers,ofwhomwehavejustspoken,whosedispositionmusthavehadthemostinfluenceonhisaffairs。 HisfeudallordthekingofFrancewasboundbyhismostobviousintereststoopposethefurtheraggrandisementofonealreadytoopotentforavassal;butthekingofFrancewasthenaminor;andBaldwin,earlofFlanders,whosedaughterWilliamhadmarried,wasregentofthekingdom。ThiscircumstancerenderedtheremonstranceoftheFrenchcouncilagainsthisdesignofnoeffect;indeedtheoppositionofthecouncilitselfwasfaint;theideaofhavingakingundervassalagetotheircrownmighthavedazzledthemoresuperficialcourtiers;whilstthose,whothoughtmoredeeply,wereunwillingtodiscourageanenterprise,whichtheybelievedwouldprobablyendintheruinoftheundertaker。Theemperorwasinhisminority,aswellasthekingofFrance;butbywhatartsthedukeprevailedupontheimperialcounciltodeclareinhisfavour,whetherornobyanideaofcreatingabalancetothepowerofFrance,ifwecanimaginethatanysuchideathensubsisted,isaltogetheruncertain;butitiscertain,thatheobtainedleaveforthevassalsoftheempiretoengageinhisservice,andthathemadeuseofthispermission。Thepope’sconsentwasobtainedwithstilllessdifficulty。Williamhadshownhimselfinmanyinstancesafriendtothechurch,andafavoureroftheclergy。OnthisoccasionhepromisedtoimprovethosehappybeginningsinproportiontothemeansheshouldacquirebythefavouroftheHolySee。ItissaidthatheevenproposedtoholdhisnewkingdomasafieffromRome。Thepope,therefore,enteredheartilyintohisinterests;heexcommunicatedallthosethatshouldopposehisenterprise,andsenthim,asameansofensuringsuccess,aconsecratedbanner。 ANCIENTINHABITANTSOFBRITAIN。 ThatBritainwasfirstpeopledfromGaul,weareassuredbythebestproofs:proximityofsituation,andresemblanceinlanguageandmanners。Ofthetimeinwhichthiseventhappened,wemustbecontentedtoremaininignorance,forwehavenomonuments。Butwemayconcludethatitwasaveryancientsettlement,sincetheCarthaginiansfoundthisislandinhabitedwhentheytradedhitherfortin;asthePhoenicians,whosetrackstheyfollowedinthiscommerce,aresaidtohavedonelongbeforethem。Itistrue,thatwhenweconsidertheshortintervalbetweentheuniversaldelugeandthatperiod,andcompareitwiththefirstsettlementofmenatsuchadistancefromthiscorneroftheworld,itmayseemnoteasytoreconcilesuchaclaimtoantiquitywiththeonlyauthenticaccountwehaveoftheoriginandprogressofmankind;especiallyasinthoseearlyagesthewholefaceofnaturewasextremelyrudeanduncultivated;whenthelinksofcommerce,eveninthecountriesfirstsettled,werefewandweak;navigationimperfect;geographyunknown; andthehardshipsoftravellingexcessive。Butthespiritofmigration,ofwhichwehavenowonlysomefaintideas,wasthenstronganduniversal;anditfullycompensatedallthesedisadvantages。Manywritersindeedimagine,thatthesemigrations,socommonintheprimitivetimes,werecausedbytheprodigiousincreaseofpeoplebeyondwhattheirseveralterritoriescouldmaintain。Butthisopinion,farfrombeingsupported,israthercontradictedbythegeneralappearanceofthingsinthatearlytime,whenineverycountryvasttractsoflandweresufferedtoliealmostuselessinmorassesandforests。Norisit,indeed,morecountenancedbytheancientmodesoflife,nowayfavourabletopopulation。Iapprehendthatthesefirstsettledcountries,sofarfrombeingoverstockedwithinhabitants,wereratherthinlypeopled;andthatthesamecauses,whichoccasionedthatthinness,occasionedalsothosefrequentmigrations,whichmakesolargeapartofthefirsthistoryofalmostallnations。Forintheseagesmensubsistedchieflybypasturageorhunting。Theseareoccupationswhichspreadthepeoplewithoutmultiplyingtheminproportion;theyteachthemanextensiveknowledgeofthecountry,theycarrythemfrequentlyandfarfromtheirhomes,andweakenthosetieswhichmightattachthemtoanyparticularhabitation。 Itwasinagreatdegreefromthismanneroflife,thatmankindbecamescatteredintheearliesttimesoverthewholeglobe。Buttheirpeacefuloccupationsdidnotcontributesomuchtothatend,astheirwars,whichwerenotthelessfrequentandviolentbecausethepeoplewerefew,andtheinterestsforwhichtheycontendedofbutsmallimportance。Ancienthistoryhasfurnisheduswithmanyinstancesofwholenations,expelledbyinvasion,fallinginuponothers,whichtheyhaveentirelyoverwhelmed;moreirresistibleintheirdefeatandruinthanintheirfullestprosperity。Therightsofwarwerethenexercisedwithgreatinhumanity。Acrueldeath,oraservitudescarcelylesscruel,wasthecertainfateofallconqueredpeople;theterrorofwhichhurriedmenfromhabitationstowhichtheywerebutlittleattached,toseeksecurityandreposeunderanyclimate,thathoweverinotherrespectsundesirable,mightaffordthemrefugefromthefuryoftheirenemies。 Thusthebleakandbarrenregionsofthenorth,notbeingpeopledbychoice,werepeopledasearly,inallprobability,asmanyofthemilderandmoreinvitingclimatesofthesouthernworld,andthus,byawonderfuldispositionoftheDivineProvidence,alifeofhunting,whichdoesnotcontributetoincrease,andwar,whichisthegreatinstrumentinthedestructionofmen,werethetwoprincipalcausesoftheirbeingspreadsoearlyandsouniversallyoverthewholeearth。FromwhatisverycommonlyknownofthestateofNorthAmerica,itneednotbesaid,howoften,andtowhatdistance,severalofthenationsonthatcontinentareusedtomigrate;who,thoughthinlyscattered,occupyanimmenseextentofcountry。Norarethecausesofitlessobvious——theirhuntinglife,andtheirinhumanwars。 Suchmigrations,sometimesbychoice,morefrequentlyfromnecessity,werecommonintheancientworld。Frequentnecessitiesintroducedafashion,whichsubsistedaftertheoriginalcauses。Forhowcouldithappen,butfromsomeuniversallyestablishedpublicprejudice,whichalwaysoverrulesandstiflestheprivatesenseofmen,thatawholenationshoulddeliberatelythinkitawisemeasuretoquittheircountryinabody,thattheymightobtaininaforeignlandasettlement,whichmustwhollydependuponthechanceofwar?Yetthisresolutionwastaken,andactuallypursuedbytheentirenationoftheHelvetii,asitisminutelyrelatedbyCaesar。Themethodofreasoningwhichledthemtoit,mustappeartousatthisdayutterlyinconceivable;theywerefarfrombeingcompelledtothisextraordinarymigrationbyanywantofsubsistenceathome;foritappearsthattheyraisedwithoutdifficultyasmuchcorninoneyearassupportedthemfortwo;theycouldnotcomplainofthebarrennessofsuchasoil。 Thisspiritofmigration,whichgrewoutoftheancientmannersandnecessities,andsometimesoperatedlikeablindinstinct,suchasactuatesbirdsofpassage,isverysufficienttoaccountfortheearlyhabitationoftheremotestpartsoftheearth;andinsomesortalsojustifiesthatclaimwhichhasbeensofondlymadebyalmostallnationstogreatantiquity。Gaul,fromwhenceBritainwasoriginallypeopled,consistedofthreenations;theBelgaetowardsthenorth;theCeltaeinthemiddlecountries;andtheAquitanitothesouth。Britainappearstohavereceiveditspeopleonlyfromthetwoformer。FromtheCeltaewerederivedthemostancienttribesoftheBritons,ofwhichthemostconsiderablewerecalledBrigantes。TheBelgae,whodidnotevensettleinGauluntilafterBritainhadbeenpeopledbycoloniesfromtheformer,forciblydrovetheBrigantesintotheinlandcountries,andpossessedthegreatestpartofthecoast,especiallytothesouthandwest。Theselatter,astheyenteredtheislandinamoreimprovedage,broughtwiththemtheknowledgeandpracticeofagriculture,whichhoweveronlyprevailedintheirowncountries;theBrigantesstillcontinuedtheirancientwayoflifebypasturageandhunting。Inthisrespectalonetheydiffered;sothatwhatweshallsayintreatingoftheirmannersisequallyapplicabletoboth。AndthoughtheBritonswerefurtherdividedintoaninnumerablemultitudeoflessertribesandnations,yetallbeingthebranchesofthesetwostocks,itisnottoourpurposetoconsiderthemmoreminutely。 BritainwasinthetimeofJuliusCaesar,whatitisatthisdayinclimateandnaturaladvantages,temperate,andreasonablyfertile。Butdestituteofallthoseimprovements,whichinasuccessionofagesithasreceivedfromingenuity,fromcommerce,fromrichesandluxury,itthenworeaveryroughandsavageappearance。Thecountry,forestormarsh;thehabitations,cottages;thecities,hiding-placesinwoods; thepeople,naked,oronlycoveredwithskins;theirsoleemployment,pasturageandhunting。Theypaintedtheirbodiesforornamentorterror,byacustomgeneralamongallsavagenations;whobeingpassionatelyfondofshowandfinery,andhavingnoobjectbuttheirnakedbodiesonwhichtoexercisethisdisposition,haveinalltimespaintedorcuttheirskins,accordingtotheirideasofornament。Theyshavedthebeardonthechin;thatontheupperlipwassufferedtoremain,andgrowtoanextraordinarylength,tofavourthemartialappearance,inwhichtheyplacedtheirglory。TheywereintheirnaturaltempernotunliketheGauls;impatient,fiery,inconstant,ostentatious,boastful,fondofnovelty;andlikeallbarbarians,fierce,treacherous,andcruel。Theirarmswereshortjavelins,smallshieldsofaslighttexture,andgreatcuttingswordswithabluntpoint,aftertheGaulishfashion。 Theirchiefswenttobattleinchariots,notunartfullycontrived,norunskilfullymanaged。Icannothelpthinkingitsomethingextraordinary,andnoteasilytobeaccountedfor,thattheBritonsshouldhavebeensoexpertinthefabricofthosechariots,whentheyseemutterlyignorantinallothermechanicarts:butthusitisdeliveredtous。Theyhadalsohorse,thoughofnogreatreputationintheirarmies。Theirfootwaswithoutheavyarmour;itwasnofirmbody;norinstructedtopreservetheirranks,tomaketheirevolutions,ortoobeytheircommanders;butintoleratinghardships,indexterityofformingambuscades(theartmilitaryofsavages),theyaresaidtohaveexcelled。Anaturalferocity,andanimpetuousonset,stoodthemintheplaceofdiscipline。 PUBLICPROSECUTIONS。 Publicprosecutionsarebecomelittlebetterthanschoolsfortreason;ofnousebuttoimprovethedexterityofcriminalsinthemysteryofevasion;ortoshowwithwhatcompleteimpunitymenmayconspireagainstthecommonwealth;withwhatsafetyassassinsmayattemptitsawfulhead。Everythingissecure,exceptwhatthelawshavemadesacred;everythingistamenessandlanguorthatisnotfuryandfaction。Whilstthedistempersofarelaxedfibreprognosticateandprepareallthemorbidforceofconvulsioninthebodyofthestate,thesteadinessofthephysicianisoverpoweredbytheveryaspectofthedisease。Thedoctoroftheconstitution,pretendingtounderratewhatheisnotabletocontendwith,shrinksfromhisownoperation。Hedoubtsandquestionsthesalutarybutcriticalterrorsofthecauteryandtheknife。Hetakesapoorcreditevenfromhisdefeat,andcoversimpotenceunderthemaskoflenity。Hepraisesthemoderationofthelaws,as,inhishands,heseesthembaffledanddespised。Isallthis,becauseinourdaythestatutesofthekingdomarenotengrossedinasfirmacharacter,andimprintedinasblackandlegibleatypeasever?No!thelawisaclear,butitisadeadletter。Deadandputrid,itisinsufficienttosavethestate,butpotenttoinfectandtokill。Livinglaw,fullofreason,andofequityandjustice(asitis,oritshouldnotexist),oughttobesevereandawfultoo;orthewordsofmenace,whetherwrittenontheparchmentrollofEngland,orcutintothebrazentabletofRome,willexcitenothingbutcontempt。Howcomesit,thatinallthestateprosecutionsofmagnitude,fromtheRevolutiontowithinthesetwoorthreeyears,theCrownhasscarcelyeverretireddisgracedanddefeatedfromitscourts?Whencethisalarmingchange?Byaconnectioneasilyfelt,andnotimpossibletobetracedtoitscause,allthepartsofthestatehavetheircorrespondenceandconsent。 Theywhobowtotheenemyabroad,willnotbeofpowertosubduetheconspiratorathome。Itisimpossiblenottoobserve,that,inproportionasweapproximatetothepoisonousjawsofanarchy,thefascinationgrowsirresistible。Inproportionasweareattractedtowardsthefocusofillegality,irreligion,anddesperateenterprise,allthevenomousandblightinginsectsofthestateareawakenedintolife。Thepromiseoftheyearisblasted,andshrivelledandburnedupbeforethem。Ourmostsalutaryandmostbeautifulinstitutionsyieldnothingbutdustandsmut;theharvestofourlawisnomorethanstubble。Itisinthenatureoftheseeruptivediseasesinthestatetosinkinbyfits,andre-appear。Butthefuelofthemaladyremains;andinmyopinionisnotinthesmallestdegreemitigatedinitsmalignity,thoughitwaitsthefavourablemomentofafreercommunicationwiththesourceofregicidetoexertandtoincreaseitsforce。 Isitthatthepeoplearechanged,thatthecommonwealthcannotbeprotectedbyitslaws?Ihardlythinkit。Onthecontrary,Iconceivethatthesethingshappenbecausemenarenotchanged,butremainalwayswhattheyalwayswere;theyremainwhatthebulkofusevermustbe,whenabandonedtoourvulgarpropensities,withoutguide,leader,orcontrol;thatis,madetobefullofablindelevationinprosperity;todespiseuntrieddangers;tobeoverpoweredwithunexpectedreverses;tofindnoclueinalabyrinthofdifficulties,togetoutofapresentinconveniencewithanyriskoffutureruin;tofollowandtobowtofortune;toadmiresuccessfulthoughwickedenterprise,andtoimitatewhatweadmire;tocontemnthegovernmentwhichannouncesdangerfromsacrilegeandregicide,whilsttheyareonlyintheirinfancyandtheirstruggle,butwhichfindsnothingthatcanalarmintheiradultstate,andinthepowerandtriumphofthosedestructiveprinciples。Inamasswecannotbelefttoourselves。Wemusthaveleaders。Ifnonewillundertaketoleadusright,weshallfindguideswhowillcontrivetoconductustoshameandruin。 TRUENATUREOFAJACOBINWAR。 Astome,Iwasalwayssteadilyofopinion,thatthisdisorderwasnotinitsnatureintermittent。Iconceivedthatthecontest,oncebegun,couldnotbelaiddownagain,toberesumedatourdiscretion;butthatourfirststrugglewiththisevilwouldalsobeourlast。Ineverthoughtwecouldmakepeacewiththesystem;becauseitwasnotforthesakeofanobjectwepursuedinrivalrywitheachother,butwiththesystemitself,thatwewereatwar。AsIunderstoodthematter,wewereatwarnotwithitsconduct,butwithitsexistence;convincedthatitsexistenceanditshostilitywerethesame。 Thefactionisnotlocalorterritorial。Itisageneralevil。Whereitleastappearsinaction,itisstillfulloflife。Initssleepitrecruitsitsstrength,andpreparesitsexertion。Itsspiritliesdeepinthecorruptionofourcommonnature。Thesocialorderwhichrestrainsit,feedsit。ItexistsineverycountryinEurope;andamongallordersofmenineverycountry,wholookuptoFranceastoacommonhead。Thecentreisthere。ThecircumferenceistheworldofEuropewherevertheraceofEuropemaybesettled。Everywhereelsethefactionismilitant; inFranceitistriumphant。InFranceisthebankofdeposit,andthebankofcirculation,ofalltheperniciousprinciplesthatareformingineverystate。Itwillbeafollyscarcelydeservingofpity,andtoomischievousforcontempt,tothinkofrestrainingitinanyothercountrywhilstitispredominantthere。War,insteadofbeingthecauseofitsforce,hassuspendeditsoperation。Ithasgivenareprieve,atleast,totheChristianworld。ThetruenatureofaJacobinwar,inthebeginning,was,bymostoftheChristianpowers,felt,acknowledged,andeveninthemostprecisemannerdeclared。Inthejointmanifesto,publishedbytheemperorandthekingofPrussia,onthe4thofAugust,1792,itisexpressedintheclearestterms,andonprincipleswhichcouldnotfail,iftheyhadadheredtothem,ofclassingthosemonarchswiththefirstbenefactorsofmankind。Thismanifestowaspublished,astheythemselvesexpressit,“tolayopentothepresentgeneration,aswellastoposterity,theirmotives,theirintentions,andtheDISINTERESTEDNESSoftheirpersonalviews;takinguparmsforthepurposeofpreservingsocialandpoliticalorderamongstallcivilizednations,andtosecuretoEACHstateitsreligion,happiness,independence,territories,andrealconstitution。”——“Onthisground,theyhopedthatallempiresandallstateswouldbeunanimous;andbecomingthefirmguardiansofthehappinessofmankind,thattheycouldnotfailtounitetheireffortstorescueanumerousnationfromitsownfury,topreserveEuropefromthereturnofbarbarism,andtheuniversefromthesubversionandanarchywithwhichitwasthreatened。”Thewholeofthatnobleperformanceoughttobereadatthefirstmeetingofanycongress,whichmayassembleforthepurposeofpacification。Inthatpeace“thesepowersexpresslyrenounceallviewsofpersonalaggrandisement,“andconfinethemselvestoobjectsworthyofsogenerous,soheroic,andsoperfectlywiseandpoliticanenterprise。Itwastotheprinciplesofthisconfederation,andtonoother,thatwewishedoursovereignandourcountrytoaccede,asapartofthecommonwealthofEurope。Totheseprinciples,withsometriflingexceptionsandlimitations,theydidfullyaccede。(SeeDeclaration,Whitehall,October29,1793。)Andallourfriendswhotookofficeaccededtotheministry(whetherwiselyornot),asIalwaysunderstoodthematter,onthefaithandontheprinciplesofthatdeclaration。 Aslongasthesepowersflatteredthemselvesthatthemenaceofforcewouldproducetheeffectofforce,theyactedonthosedeclarations:butwhentheirmenacesfailedofsuccess,theireffortstookanewdirection。Itdidnotappeartothemthatvirtueandheroismoughttobepurchasedbymillionsofrix-dollars。Itisadreadfultruth,butitisatruththatcannotbeconcealed;inability,indexterity,inthedistinctnessoftheirviews,theJacobinsareoursuperiors。Theysawthethingrightfromtheverybeginning。Whateverwerethefirstmotivestothewaramongpoliticians,theysawthatinitsspirit,andforitsobjects,itwasaCIVILWAR;andassuchtheypursuedit。Itisawarbetweenthepartisansoftheancient,civil,moral,andpoliticalorderofEurope,againstasectoffanaticalandambitiousatheistswhichmeanstochangethemall。ItisnotFranceextendingaforeignempireoverothernations:itisasectaimingatuniversalempire,andbeginningwiththeconquestofFrance。TheleadersofthatsectsecuredtheCENTREOFEUROPE;andthatsecured,theyknew,thatwhatevermightbetheeventofbattlesandsieges,theirCAUSEwasvictorious。Whetheritsterritoryhadalittlemoreoralittlelesspeeledfromitssurface,orwhetheranislandortwowasdetachedfromitscommerce,tothemwasoflittlemoment。TheconquestofFrancewasagloriousacquisition。Thatoncewelllaidasabasisofempire,opportunitiesnevercouldbewantingtoregainortoreplacewhathadbeenlost,anddreadfullytoavengethemselvesonthefactionoftheiradversaries。 TheysawitwasaCIVILWAR。ItwastheirbusinesstopersuadetheiradversariesthatitoughttobeaFOREIGNwar。TheJacobinseverywheresetupacryagainstthenewcrusade;andtheyintriguedwitheffectinthecabinet,inthefield,andineveryprivatesocietyinEurope。Theirtaskwasnotdifficult。Theconditionofprinces,andsometimesoffirstministerstoo,istobepitied。Thecreaturesofthedesk,andthecreaturesoffavour,hadnorelishfortheprinciplesofthemanifestoes。Theypromisednogovernments,noregiments,norevenuesfromwhenceemolumentsmightarisebyperquisiteorbygrant。Intruth,thetribeofvulgarpoliticiansarethelowestofourspecies。Thereisnotradesovileandmechanicalasgovernmentintheirhands。Virtueisnottheirhabit。Theyareoutofthemselvesinanycourseofconductrecommendedonlybyconscienceandglory。Alarge,liberal,andprospectiveviewoftheinterestsofstatespasseswiththemforromance;andtheprinciplesthatrecommendit,forthewanderingsofadisorderedimagination。Thecalculatorscomputethemoutoftheirsenses。Thejestersandbuffoonsshamethemoutofeverythinggrandandelevated。Littlenessinobjectandinmeans,tothemappearssoundnessandsobriety。Theythinkthereisnothingworthpursuit,butthatwhichtheycanhandle;whichtheycanmeasurewithatwo-footrule;whichtheycantellupontenfingers。 WithouttheprinciplesoftheJacobins,perhapswithoutanyprinciplesatall,theyplayedthegameofthatfaction。Therewasabeatenroadbeforethem。ThepowersofEuropewerearmed;Francehadalwaysappeareddangerous;thewarwaseasilydivertedfromFranceasafaction,toFranceasastate。Theprinceswereeasilytaughttoslidebackintotheirold,habitualcourseofpolitics。TheywereeasilyledtoconsidertheflamesthatwereconsumingFrance,notasawarningtoprotecttheirownbuildings(whichwerewithoutanyparty-wall,andlinkedbyacontignationintotheedificeofFrance),butasahappyoccasionforpillagingthegoods,andforcarryingoffthematerials,oftheirneighbour’shouse。Theirprovidentfearswerechangedintoavaricioushopes。Theycarriedontheirnewdesignswithoutseemingtoabandontheprinciplesoftheiroldpolicy。Theypretendedtoseek,ortheyflatteredthemselvesthattheysought,intheaccessionofnewfortresses,andnewterritories,aDEFENSIVEsecurity。Butthesecuritywantedwasagainstakindofpower,whichwasnotsotrulydangerousinitsfortressesnorinitsterritories,asinitsspiritanditsprinciples。Theyaimed,orpretendedtoaim,atDEFENDINGthemselvesagainstadangerfromwhichtherecanbenosecurityinanyDEFENSIVE plan。Ifarmiesandfortresseswereadefenceagainstjacobinism,LouistheSixteenthwouldthisdayreignapowerfulmonarchoverahappypeople。 Thiserrorobligedthem,evenintheiroffensiveoperations,toadoptaplanofwar,againstthesuccessofwhichtherewassomethinglittleshortofmathematicaldemonstration。Theyrefusedtotakeanystepwhichmightstrikeattheheartofaffairs。Theyseemedunwillingtowoundtheenemyinanyvitalpart。Theyactedthroughthewhole,asiftheyreallywishedtheconservationoftheJacobinpower,aswhatmightbemorefavourablethanthelawfulgovernmenttotheattainmentofthepettyobjectstheylookedfor。Theyalwayskeptonthecircumference;andthewiderandremoterthecirclewas,themoreeagerlytheychoseitastheirsphereofactioninthiscentrifugalwar。Theplantheypursued,initsnaturedemandedgreatlengthoftime。Initsexecution,they,whowentthenearestwaytowork,wereobligedtocoveranincredibleextentofcountry。Itlefttotheenemyeverymeansofdestroyingthisextendedlineofweakness。Illsuccessinanypartwassuretodefeattheeffectofthewhole。ThisistrueofAustria。ItisstillmoretrueofEngland。 Onthisfalseplan,evengoodfortune,byfurtherweakeningthevictor,puthimbutthefurtherofffromhisobject。 Aslongastherewasanyappearanceofsuccess,thespiritofaggrandisement,andconsequentlythespiritofmutualjealousy,seizeduponallthecoalescedpowers。SomesoughtanaccessionofterritoryattheexpenseofFrance,someattheexpenseofeachother,someattheexpenseofthirdparties;andwhenthevicissitudeofdisastertookitsturn,theyfoundcommondistressatreacherousbondoffaithandfriendship。Thegreatestskillconductingthegreatestmilitaryapparatushasbeenemployed;butithasbeenworsethanuselesslyemployed,throughthefalsepolicyofthewar。Theoperationsofthefieldsufferedbytheerrorsofthecabinet。Ifthesamespiritcontinueswhenpeaceismade,thepeacewillfixandperpetuatealltheerrorsofthewar;becauseitwillbemadeuponthesamefalseprinciple。Whathasbeenlostinthefield,inthefieldmayberegained。Anarrangementofpeaceinitsnatureisapermanentsettlement;itistheeffectofcounselanddeliberation,andnotoffortuitousevents。Ifbuiltuponabasisfundamentallyerroneous,itcanonlyberetrievedbysomeofthoseunforeseendispensations,whichtheall-wisebutmysteriousGovernoroftheworldsometimesinterposes,tosnatchnationsfromruin。Itwouldnotbepiouserror,butmadandimpiouspresumption,foranyonetotrustinanunknownorderofdispensations,indefianceoftherulesofprudence,whichareformedupontheknownmarchoftheordinaryprovidenceofGod。 NATIONALDIGNITY。 NationaldignityinalltreatiesIdoadmitisanimportantconsideration。Theyhavegivenusausefulhintonthatsubject:butdignity,hitherto,hasbelongedtothemodeofproceeding,nottothematterofatreaty。Neverbeforehasitbeenmentionedasthestandardforratingtheconditionsofpeace;no,neverbythemostviolentofconquerors。Indemnificationiscapableofsomeestimate:dignityhasnostandard。ItisimpossibletoguesswhatacquisitionsprideandambitionmaythinkfitfortheirDIGNITY。 PRINCIPLESOFGOVERNMENTNOTABSOLUTE,BUTRELATIVE。 Ireprobatenoformofgovernmentmerelyuponabstractprinciples。Theremaybesituationsinwhichthepurelydemocraticformwillbecomenecessary。Theremaybesome(veryfew,andveryparticularlycircumstanced)whereitwouldbeclearlydesirable。ThisIdonottaketobethecaseofFrance,orofanyothergreatcountry。Untilnow,wehaveseennoexamplesofconsiderabledemocracies。Theancientswerebetteracquaintedwiththem。Notbeingwhollyunreadintheauthors,whohadseenthemostofthoseconstitutions,andwhobestunderstoodthem,Icannothelpconcurringwiththeiropinion,thatanabsolutedemocracy,nomorethanabsolutemonarchy,istobereckonedamongthelegitimateformsofgovernment。Theythinkitratherthecorruptionanddegeneracy,thanthesoundconstitutionofarepublic。IfIrecollectrightly,Aristotleobserves,thatademocracyhasmanystrikingpointsofresemblancewithatyranny。(WhenIwrotethis,Iquotedfrommemory,aftermanyyearshadelapsedfrommyreadingthepassage。Alearnedfriendhasfoundit,anditisasfollows:—— Toethostoauto,kaiamphodespotikatonBeltionon,kaitapsephismata,osperekeitaepitagmatakaiodemagogoskaiokolax,oiautoikaianalogoikaimalistaekateroiparekateroisischuousin,oimenkolakesparaturannois,oidedemagogoiparatoisdemoistoistoioutois—— “Theethicalcharacteristhesame;bothexercisedespotismoverthebetterclassofcitizens;anddecreesareintheone,whatordinancesandarretsareintheother:thedemagoguetoo,andthecourtfavourite,arenotunfrequentlythesameidenticalmen,andalwaysbearacloseanalogy;andthesehavetheprincipalpower,eachintheirrespectiveformsofgovernment,favouriteswiththeabsolutemonarch,anddemagogueswithapeoplesuchasIhavedescribed。”——Arist。Politic。 lib。iv。cap4。) OfthisIamcertain,thatinademocracy,themajorityofthecitizensiscapableofexercisingthemostcrueloppressionsupontheminority,wheneverstrongdivisionsprevailinthatkindofpolity,astheyoftenmust;andthatoppressionoftheminoritywillextendtofargreaternumbers,andwillbecarriedonwithmuchgreaterfury,thancanalmosteverbeapprehendedfromthedominionofasinglesceptre。Insuchapopularpersecution,individualsufferersareinamuchmoredeplorableconditionthaninanyother。Underacruelprincetheyhavethebalmycompassionofmankindtoassuagethesmartoftheirwounds;theyhavetheplauditsofthepeopletoanimatetheirgenerousconstancyundertheirsufferings:butthosewhoaresubjectedtowrongundermultitudes,aredeprivedofallexternalconsolation。Theyseemdesertedbymankind,overpoweredbyaconspiracyoftheirwholespecies。Butadmittingdemocracynottohavethatinevitabletendencytopartytyranny,whichI supposeittohave,andadmittingittopossessasmuchgoodinitwhenunmixed,asIamsureitpossesseswhencompoundedwithotherforms; doesmonarchy,onitspart,containnothingatalltorecommendit?IdonotoftenquoteBolingbroke,norhavehisworksingeneralleftanypermanentimpressiononmymind。Heisapresumptuousandasuperficialwriter。Buthehasoneobservation,which,inmyopinion,isnotwithoutdepthandsolidity。Hesays,thatheprefersamonarchytoothergovernments,becauseyoucanbetteringraftanydescriptionofrepubliconamonarchy,thananythingofmonarchyupontherepublicanforms。I thinkhimperfectlyintheright。Thefactissohistorically;anditagreeswellwiththespeculation。 Iknowhoweasyatopicitistodwellonthefaultsofdepartedgreatness。Byarevolutioninthestate,thefawningsycophantofyesterdayisconvertedintotheausterecriticofthepresenthour。Butsteady,independentminds,whentheyhaveanobjectofsoseriousaconcerntomankindasgovernmentundertheircontemplation,willdisdaintoassumethepartofsatiristsanddeclaimers。Theywilljudgeofhumaninstitutionsastheydoofhumancharacters。Theywillsortoutthegoodfromtheevil,whichismixedinmortalinstitutions,asitisinmortalmen。 DECLARATIONOF1793。 Itisnotdifficulttodiscernwhatsortofhumanityourgovernmentistolearnfromthesesyrensingers。Ourgovernmentalso,Iadmitwithsomereason,asasteptowardstheproposedfraternity,isrequiredtoabjuretheunjusthatredwhichitbearstothisbody,ofhonourandvirtue。IthankGodIamneitheraministernoraleaderofopposition。 IprotestIcannotdowhattheydesire。IcouldnotdoitifIwereundertheguillotine;orastheyingeniouslyandpleasantlyexpressit,“lookingoutofthelittlenationalwindow。”EvenatthatopeningI couldreceivenoneoftheirlight。Iamfortifiedagainstallsuchaffectionsbythedeclarationofthegovernment,whichImustyetconsideraslawful,madeonthe29thofOctober,1793,andstillringinginmyears。 (“Intheirplacehassucceededasystemdestructiveofallpublicorder,maintainedbyproscriptions,exiles,andconfiscationswithoutnumber; byarbitraryimprisonment;bymassacreswhichcannotberememberedwithouthorror;andatlengthbytheexecrablemurderofajustandbeneficentsovereign,andoftheillustriousprincess,who,withanunshakenfirmness,hassharedallthemisfortunesofherroyalconsort,hisprotractedsufferings,hiscruelcaptivity,andignominiousdeath。” They(theallies)havehadtoencounteractsofaggressionwithoutpretext,openviolationofalltreaties,unprovokeddeclarationsofwar; inaword,whatevercorruption,intrigue,orviolence,couldeffectforthepurpose,openlyavowed,ofsubvertingalltheinstitutionsofsociety,andofextendingoverallthenationsofEuropethatconfusion,whichhasproducedthemiseryofFrance。”——“ThisstateofthingscannotexistinFrancewithoutinvolvingallthesurroundingpowersinonecommondanger,withoutgivingthemtheright,withoutimposingituponthemasaduty,tostoptheprogressofanevil,whichexistsonlybythesuccessiveviolationofalllawandallproperty,andwhichattacksthefundamentalprinciplesbywhichmankindisunitedinthebondsofcivilsociety。”——“Thekingwouldimposenoneotherthanequitableandmoderateconditions,notsuchastheexpense,therisks,andthesacrificesofthewarmightjustify;butsuchashismajestythinkshimselfundertheindispensablenecessityofrequiring,withaviewtotheseconsiderations,andstillmoretothatofhisownsecurityandofthefuturetranquillityofEurope。Hismajestydesiresnothingmoresincerelythanthustoterminateawar,whichheinvainendeavouredtoavoid,andallthecalamitiesofwhich,asnowexperiencedbyFrance,aretobeattributedonlytotheambition,theperfidy,andtheviolenceofthose,whosecrimeshaveinvolvedtheirowncountryinmisery,anddisgracedallcivilizednations。”——“Thekingpromises,onhispart,thesuspensionofhostilities,friendship,and(asfarasthecourseofeventswillallow,ofwhichthewillofmancannotdispose)securityandprotectiontoallthosewho,bydeclaringforamonarchicalformofgovernment,shallshakeofftheyokeofsanguinaryanarchy;ofthatanarchywhichhasbrokenallthemostsacredbondsofsociety,dissolvedalltherelationsofcivillife,violatedeveryright,confoundedeveryduty;whichusesthenameoflibertytoexercisethemostcrueltyranny,toannihilateallproperty,toseizeonallpossessions:whichfoundsitspoweronthepretendedconsentofthepeople,anditselfcarriesfireandswordthroughextensiveprovincesforhavingdemandedtheirlaws,theirreligion,andtheirLAWFULSOVEREIGN。” Declarationsentbyhismajesty’scommandtothecommandersofhismajesty’sfleetsandarmiesemployedagainstFrance,andtohismajesty’sministersemployedatforeigncourts。) Thisdeclarationwastransmittednotonlytoourcommandersbyseaandland,buttoourministersineverycourtofEurope。Itisthemosteloquentandhighly-finishedinthestyle,themostjudiciousinthechoiceoftopics,themostorderlyinthearrangement,andthemostrichinthecolouring,withoutemployingthesmallestdegreeofexaggeration,ofanystatepaperthathaseveryetappeared。Anancientwriter,Plutarch,Ithinkitis,quotessomeversesontheeloquenceofPericles,whoiscalled“theonlyoratorthatleftstingsinthemindsofhishearers。”Likehis,theeloquenceofthedeclaration,notcontradicting,butenforcingsentimentsofthetruesthumanity,hasleftstingsthathavepenetratedmorethanskin-deepintomymind;andnevercantheybeextractedbyallthesurgeryofmurder,nevercanthethrobbingstheyhavecreatedbeassuagedbyalltheemolientcataplasmsofrobberyandconfiscation。ICANNOTlovetherepublic。 MORALDIET。 Todietamanintoweaknessandlanguor,afterwardstogivehimthegreaterstrength,hasmoreoftheempiricthantherationalphysician。 Itistruethatsomepersonshavebeenkickedintocourage;andthisisnobadhinttogivetothosewhoaretooforwardandliberalinbestowinginsultsandoutragesontheirpassivecompanions。Butsuchacoursedoesnotatfirstviewappearawell-chosendisciplinetoformmentoanicesenseofhonour,oraquickresentmentofinjuries。Alonghabitofhumiliationdoesnotseemaverygoodpreparativetomanlyandvigoroussentiment。Itmaynotleave,perhaps,enoughofenergyinthemindfairlytodiscernwhataregoodtermsorwhatarenot。Menlowanddispiritedmayregardthosetermsasnotatallamiss,whichinanotherstateofmindtheywouldthinkintolerable:iftheygrowpeevishinthisstateofmind,theymayberoused,notagainsttheenemywhomtheyhavebeentaughttofear,butagainsttheministry,whoaremorewithintheirreach,andwhohaverefusedconditionsthatarenotunreasonable,frompowerthattheyhavebeentaughttoconsiderasirresistible。 KINGWILLIAM’SPOLICY。 Hismajestydiddetermine;anddidtakeandpursuehisresolution。Inallthetotteringimbecilityofanewgovernment,andwithparliamenttotallyunmanageable,hepersevered。Heperseveredtoexpelthefearsofhispeoplebyhisfortitude——tosteadytheirficklenessbyhisconstancy——toexpandtheirnarrowprudencebyhisenlargedwisdom——tosinktheirfactioustemperinhispublicspirit。Inspiteofhispeopleheresolvedtomakethemgreatandglorious;tomakeEngland,inclinedtoshrinkintohernarrowself,thearbitressofEurope,thetutelaryangelofthehumanrace。Inspiteoftheministers,whostaggeredundertheweightthathismindimposedupontheirs,unsupportedastheyfeltthemselvesbythepopularspirit,heinfusedintothemhisownsoul,herenewedinthemtheirancientheart,heralliedtheminthesamecause。 Itrequiredsometimetoaccomplishthiswork。Thepeoplewerefirstgained,andthroughthemtheirdistractedrepresentatives。UndertheinfluenceofKingWilliam,Hollandhadrejectedtheallurementsofeveryseduction,andhadresistedtheterrorsofeverymenace。WithHannibalathergates,shehadnoblyandmagnanimouslyrefusedallseparatetreaty,oranythingwhichmightforamomentappeartodivideheraffectionorherinterest,oreventodistinguishherinidentityfromEngland。Havingsettledthegreatpointoftheconsolidation(whichhehopedwouldbeeternal)ofthecountriesmadeforacommoninterest,andcommonsentiment,theking,inhismessagetobothhouses,callstheirattentiontotheaffairsoftheSTATES-GENERAL。TheHouseofLordswasperfectlysound,andentirelyimpressedwiththewisdomanddignityoftheking’sproceedings。Inanswertothemessage,whichyouwillobservewasnarrowedtoasinglepoint(thedangeroftheStates-General),aftertheusualprofessionsofzealforhisservice,thelordsopenedthemselvesatlarge。Theygofarbeyondthedemandsofthemessage。Theyexpressthemselvesasfollows:“WetakethisoccasionFURTHERtoassureyourmajesty,thatwearesensibleoftheGREATANDIMMINENTDANGERTO WHICHTHESTATES-GENERALAREEXPOSED。ANDWEPERFECTLYAGREEWITHTHEM INBELIEVINGTHATTHEIRSAFETYANDOURSARESOINSEPARABLYUNITED,THAT WHATSOEVERISRUINTOTHEONEMUSTBEFATALTOTHEOTHER。 “WehumblydesireyourmajestywillbepleasedNOTONLYtomadegoodallthearticlesofanyFORMERtreatiestotheStates-General,butthatyouwillenterintoastrictleague,offensiveanddefensive,withthem,FOR THEIRCOMMONPRESERVATION;ANDTHATYOUWILLINVITEINTOITALLPRINCES ANDSTATESWHOARECONCERNEDINTHEPRESENTVISIBLEDANGER,ARISINGFROM THEUNIONOFFRANCEANDSPAIN。 “Andwefurtherdesireyourmajesty,thatyouwillbepleasedtoenterintosuchallianceswiththeEMPERORasyourmajestyshallthinkfit,pursuanttotheendsofthetreatyof1689;towardsallwhichweassureyourmajestyofourheartyandsincereassistance;notdoubting,butwheneveryourmajestyshallbeobligedtobeengagedforthedefenceofyourallies,ANDSECURINGTHELIBERTYANDQUIETOFEUROPE,AlmightyGodwillprotectyoursacredpersoninsorighteousacause。Andthattheunanimity,wealth,andcourage,ofyoursubjectswillcarryyourmajestywithhonourandsuccessTHROUGHALLTHEDIFFICULTIESOFAJUSTWAR。” TheHouseofCommonswasmorereserved;thelatepopulardispositionwasstillinagreatdegreeprevalentintherepresentative,afterithadbeenmadetochangeintheconstituentbody。TheprincipleofthegrandalliancewasnotdirectlyrecognisedintheresolutionoftheCommons,northewarannounced,thoughtheywerewellawarethealliancewasformedforthewar。However,compelledbythereturningsenseofthepeople,theywentsofarastofixthethreegreatimmovablepillarsofthesafetyandgreatnessofEngland,astheywerethen,astheyarenow,andastheymusteverbetotheendoftime。TheyassertedingeneraltermsthenecessityofsupportingHolland,ofkeepingunitedwithourallies,andmaintainingthelibertyofEurope;thoughtheyrestrictedtheirvotetothesuccoursstipulatedbyactualtreaty。Butnowtheywerefairlyembarked,theywereobligedtogowiththecourseofthevessel;andthewholenation,splitbeforeintoahundredadversefactions,withakingatitsheadevidentlydecliningtohistomb,thewholenation,lords,commons,andpeople,proceededasonebody,informedbyonesoul。UndertheBritishunion,theunionofEuropewasconsolidated;anditlongheldtogetherwithadegreeofcohesion,firmness,andfidelity,notknownbeforeorsinceinanypoliticalcombinationofthatextent。 Justasthelasthandwasgiventothisimmenseandcomplicatedmachine,themasterworkmandied:buttheworkwasformedontruemechanicalprinciples,anditwasastrulywrought。Itwentbytheimpulseithadreceivedfromthefirstmover。Themanwasdead;butthegrandalliancesurvivedinwhichKingWilliamlivedandreigned。Thatheartlessanddispiritedpeople,whomLordSomershadrepresentedabouttwoyearsbeforeasdeadinenergyandoperation,continuedthatwartowhichitwassupposedtheywereunequalinmind,andinmeans,fornearlythirteenyears。ForwhathaveIenteredintoallthisdetail?TowhatpurposehaveIrecalledyourviewtotheendofthelastcentury?IthasbeendonetoshowthattheBritishnationwasthenagreatpeople——topointouthowandbywhatmeanstheycametobeexaltedabovethevulgarlevel,andtotakethatleadwhichtheyassumedamongmankind。Toqualifyusforthatpre-eminence,wehadthenahighmindandaconstancyunconquerable;weweretheninspiredwithnoflashypassions,butsuchasweredurableaswellaswarm,suchascorrespondedtothegreatinterestswehadatstake。Thisforceofcharacterwasinspired,asallsuchspiritmusteverbe,fromabove。Governmentgavetheimpulse。Aswellmaywefancy,thatofitselftheseawillswell,andthatwithoutwindsthebillowswillinsulttheadverseshore,asthatthegrossmassofthepeoplewillbemoved,andelevated,andcontinuebyasteadyandpermanentdirectiontobearupononepoint,withouttheinfluenceofsuperiorauthority,orsuperiormind。 Thisimpulseought,inmyopinion,tohavebeengiveninthiswar;anditoughttohavebeencontinuedtoitateveryinstant。Itismade,ifeverwarwasmade,totouchallthegreatspringsofactioninthehumanbreast。Itoughtnottohavebeenawarofapology。Theministerhad,inthisconflict,wherewithaltogloryinsuccess;tobeconsoledinadversity;toholdhighhisprincipleinallfortunes。Ifitwerenotgivenhimtosupportthefallingedifice,heoughttoburyhimselfundertheruinsofthecivilizedworld。AlltheartofGreece,andalltheprideandpowerofeasternmonarchs,neverheapedupontheirashessograndamonument。 DISTEMPEROFREMEDY。 Thisdistemperofremedy,grownhabitual,relaxesandwearsout,byavulgarandprostituteduse,thespringofthatspiritwhichistobeexertedongreatoccasions。ItwasinthemostpatientperiodofRomanservitudethatthemesoftyrannicidemadetheordinaryexerciseofboysatschool——cumperimitsaevosclassisnumerosatyrannos。Intheordinarystateofthings,itproducesinacountrylikeourstheworsteffects,evenonthecauseofthatlibertywhichitabuseswiththedissolutenessofanextravagantspeculation。Almostallthehigh-bredrepublicansofmytimehave,afterashortspace,becomethemostdecided,thorough-pacedcourtiers;theysoonleftthebusinessofatedious,moderate,butpracticalresistance,tothoseofuswhom,intheprideandintoxicationoftheirtheories,theyhaveslightedasnotmuchbetterthanTories。Hypocrisy,ofcourse,delightsinthemostsublimespeculations;for,neverintendingtogobeyondspeculation,itcostsnothingtohaveitmagnificent。Butevenincaseswhereratherlevitythanfraudwastobesuspectedintheserantingspeculations,theissuehasbeenmuchthesame。Theseprofessors,findingtheirextremeprinciplesnotapplicabletocaseswhichcallonlyforaqualified,or,asImaysay,civil,andlegalresistance,insuchcasesemploynoresistanceatall。Itiswiththemawarorarevolution,oritisnothing。Findingtheirschemesofpoliticsnotadaptedtothestateoftheworldinwhichtheylive,theyoftencometothinklightlyofallpublicprinciple;andareready,ontheirpart,toabandonforaverytrivialinterestwhattheyfindofverytrivialvalue。Someindeedareofmoresteadyandperseveringnatures;buttheseareeagerpoliticiansoutofparliament,whohavelittletotemptthemtoabandontheirfavouriteprojects。TheyhavesomechangeintheChurchorState,orboth,constantlyintheirview。Whenthatisthecase,theyarealwaysbadcitizens,andperfectlyunsureconnections。For,consideringtheirspeculativedesignsasofinfinitevalue,andtheactualarrangementofthestateasofnoestimation,theyareatbestindifferentaboutit。 Theyseenomeritinthegood,andnofaultintheviciousmanagementofpublicaffairs;theyratherrejoiceinthelatter,asmorepropitioustorevolution。Theyseenomeritordemeritinanyman,oranyaction,oranypoliticalprinciple,anyfurtherthanastheymayforwardorretardtheirdesignofchange:theythereforetakeup,oneday,themostviolentandstretchedprerogative,andanothertimethewildestdemocraticideasoffreedom,andpassfromtheonetotheotherwithoutanysortofregardtocause,toperson,ortoparty。 WARANDWILLOFTHEPEOPLE。 Inmattersofstate,aconstitutionalcompetencetoactisinmanycasesthesmallestpartofthequestion。Withoutdisputing(GodforbidI shoulddispute)thesolecompetenceofthekingandtheparliament,eachinitsprovince,todecideonwarandpeace,Iventuretosay,nowarCANbelongcarriedonagainstthewillofthepeople。Thiswar,inparticular,cannotbecarriedonunlesstheyareenthusiasticallyinfavourofit。Acquiescencewillnotdo。Theremustbezeal。Universalzealinsuchacause,andatsuchatimeasthisis,cannotbelookedfor;neitherisitnecessary。Zealinthelargerpartcarriestheforceofthewhole。Withoutthis,nogovernment,certainlynotourgovernment,iscapableofagreatwar。Noneoftheancientregulargovernmentshavewherewithaltofightabroadwithaforeignfoe,andathometoovercomerepining,reluctance,andchicane。Itmustbesomeportentousthing,likeregicideFrance,thatcanexhibitsuchaprodigy。Yetevenshe,themotherofmonsters,moreprolificthanthecountryofoldcalledFeraxmonstrorum,showssymptomsofbeingalmosteffetealready;andshewillbeso,unlessthefallowofapeacecomestorecruitherfertility。Butwhatevermayberepresentedconcerningthemeannessofthepopularspirit,I,forone,donotthinksodesperatelyoftheBritishnation。 Ourminds,asIsaid,arelight,buttheyarenotdepraved。Wearedreadfullyopentodelusionandtodejection;butwearecapableofbeinganimatedandundeceived。 Itcannotbeconcealed:weareadividedpeople。Butindivisions,whereapartistobetaken,wearetomakeamusterofourstrength。Ihaveoftenendeavouredtocomputeandtoclassthosewho,inanypoliticalview,aretobecalledthepeople。Withoutdoingsomethingofthissortwemustproceedabsurdly。Weshouldnotbemuchwiser,ifwepretendedtoverygreataccuracyinourestimate;butIthink,inthecalculationIhavemade,theerrorcannotbeverymaterial。InEnglandandScotland,Icomputethatthoseofadultage,notdeclininginlife,oftolerableleisureforsuchdiscussions,andofsomemeansofinformation,moreorless,andwhoareabovemenialdependence(orwhatvirtuallyissuch),mayamounttoaboutfourhundredthousand。Thereissuchathingasanaturalrepresentativeofthepeople。Thisbodyisthatrepresentative; andonthisbody,morethanonthelegalconstituent,theartificialrepresentativedepends。ThisistheBritishpublic;anditisapublicverynumerous。Therest,whenfeeble,aretheobjectsofprotection; whenstrong,themeansofforce。Theywhoaffecttoconsiderthatpartofusinanyotherlight,insultwhiletheycajoleus;theydonotwantusforcounsellorsindeliberation,buttolistusassoldiersforbattle。 Ofthesefourhundredthousandpoliticalcitizens,Ilookuponone-fifth,orabouteightythousand,tobepureJacobins;utterlyincapableofamendment;objectsofeternalvigilance,and,whentheybreakout,oflegalconstraint。Onthese,noreason,noargument,noexample,novenerableauthority,canhavetheslightestinfluence。Theydesireachange;andtheywillhaveitiftheycan。IftheycannothaveitbyEnglishcabal,theywillmakenosortofscrupleofhavingitbythecabalofFrance,intowhichalreadytheyarevirtuallyincorporated。 ItisonlytheirassuredandconfidentexpectationoftheadvantagesofFrenchfraternity,andtheapproachingblessingsofregicideintercourse,thatskinsovertheirmischievousdispositionswithamomentaryquiet。Thisminorityisgreatandformidable。IdonotknowwhetherifIaimedatthetotaloverthrowofakingdom,Ishouldwishtobeencumberedwithalargerbodyofpartisans。Theyaremoreeasilydisciplinedanddirectedthanifthenumberweregreater。These,bytheirspiritofintrigue,andbytheirrestlessagitatingactivity,areofaforcefarsuperiortotheirnumbers;and,iftimesgrewtheleastcritical,havethemeansofdebauchingorintimidatingmanyofthosewhoarenowsound,aswellasofaddingtotheirforcelargebodiesofthemorepassivepartofthenation。Thisminorityisnumerousenoughtomakeamightycryforpeace,orforwar,orforanyobjecttheyareledvehementlytodesire。Bypassingfromplacetoplacewithavelocityincredible,anddiversifyingtheircharacteranddescription,theyarecapableofmimickingthegeneralvoice。Wemustnotalwaysjudgeofthegeneralityoftheopinionbythenoiseoftheacclamation。 FALSEPOLICYINOURFRENCHWAR。 Wehaveneverputforthhalfthestrengthwhichwehaveexertedinordinarywars。Inthefatalbattleswhichhavedrenchedthecontinentwithblood,andshakenthesystemofEuropetopieces,wehaveneverhadanyconsiderablearmyofamagnitudetobecomparedtotheleastofthosebywhich,informertimes,wesogloriouslyassertedourplaceasprotectors,notoppressors,attheheadofthegreatcommonwealthofEurope。Wehavenevermanfullymetthedangerinfront:andwhentheenemy,resigningtousournaturaldominionoftheocean,andabandoningthedefenceofhisdistantpossessionstotheinfernalenergyofthedestroyingprincipleswhichhehadplantedthereforthesubversionoftheneighbouringcolonies,droveforth,byonesweepinglawofunprecedenteddespotism,hisarmedmultitudesoneveryside,tooverwhelmthecountriesandstateswhichhadforcenturiesstoodthefirmbarriersagainsttheambitionofFrance;wedrewbackthearmofourmilitaryforce,whichhadneverbeenmorethanhalfraisedtoopposehim。Fromthattimewehavebeencombatingonlywiththeotherarmofournavalpower;therightarmofEnglandIadmit;butwhichstruckalmostunresistedwithblowsthatcouldneverreachtheheartofthehostilemischief。Fromthattime,withoutasingleefforttoregainthoseoutworks,whichevertillnowwesostrenuouslymaintained,asthestrongfrontierofourowndignityandsafety,nolessthanthelibertiesofEurope;withbutonefeebleattempttosuccourthosebrave,faithful,andnumerousallies,whom,forthefirsttimesincethedaysofourEdwardsandHenrys,wenowhaveinthebosomofFranceitself;wehavebeenintrenching,andfortifying,andgarrisoningourselvesathome:wehavebeenredoublingsecurityonsecurity,toprotectourselvesfrominvasion,whichhasnowbecometousaseriousobjectofalarmandterror。Alas!thefewofuswhohaveprotractedlifeinanymeasureneartotheextremelimitsofourshortperiod,havebeencondemnedtoseestrangethings;newsystemsofpolicy,newprinciples,andnotonlynewmen,butwhatmightappearanewspeciesofmen。Ibelievethatanypersonwhowasofagetotakeapartinpublicaffairsfortyyearsago(iftheintermediatespaceoftimewereexpungedfromhismemory)wouldhardlycredithissenses,whenheshouldhearfromthehighestauthority,thatanarmyoftwohundredthousandmenwaskeptupinthisisland,andthatintheneighbouringislandtherewereatleastfourscorethousandmore。Butwhenhehadrecoveredfromhissurpriseonbeingtoldofthisarmy,whichhasnotitsparallel,whatmustbehisastonishmenttobetoldagain,thatthismightyforcewaskeptupforthemerepurposeofaninertandpassivedefence,andthatinitsfargreaterpart,itwasdisabledbyitsconstitutionandveryessencefromdefendingusagainstanenemybyanyonepreventivestroke,oranyoneoperationofactivehostility?Whatmusthisreflectionsbeonlearningfurther,thatafleetoffivehundredmenofwar,thebestappointed,andtothefullasablycommandedasanythiscountryeverhaduponthesea,wasforthegreaterpartemployedincarryingonthesamesystemofunenterprisingdefence?,whatmustbethesentimentsandfeelingsofonewhorememberstheformerenergyofEngland,whenheisgiventounderstandthatthesetwoislands,withtheirextensiveandeverywherevulnerablecoast,shouldbeconsideredasagarrisonedsea-town;whatwouldsuchaman,whatwouldanymanthink,ifthegarrisonofsostrangeafortressshouldbesuch,andsofeeblycommanded,asnevertomakeasally;andthat,contrarytoallwhichhashithertobeenseeninwar,aninfinitelyinferiorarmy,withtheshatteredrelicsofanalmostannihilatednavy,illfoundandillmanned,maywithsafetybesiegethissuperiorgarrison,and,withouthazardingthelifeofaman,ruintheplace,merelybythemenacesandfalseappearancesofanattack?Indeed,indeed,mydearfriend,Ilookuponthismatterofourdefensivesystemasmuchthemostimportantofallconsiderationsatthismoment。Ithasoppressedmewithmanyanxiousthoughts,which,morethananybodilydistemper,havesunkmetotheconditioninwhichyouknowthatIam。ShoulditpleaseProvidencetorestoretomeeventhelateweakremainsofmystrength,Iproposetomakethismatterthesubjectofaparticulardiscussion。Ionlymeanheretoargue,thatthemodeofconductingthewaronourpart,beitgoodorbad,haspreventedeventhecommonhavocofwarinourpopulation,andespeciallyamongthatclasswhosedutyandprivilegeofsuperiorityitistoleadthewayamidsttheperilsandslaughterofthefieldofbattle。