MORALESSENCEMAKESANATION。
Merelocalitydoesnotconstituteabodypolitic。HadCadeandhisganggotpossessionofLondon,theywouldnothavebeenthelordmayor,aldermen,andcommoncouncil。ThebodypoliticofFranceexistedinthemajestyofitsthrone,inthedignityofitsnobility,inthehonourofitsgentry,inthesanctityofitsclergy,inthereverenceofitsmagistracy,intheweightandconsiderationduetoitslandedpropertyintheseveralbailliages,intherespectduetoitsmoveablesubstancerepresentedbythecorporationsofthekingdom。Alltheseparticularmoleculaeunitedformthegreatmassofwhatistrulythebodypoliticinallcountries。Theyaresomanydepositsandreceptaclesofjustice;
becausetheycanonlyexistbyjustice。Nationisamoralessence,notageographicalarrangement,oradenominationofthenomenclator。France,thoughoutofherterritorialpossession,exists;becausethesolepossibleclaimant,Imeantheproprietary,andthegovernmenttowhichtheproprietaryadheres,exists,andclaims。Godforbid,thatifyouwereexpelledfromyourhousebyruffiansandassassins,thatIshouldcallthematerialwalls,doors,andwindowsof——,theancientandhonourablefamilyof。AmItotransfertotheintruders,who,notcontenttoturnyououtnakedtotheworld,wouldrobyouofyourveryname,alltheesteemandrespectIowetoyou?TheregicidesinFrancearenotFrance。Franceisoutofherbounds,butthekingdomisthesame。
PUBLICSPIRIT。
Othergreatstates,havingbeenwithoutanyregular,certaincourseofelevationordecline,wemayhopethattheBritishfortunemayfluctuatealso;becausethepublicmind,whichgreatlyinfluencesthatfortune,mayhaveitschanges。Wearethereforeneverauthorisedtoabandonourcountrytoitsfate,ortoactoradviseasifithadnoresource。Thereisnoreasontoapprehend,becauseordinarymeansthreatentofail,thatnootherscanspringup。Whilstourheartiswhole,itwillfindmeans,ormakethem。Theheartofthecitizenisaperennialspringofenergytothestate。Becausethepulseseemstointermit,wemustnotpresumethatitwillceaseinstantlytobeat。
Thepublicmustneverberegardedasincurable。IrememberinthebeginningofwhathaslatelybeencalledtheSevenYears’War,thataneloquentwriterandingeniousspeculator,Dr。Brown,uponsomereverseswhichhappenedinthebeginningofthatwar,publishedanelaboratephilosophicaldiscoursetoprovethatthedistinguishingfeaturesofthepeopleofEnglandhavebeentotallychanged,andthatafrivolouseffeminacywasbecomethenationalcharacter。Nothingcouldbemorepopularthanthatwork。Itwasthoughtagreatconsolationtous,thelightpeopleofthiscountry(whowereandarelight,butwhowerenotandarenoteffeminate),thatwehadfoundthecausesofourmisfortunesinourvices。Pythagorascouldnotbemorepleasedwithhisleadingdiscovery。Butwhilstinthatspleneticmoodweamusedourselvesinasour,criticalspeculation,ofwhichwewereourselvestheobjects,andinwhicheverymanlosthisparticularsenseofthepublicdisgraceintheepidemicnatureofthedistemper;whilst,asintheAlps,goitre[“i“circumflex]keptgoitre[“i“acute]incountenance;whilstwewerethusabandoningourselvestoadirectconfessionofourinferioritytoFrance,andwhilstmany,verymany,werereadytoactuponasenseofthatinferiority,afewmonthseffectedatotalchangeinourvariableminds。Weemergedfromthegulfofthatspeculativedespondency,andwerebuoyeduptothehighestpointofpracticalvigour。NeverdidthemasculinespiritofEnglanddisplayitselfwithmoreenergy,noreverdiditsgeniussoarwithaprouderpre-eminenceoverFrance,thanatthetimewhenfrivolityandeffeminacyhadbeenatleasttacitlyacknowledgedastheirnationalcharacterbythegoodpeopleofthiskingdom。
PROGRESSIVEGROWTHOFCHRISTIANSTATES。
WhenIcontemplatetheschemeonwhichFranceisformed,andwhenI
compareitwiththesesystems,withwhichitis,andevermustbe,inconflict,thosethings,whichseemasdefectsinherpolity,aretheverythingswhichmakemetremble。ThestatesoftheChristianworldhavegrownuptotheirpresentmagnitudeinagreatlengthoftime,andbyagreatvarietyofaccidents。Theyhavebeenimprovedtowhatweseethemwithgreaterorlessdegreesoffelicityandskill。Notoneofthemhasbeenformeduponaregularplanorwithanyunityofdesign。Astheirconstitutionsarenotsystematical,theyhavenotbeendirectedtoanyPECULIARend,eminentlydistinguished,andsupersedingeveryother。
Theobjectswhichtheyembraceareofthegreatestpossiblevariety,andhavebecomeinamannerinfinite。Inalltheseoldcountries,thestatehasbeenmadetothepeople,andnotthepeopleconformedtothestate。
Everystatehaspursuednotonlyeverysortofsocialadvantage,butithascultivatedthewelfareofeveryindividual。Hiswants,hiswishes,evenhistastes,havebeenconsulted。Thiscomprehensiveschemevirtuallyproducedadegreeofpersonallibertyinformsthemostadversetoit。Thatlibertywasfound,undermonarchiesstyledabsolute,inadegreeunknowntotheancientcommonwealths。Fromhencethepowersofallourmodernstatesmeet,inalltheirmovements,withsomeobstruction。Itisthereforenowonder,that,whenthesestatesaretobeconsideredasmachinestooperateforsomeonegreatend,thisdissipatedandbalancedforceisnoteasilyconcentrated,ormadetobearwiththewholeforceofthenationupononepoint。
TheBritishstateis,withoutquestion,thatwhichpursuesthegreatestvarietyofends,andistheleastdisposedtosacrificeanyoneofthemtoanother,ortothewhole。Itaimsattakingintheentirecircleofhumandesires,andsecuringforthemtheirfairenjoyment。Ourlegislaturehasbeenevercloselyconnected,initsmostefficientpart,withindividualfeeling,andindividualinterest。Personalliberty,themostlivelyofthesefeelingsandthemostimportantoftheseinterests,whichinotherEuropeancountrieshasratherarisenfromthesystemofmannersandthehabitudesoflife,thanfromthelawsofthestate(inwhichitflourishedmorefromneglectthanattention),inEngland,hasbeenadirectobjectofgovernment。
OnthisprincipleEnglandwouldbetheweakestpowerinthewholesystem。Fortunately,however,thegreatrichesofthiskingdomarisingfromavarietyofcauses,andthedispositionofthepeople,whichisasgreattospendastoaccumulate,haseasilyaffordedadisposablesurplusthatgivesamightymomentumtothestate。Thisdifficulty,withtheseadvantagestoovercomeit,hascalledforththetalentsoftheEnglishfinanciers,who,bythesurplusofindustrypouredoutbyprodigality,haveoutdoneeverythingwhichhasbeenaccomplishedinothernations。Thepresentministerhasoutdonehispredecessors;and,asaministerofrevenue,isfarabovemypowerofpraise。ButstilltherearecasesinwhichEnglandfeelsmorethanseveralothers(thoughtheyallfeel)theperplexityofanimmensebodyofbalancedadvantages,andofindividualdemands,andofsomeirregularityinthewholemass。
Francediffersessentiallyfromallthosegovernments,whichareformedwithoutsystem,whichexistbyhabit,andwhichareconfusedwiththemultitude,andwiththeperplexityoftheirpursuits。WhatnowstandsasgovernmentinFranceisstruckoutataheat。Thedesigniswicked,immoral,impious,oppressive;butitisspiritedanddaring;itissystematic;itissimpleinitsprinciple;ithasunityandconsistencyinperfection。
PETTYINTERESTS。
Itisundoubtedlythebusinessofministersverymuchtoconsulttheinclinationsofthepeople,buttheyoughttotakegreatcarethattheydonotreceivethatinclinationfromthefewpersonswhomayhappentoapproachthem。Thepettyinterestsofsuchgentlemen,thelowconceptionsofthings,theirfearsarisingfromthedangertowhichtheveryarduousandcriticalsituationofpublicaffairsmayexposetheirplaces;theirapprehensionsfromthehazardstowhichthediscontentsofafewpopularmenatelectionsmayexposetheirseatsinparliament;allthesecausestroubleandconfusetherepresentationswhichtheymaketoministersoftherealtemperofthenation。Ifministers,insteadoffollowingthegreatindicationsoftheconstitution,proceedonsuchreports,theywilltakethewhispersofacabalforthevoiceofthepeople,andthecounselsofimprudenttimidityforthewisdomofanation。
PIUSVII。
ItisnotforhisHolinessweintendthisconsolatorydeclarationofourownweakness,andofthetyrannoustemperofhisgrandenemy。
Thatprincehasknownboththeoneandtheotherfromthebeginning。
TheartistsoftheFrenchrevolutionhadgiventheirveryfirstessaysandsketchesofrobberyanddesolationagainsthisterritories,inafarmorecruel“murderingpiece“thanhadeverenteredintotheimaginationofpainterorpoet。Withoutceremonytheytorefromhischerishingarmsthepossessionswhichheheldforfivehundredyears,undisturbedbyalltheambitionofalltheambitiousmonarchswho,duringthatperiod,havereignedinFrance。
Isittohim,inwhosewrongwehaveinourlatenegotiationcededhisnowunhappycountriesneartheRhone,latelyamongstthemostflourishing(perhapsthemostflourishingfortheirextent)ofallthecountriesuponearth,thatwearetoprovethesincerityofourresolutiontomakepeacewiththerepublicbarbarism?Thatvenerablepotentateandpontiffissunkdeepintothevaleofyears;heishalfdisarmedbyhispeacefulcharacter;hisdominionsaremorethanhalfdisarmedbyapeaceoftwohundredyears,defendedastheywere,notbyforces,butbyreverence;yetinallthesestraits,weseehimdisplay,amidsttherecentruinsandthenewdefacementsofhisplunderedcapital,alongwiththemildanddecoratedpietyofthemodern,allthespiritandmagnanimityofancientRome!Doeshe,who,thoughhimselfunabletodefendthem,noblyrefusedtoreceivepecuniarycompensationsfortheprotectionheowedtohispeopleofAvignon,Carpentras,andtheVenaisin;——doeshewantproofsofourgooddispositiontodeliveroverthatpeoplewithoutanysecurityforthem,oranycompensationtotheirsovereign,tothiscruelenemy?
DoeshewanttobesatisfiedofthesincerityofourhumiliationtoFrance,whohasseenhisfree,fertile,andhappycityandstateofBologna,thecradleofregeneratedlaw,theseatofsciencesandofarts,sohideouslymetamorphosed,whilsthewascryingtoGreatBritainforaid,andofferingtopurchasethataidatanyprice?Isithim,whoseesthatchosenspotofplentyanddelightconvertedintoaJacobinferociousrepublic,dependentonthehomicidesofFrance?Isithim,who,fromthemiraclesofhisbeneficentindustry,hasdoneaworkwhichdefiedthepoweroftheRomanemperors,thoughwithanenthralledworldtolabourforthem;isithim,whohasdrainedandcultivatedthePONTINEMARSHES,thatwearetosatisfyofourcordialspiritofconciliation,withthosewho,intheirequity,arerestoringHollandagaintotheseas,whosemaximspoisonmorethantheexhalationsofthemostdeadlyfens,andwhoturnallthefertilitiesofnatureandofartintoahowlingdesert?Isittohim,thatwearetodemonstratethegoodfaithofoursubmissionstothecannibalrepublic;tohimwhoiscommandedtodeliverintotheirhandsAnconaandCivitaVecchia,seatsofcommerce,raisedbythewiseandliberallaboursandexpensesofthepresentandlatepontiffs;portsnotmorebelongingtotheEcclesiasticalStatethantothecommerceofGreatBritain;thuswrestingfromhishandsthepowerofthekeysofthecentreofItaly,asbeforetheyhadtakenpossessionofthekeysofthenorthernpart,fromthehandsoftheunhappykingofSardinia,thenaturalallyofEngland?,Isittohimwearetoproveourgoodfaithinthepeacewhichwearesolicitingtoreceivefromthehandsofhisandourrobbers,theenemiesofallarts,allsciences,allcivilization,andallcommerce?
EXTINCTIONOFLOCALPATRIOTISM。
Thatdaywas,Ifear,thefataltermofLOCALpatriotism。Onthatday,I
fear,therewasanendofthatnarrowschemeofrelationscalledourcountry,withallitspride,itsprejudices,anditspartialaffections。
Allthelittlequietrivulets,thatwateredanhumble,acontracted,butnotanunfruitfulfield,aretobelostinthewasteexpanse,andboundless,barrenoceanofthehomicidephilanthropyofFrance。Itisnolongeranobjectofterror,theaggrandizementofanewpower,whichteachesasaprofessorthatphilanthropyintheirchair;whilstitpropagatesbyarms,andestablishesbyconquest,thecomprehensivesystemofuniversalfraternity。Inwhatlightisallthisviewedinagreatassembly?Thepartywhichtakestheleadtherehasnolongeranyapprehensions,exceptthosethatarisefromnotbeingadmittedtotheclosestandmostconfidentialconnectionswiththemetropolisofthatfraternity。Thatreigningpartynolongertouchesonitsfavouritesubject,thedisplayofthosehorrors,thatmustattendtheexistenceofapower,withsuchdispositionsandprinciples,seatedintheheartofEurope。Itissatisfiedtofindsomeloose,ambiguousexpressionsinitsformerdeclarations,whichmaysetitfreefromitsprofessionsandengagements。Italwaysspeaksofpeacewiththeregicidesasagreatandanundoubtedblessing;andsuchablessingas,ifobtained,promises,asmuchasanyhumandispositionofthingscanpromise,securityandpermanence。Itholdsoutnothingatalldefinitetowardsthissecurity。
Itonlyseeks,byarestoration,tosomeoftheirformerowners,ofsomefragmentsofthegeneralwreckofEurope,tofindaplausiblepleaforapresentretreatfromanembarrassingposition。Astothefuture,thatpartyiscontenttoleaveit,coveredinanightofthemostpalpableobscurity。Itneveroncehasenteredintoaparticleofdetailofwhatourownsituation,orthatofotherpowers,mustbe,undertheblessingsofthepeaceweseek。Thisdefect,tomypower,Imeantosupply;thatifanypersonsshouldstillcontinuetothinkanattemptatforesightisanypartofthedutyofastatesman,Imaycontributemytrifletothematerialsofhisspeculation。
Astotheotherparty,theminorityofto?day,possiblythemajorityofto-morrow,smallinnumberbutfulloftalentsandeveryspeciesofenergy,which,upontheavowedgroundofbeingmoreacceptabletoFrance,isacandidateforthehelmofthiskingdom,ithasneverchangedfromthebeginning。Ithaspreservedaperennialconsistency。
Thiswouldbeanever-failingsourceoftrueglory,ifspringingfromjustandright;butitistrulydreadfulifitbeanarmofStyx,whichspringsoutoftheprofoundestdepthsofapoisonedsoil。TheFrenchmaximswerebythesegentlemenatnotimecondemned。Ispeakoftheirlanguageinthemostmoderateterms。Therearemanywhothinkthattheyhavegonemuchfurther;thattheyhavealwaysmagnifiedandextolledtheFrenchmaxims;thatnotintheleastdisgustedordiscouragedbythemonstrousevils,whichhaveattendedthesemaximsfromthemomentoftheiradoptionbothathomeandabroad,theystillcontinuetopredict,thatinduetimetheymustproducethegreatestgoodtothepoorhumanrace。Theyobstinatelypersistinstatingthoseevilsasmatterofaccident;asthingswhollycollateraltothesystem。Itisobserved,thatthispartyhasneverspokenofanallyofGreatBritainwiththesmallestdegreeofrespectorregard;onthecontrary,ithasgenerallymentionedthemunderopprobriousappellations,andinsuchtermsofcontemptorexecration,asneverhadbeenheardbefore,becausenosuchwouldhaveformerlybeenpermittedinourpublicassemblies。Themoment,however,thatanyofthosealliesquittedthisobnoxiousconnection,thepartyhasinstantlypassedanactofindemnityandoblivionintheirfavour。Afterthis,nosortofcensureontheirconduct;noimputationontheircharacter!Fromthatmomenttheirpardonwassealedinareverentialandmysterioussilence。Withthegentlemenofthisminority,thereisnoally,fromoneendofEuropetotheother,withwhomweoughtnottobeashamedtoact。ThewholecollegeofthestatesofEuropeisnobetterthanagangoftyrants。Withthemallourconnexionswerebrokenoffatonce。WeoughttohavecultivatedFrance,andFrancealone,fromthemomentofherrevolution。Onthathappychange,allourdreadofthatnationasapowerwastocease。Shebecameinaninstantdeartoouraffections,andonewithourinterests。Allothernationsweoughttohavecommandednottotroublehersacredthroes,whilstinlabourtobringintoahappybirthherabundantlitterofconstitutions。
WALPOLEANDHISPOLICY。
Therehasnotbeeninthiscenturyanyforeignpeaceorwar,initsorigin,thefruitofpopulardesire;exceptthewarthatwasmadewithSpainin1739。SirRobertWalpolewasforcedintothewarbythepeople,whowereinflamedtothismeasurebythemostleadingpoliticians,bythefirstorators,andthegreatestpoets,ofthetime。Forthatwar,Popesunghisdyingnotes。Forthatwar,Johnson,inmoreenergeticstrains,employedthevoiceofhisearlygenius。Forthatwar,Gloverdistinguishedhimselfinthewayinwhichhismusewasthemostnaturalandhappy。Thecrowdreadilyfollowedthepoliticiansinthecryforawar,whichthreatenedlittlebloodshed,andwhichpromisedvictoriesthatwereattendedwithsomethingmoresolidthanglory。AwarwithSpainwasawarofplunder。Inthepresentconflictwithregicide,Mr。
Pitthasnothithertohad,norwill,perhaps,forafewdayshave,manyprizestoholdoutinthelotteryofwar,toattemptthelowerpartofourcharacter。Hecanonlymaintainitbyanappealtothehigher;andtothose,inwhomthathigherpartisthemostpredominant,hemustlookthemostforhissupport。Whilstheholdsoutnoinducementstothewise,norbribestotheavaricious,hemaybeforcedbyavulgarcryintoapeacetentimesmoreruinousthanthemostdisastrouswar。Theweakerheisinthefundofmotiveswhichapplytoouravarice,toourlaziness,andtoourlassitude,ifhemeanstocarrythewartoanyendatall,thestrongerheoughttobeinhisaddressestoourmagnanimityandtoourreason。
InstatingthatWalpolewasdrivenbyapopularclamourintoameasurenottobejustified,Idonotmeanwhollytoexcusehisconduct。Mytimeofobservationdidnotexactlycoincidewiththatevent:butIreadmuchofthecontroversiesthencarriedon。Severalyearsafterthecontestsofpartieshadceased,thepeoplewereamused,andinadegreewarmed,withthem。Theeventsofthateraseemedthenofmagnitude,whichtherevolutionsofourtimehavereducedtoparochialimportance;andthedebates,whichthenshookthenation,nowappearofnohighermomentthanadiscussioninavestry。WhenIwasveryyoung,ageneralfashiontoldmeIwastoadmiresomeofthewritingsagainstthatminister;alittlemorematuritytaughtmeasmuchtodespisethem。Iobservedonefaultinhisgeneralproceeding。Henevermanfullyputforwardtheentirestrengthofhiscause。Hetemporised,hemanaged,and,adoptingverynearlythesentimentsofhisadversaries,heopposedtheirinferences。This,forapoliticalcommander,isthechoiceofaweakpost。Hisadversarieshadthebetteroftheargument,ashehandledit,notasthereasonandjusticeofhiscauseenabledhimtomanageit。I
saythis,afterhavingseen,andwithsomecareexamined,theoriginaldocumentsconcerningcertainimportanttransactionsofthosetimes。Theyperfectlysatisfiedmeoftheextremeinjusticeofthatwar,andofthefalsehoodofthecolourswhich,tohisownruin,andguidedbyamistakenpolicy,hesufferedtobedaubedoverthatmeasure。Someyearsafter,itwasmyfortunetoconversewithmanyoftheprincipalactorsagainstthatminister,andwiththosewhoprincipallyexcitedthatclamour。Noneofthem,nonotone,didintheleastdefendthemeasure,orattempttojustifytheirconduct。Theycondemneditasfreelyastheywouldhavedoneincommentinguponanyproceedinginhistory,inwhichtheyweretotallyunconcerned。Thusitwillbe。Theywhostirupthepeopletoimproperdesires,whetherofpeaceorwar,willbecondemnedbythemselves。Theywhoweaklyyieldtothemwillbecondemnedbyhistory。
POLITICALPEACE。
Howaquestionofpeacecanbediscussedwithouthavingtheminview,I
cannotimagine。Ifyouorothersseeawayoutofthesedifficulties,I
amhappy。Isee,indeed,afundfromwhenceequivalentswillbeproposed。Iseeit,butIcannotjustnowtouchit。Itisaquestionofhighmoment。ItopensanotherIliadofwoestoEurope。
SuchisthetimeproposedformakingACOMMONPOLITICALPEACE;towhichnoonecircumstanceispropitious。Astothegrandprincipleofthepeace,itisleft,asifbycommonconsent,whollyoutofthequestion。
Viewingthingsinthislight,Ihavefrequentlysunkintoadegreeofdespondencyanddejectionhardlytobedescribed;yetoutoftheprofoundestdepthsofthisdespair,animpulse,whichIhaveinvainendeavouredtoresist,hasurgedmetoraiseonefeeblecryagainstthisunfortunatecoalitionwhichisformedathome,inordertomakeacoalitionwithFrance,subversiveofthewholeancientorderoftheworld。Nodisasterofwar,nocalamityofseason,couldeverstrikemewithhalfthehorrorwhichIfeltfromwhatisintroducedtousbythisjunctionofparties,underthesoothingnameofpeace。Weareapttospeakofalowandpusillanimousspiritastheordinarycausebywhichdubiouswarsterminatedinhumiliatingtreaties。Itisherethedirectcontrary。Iamperfectlyastonishedattheboldnessofcharacter,attheintrepidityofmind,thefirmnessofnerve,inthosewhoareablewithdeliberationtofacetheperilsofJacobinfraternity。
Thisfraternityisindeedsoterribleinitsnature,andinitsmanifestconsequences,thatthereisnowayofquietingourapprehensionsaboutit,butbytotallyputtingitoutofsight,bysubstitutingforit,throughasortofperiphrasis,somethingofanambiguousquality,anddescribingsuchaconnectionunderthetermsof“THEUSUALRELATIONSOF
PEACEANDAMITY。”Bythismeanstheproposedfraternityishustledinthecrowdofthosetreaties,whichimplynochangeinthepubliclawofEurope,andwhichdonotuponsystemaffecttheinteriorconditionofnations。Itisconfoundedwiththoseconventionsinwhichmattersofdisputeamongsovereignpowersarecompromised,bythetakingoffadutymoreorless,bythesurrenderofafrontiertown,oradisputeddistrict,ontheonesideortheother;bypactionsinwhichthepretensionsoffamiliesaresettled(asbyaconveyancer,makingfamilysubstitutionsandsuccessions),withoutanyalterationsinthelaws,manners,religion,privileges,andcustoms,ofthecities,orterritories,whicharethesubjectofsucharrangements。
Allthisbodyofoldconventions,composingthevastandvoluminouscollectioncalledthecorpsdiplomatique,formsthecodeorstatutelaw,asthemethodisedreasoningsofthegreatpublicistsandjuristsformthedigestandjurisprudenceoftheChristianworld。InthesetreasuresaretobefoundtheUSUALrelationsofpeaceandamityincivilizedEurope;andtheretherelationsofancientFranceweretobefoundamongsttherest。
ThepresentsysteminFranceisnottheancientFrance。ItisnottheancientFrancewithordinaryambitionandordinarymeans。Itisnotanewpowerofanoldkind。Itisanewpowerofanewspecies。WhensuchaquestionableshapeistobeadmittedforthefirsttimeintothebrotherhoodofChristendom,itisnotamerematterofidlecuriositytoconsiderhowfaritisinitsnaturealliablewiththerest,orwhether“therelationsofpeaceandamity“withthisnewstatearelikelytobeofthesamenaturewiththeUSUALrelationsofthestatesofEurope。
PUBLICLOANS。
Itisnever,therefore,wisetoquarrelwiththeinterestedviewsofmen,whilsttheyarecombinedwiththepublicinterestandpromoteit:
itisourbusinesstotietheknot,ifpossible,closer。Resourcesthatarederivedfromextraordinaryvirtues,assuchvirtuesarerare,sotheymustbeunproductive。Itisagoodthingforamoniedmantopledgehispropertyonthewelfareofhiscountry;heshowsthatheplaceshistreasurewherehisheartis;and,revolvinginthiscircle,weknowthat“whereveraman’streasureis,therehisheartwillbealso。”Forthesereasons,andontheseprinciples,Ihavebeensorrytoseetheattemptswhichhavebeenmade,withmoregoodmeaningthanforesightandconsideration,towardsraisingtheannualinterestofthisloanbyprivatecontributions。Whereveraregularrevenueisestablished,therevoluntarycontributioncananswernopurpose,buttodisorderanddisturbitinitscourse。Torecurtosuchaidsis,forsomuch,todissolvethecommunity,andtoreturntoastateofunconnectednature。
Andevenifsuchasupplyshouldbeproductive,inadegreecommensuratetoitsobject,itmustalsobeproductiveofmuchvexation,andmuchoppression。Eitherthecitizens,bytheproposedduties,paytheirproportionaccordingtosomeratemadebypublicauthority,ortheydonot。Ifthelawbewellmade,andthecontributionsfoundedonjustproportions,everythingsuperaddedbysomethingthatisnotasregularaslaw,andasuniforminitsoperation,willbecomemoreorlessoutofproportion。If,onthecontrary,thelawbenotmadeuponpropercalculation,itisadisgracetothepublicwisdom,whichfailsinskilltoassessthecitizeninjustmeasure,andaccordingtohismeans。Butthehandofauthorityisnotalwaysthemostheavyhand。Itisobvious,thatmenmaybeoppressedbymanyways,besidesthosewhichtaketheircoursefromthesupremepowerofthestate。Supposethepaymenttobewhollydiscretionary。Whateverhasitsoriginincaprice,issurenottoimproveinitsprogress,nortoendinreason。Itisimpossibleforeachprivateindividualtohaveanymeasureconformabletotheparticularconditionofeachofhisfellow-citizens,ortothegeneralexigenciesofhiscountry。’Tisarandomshotatbest。
Whenmenproceedinthisirregularmode,thefirstcontributorisapttogrowpeevishwithhisneighbours。Heisbuttoowelldisposedtomeasuretheirmeansbyhisownenvy,andnotbytherealstateoftheirfortunes,whichhecanrarelyknow,andwhichitmayinthembeanactofthegrossestimprudencetoreveal。Hencetheodiumandlassitude,withwhichpeoplewilllookuponaprovisionforthepublic,whichisboughtbydiscordattheexpenseofsocialquiet。Hencethebitterheart-burnings,andthewaroftongues,whichissooftenthepreludetootherwars。Norisiteverycontribution,calledvoluntary,whichisaccordingtothefreewillofthegiver。Afalseshame,orafalseglory,againsthisfeelingsandhisjudgment,maytaxanindividualtothedetrimentofhisfamily,andinwrongofhiscreditors。Apretenceofpublicspiritmaydisablehimfromtheperformanceofhisprivateduties。Itmaydisablehimevenfrompayingthelegitimatecontributionswhichheistofurnishaccordingtotheprescriptofthelaw;butwhatisthemostdangerousofallis,thatmalignantdispositiontowhichthismodeofcontributionevidentlytends,andwhichatlengthleavesthecomparativelyindigenttojudgeofthewealth,andtoprescribetotheopulent,orthosewhomtheyconceivetobesuch,theusetheyaretomakeoftheirfortunes。Fromthenceitisbutonesteptothesubversionofallproperty。
HISTORICALSTRICTURES。
Theauthordoesnotconfinethebenefitoftheregicidelessontokingsalone。Hehasadiffusivebounty。Nobles,andmenofproperty,willlikewisebegreatlyreformed。Theytoowillbeledtoareviewoftheirsocialsituationandduties;“andwillreflect,thattheirlargeallotmentofworldlyadvantagesisfortheaidandbenefitofthewhole。”IsitthenfromthefateofJuignie,archbishopofParis,orofthecardinaldeRochefoucault,andofsomanyothers,whogavetheirfortunes,and,Imaysay,theirverybeings,tothepoor,thatthericharetolearn,thattheir“fortunesarefortheaidandbenefitofthewhole?”Isaynothingoftheliberalpersonsofgreatrankandproperty,layandecclesiastic,menandwomen,towhomwehavehadthehonourandhappinessofaffordinganasylum,——Ipassbythese,lestIshouldneverhavedone,orlestIshouldomitsomeasdeservingasanyImightmention。Whywilltheauthorthensuppose,thatthenoblesandmenofpropertyinFrancehavebeenbanished,confiscated,andmurdered,onaccountofthesavagenessandferocityoftheircharacter,andtheirbeingtaintedwithvicesbeyondthoseofthesameorderanddescriptioninothercountries?Nojudgeofarevolutionarytribunal,withhishandsdippedintheirblood,andhismawgorgedwiththeirproperty,hasyetdaredtoassertwhatthisauthorhasbeenpleased,bywayofamorallesson,toinsinuate。
Theirnobility,andtheirmenofproperty,inamass,hadtheverysamevirtuesandtheverysamevices,andintheverysameproportions,withthesamedescriptionofmeninthisandinothernations。Imustdojusticetosufferinghonour,generosity,andintegrity。Idonotknow,thatanytime,oranycountry,hasfurnishedmoresplendidexamplesofeveryvirtue,domesticandpublic。IdonotenterintothecouncilsofProvidence:but,humanlyspeaking,manyofthesenoblesandmenofproperty,fromwhosedisastrousfateweare,itseems,tolearnageneralsofteningofcharacter,andarevisionofoursocialsituationsandduties,appeartomefullaslittledeservingofthatfate,astheauthor,whoeverheis,canbe。Manyofthem,Iamsure,weresuch,asI
shouldbeproudindeedtobeabletocomparemyselfwith,inknowledge,inintegrity,andineveryothervirtue。Myfeeblenaturemightshrink,thoughtheirsdidnot,fromtheproof;butmyreasonandmyambitiontellme,thatitwouldbeagoodbargaintopurchasetheirmeritswiththeirfate。
Forwhichofhisvicesdidthatgreatmagistrate,D’Espremenil,losehisfortuneandhishead?WhatweretheabominationsofMalesherbes,thatotherexcellentmagistrate,whosesixtyyearsofuniformvirtuewasacknowledged,intheveryactofhismurder,bythejudicialbutchers,whocondemnedhim?Onaccountofwhatmisdemeanorswasherobbedofhisproperty,andslaughteredwithtwogenerationsofhisoffspring;andtheremainsofthethirdrace,witharefinementofcruelty,andlesttheyshouldappeartoreclaimthepropertyforfeitedbythevirtuesoftheirancestor,confoundedinanhospitalwiththethousandsofthoseunhappyfoundlinginfants,whoareabandoned,withoutrelation,andwithoutname,bythewretchednessorbytheprofligacyoftheirparents?
IsthefateofthequeenofFrancetoproducethissofteningofcharacter?Wassheapersonsoveryferociousandcruelas,bytheexampleofherdeath,tofrightenusintocommonhumanity?Istherenowaytoteachtheemperorasofteningofcharacter,andareviewofhissocialsituationandduty,buthisconsent,byaninfamousaccordwithregicide,todriveasecondcoachwiththeAustrianarmsthroughthestreetsofParis,alongwhich,afteraseriesofpreparatoryhorrors,exceedingtheatrocitiesofthebloodyexecutionitself,thegloryoftheimperialracehadbeencarriedtoanignominiousdeath?IsthisalessonofMODERATIONtoadescendantofMariaTheresa,drawnfromthefateofthedaughterofthatincomparablewomanandsovereign?Ifhelearnsthislessonfromsuchanobject,andfromsuchteachers,themanmayremain,butthekingisdeposed。Ifhedoesnotcarryquiteanothermemoryofthattransactionintheinmostrecessesofhisheart,heisunworthytoreign;heisunworthytolive。Inthechronicleofdisgracehewillhavebutthisshorttaletoldofhim,“hewasthefirstemperorofhishousethatembracedaregicide:hewasthelastthatworetheimperialpurple。”——FaramIfromthinkingsoillofthisaugustsovereign,whoisattheheadofthemonarchiesofEurope,andwhoisthetrusteeoftheirdignitiesandhisown。WhatferocityofcharacterdrewonthefateofElizabeth,thesisterofKingLouistheSixteenth?
Forwhichofthevicesofthatpatternofbenevolence,ofpiety,andofallthevirtues,didtheyputhertodeath?Forwhichofhervicesdidtheyputtodeaththemildestofallhumancreatures,theduchessofBiron?Whatwerethecrimesofthosecrowdsofmatronsandvirginsofcondition,whomtheymassacred,withtheirjuriesofblood,inprisonsandonscaffolds?Whatweretheenormitiesoftheinfantking,whomtheycaused,bylingeringtortures,toperishintheirdungeon,andwhom,ifatlasttheydespatchedbypoison,itwasinthatdetestablecrimetheonlyactofmercytheyhaveevershown?
Whatsofteningofcharacteristobehad,whatreviewoftheirsocialsituationsanddutiesistobetaught,bytheseexamples,tokings,tonobles,tomenofproperty,towomen,andtoinfants?Theroyalfamilyperished,becauseitwasroyal。Thenoblesperished,becausetheywerenoble。Themen,women,andchildren,whohadproperty,becausetheyhadpropertytoberobbedof。Thepriestswerepunished,aftertheyhadbeenrobbedoftheirall,notfortheirvices,butfortheirvirtuesandtheirpiety,whichmadethemanhonourtotheirsacredprofession,andtothatnature,ofwhichweoughttobeproud,sincetheybelongtoit。
MyLord,nothingcanbelearnedfromsuchexamples,exceptthedangerofbeingkings,queens,nobles,priests,andchildren,tobebutcheredonaccountoftheirinheritance。Thesearethings,atwhichnotvice,notcrime,notfolly,butwisdom,goodness,learning,justice,probity,beneficence,standaghast。Bytheseexamplesourreasonandourmoralsensearenotenlightened,butconfounded;andthereisnorefugeforastonishedandaffrightedvirtue,butbeingannihilatedinhumilityandsubmission,sinkingintoasilentadorationoftheinscrutabledispensationsofProvidence,andflying,withtremblingwings,fromthisworldofdaringcrimes,andfeeble,pusillanimous,half-bred,bastardjustice,totheasylumofanotherorderofthings,inanunknownform,butinabetterlife。
WhateverthepoliticianorpreacherofSeptemberorofOctobermaythinkofthematter,itisamostcomfortless,disheartening,desolatingexample。Dreadfulistheexampleofruinedinnocenceandvirtue,andthecompletesttriumphofthecompletestvillainy,thatevervexedanddisgracedmankind!Theexampleisruinousineverypointofview,religious,moral,civil,political。ItestablishesthatdreadfulmaximofMachiavel,thatingreataffairsmenarenottobewickedbyhalves。
Thismaximisnotmadeforamiddlesortofbeings,who,becausetheycannotbeangels,oughttothwarttheirambition,andnotendeavourtobecomeinfernalspirits。Itistoowellexemplifiedinthepresenttime,wherethefaultsanderrorsofhumanity,checkedbytheimperfecttimorousvirtues,havebeenoverpoweredbythosewhohavestoppedatnocrime。Itisadreadfulpartoftheexample,thatinfernalmalevolencehashadpiousapologists,whoreadtheirlecturesonfrailtiesinfavourofcrimes;whoabandontheweak,andcourtthefriendshipofthewicked。
Torootoutthesemaxims,andtheexamplesthatsupportthem,isawiseobjectofyearsofwar。Thisisthatwar。Thisisthatmoralwar。ItwassaidbyoldTrivulzio,thatthebattleofMarignanwasthebattleofthegiants,thatalltherestofthemanyhehadseenwerethoseofthecranesandpigmies。Thisistrueoftheobjects,atleast,ofthecontest。Forthegreaterpartofthose,whichwehavehithertocontendedfor,incomparison,werethetoysofchildren。
TheOctoberpoliticianissofullofcharityandgoodnature,thathesupposes,thattheseveryrobbersandmurderersthemselvesareinacourseofmelioration;onwhatgroundIcannotconceive,exceptonthelongpracticeofeverycrime,andbyitscompletesuccess。HeisanOrigenist,andbelievesintheconversionofthedevil。Allthatrunsintheplaceofbloodinhisveinsisnothingbutthemilkofhumankindness。Heisassoftasacurd,though,asapolitician,hemightbesupposedtobemadeofsternerstuff。Hesupposes(tousehisownexpression)“thatthesalutarytruths,whichheinculcates,aremakingtheirwayintotheirbosoms。”Theirbosomisarockofgranite,onwhichfalsehoodhaslongsincebuiltherstronghold。Poortruthhashadahardworkofitwithherlittlepickaxe。Nothingbutgunpowderwilldo。Asaproof,however,oftheprogressofthissapofTruth,hegivesusaconfessiontheyhadmadenotlongbeforehewrote。“Theirfraternity“
(aswaslatelystatedbythemselvesinasolemnreport)“hasbeenthebrotherhoodofCainandAbel,andtheyhaveorganizednothingbutBankruptcyandFamine。”Averyhonestconfession,truly;andmuchinthespiritoftheiroracle,Rousseau。Yet,whatisstillmoremarvellousthantheconfession,thisistheveryfraternitytowhichourauthorgivesussuchanobliginginvitationtoaccede。Thereis,indeed,avacancyinthefraternalcorps;abrotherandapartneriswanted。Ifweplease,wemayfilluptheplaceofthebutcheredAbel;and,whilstwewaitthedestinyofthedepartedbrother,wemayenjoytheadvantagesofthepartnership,byentering,withoutdelay,intoashopofready-madebankruptcyandfamine。Thesearethedouceurs,bywhichweareinvitedtoregicidefraternityandfriendship。Butstillourauthorconsiderstheconfessionasaproof,that“truthismakingitswayintotheirbosoms。”No!Itisnotmakingitswayintotheirbosoms。Ithasforceditswayintotheirmouths!Theevilspirit,bywhichtheyarepossessed,thoughessentiallyaliar,isforced,bythetorturesofconscience,toconfessthetruth:toconfessenoughfortheircondemnation,butnotfortheiramendment。Shakspeareveryaptlyexpressesthiskindofconfession,devoidofrepentance,fromthemouthofausurper,amurderer,andaregicide——
“Weareourselvescompelled,Eventotheteethandforeheadofourfaults,Togiveinevidence。”
Whenceistheiramendment?Why,theauthorwrites,that,ontheirmurderousinsurrectionarysystem,theirownlivesarenotsureforanhour;norhastheirpoweragreaterstability。True。Theyareconvincedofit;andaccordinglythewretcheshavedonealltheycantopreservetheirlives,andtosecuretheirpower;butnotonestephavetheytakentoamendtheone,ortomakeamorejustuseoftheother。
CONSTITUTIONNOTTHEPEOPLE’SSLAVE。
ThereisonetopicuponwhichIhopeIshallbeexcusedingoingalittlebeyondmydesign。Thefactions,nowsobusyamongstus,inordertodivestmenofalllovefortheircountry,andtoremovefromtheirmindsalldutywithregardtothestate,endeavourtopropagateanopinion,thatthePEOPLE,informingtheircommonwealth,havebynomeanspartedwiththeirpoweroverit。Thisisanimpregnablecitadel,towhichthesegentlemenretreatwhenevertheyarepushedbythebatteryoflawsandusages,andpositiveconventions。Indeed,itissuchandofsogreatforce,thatalltheyhavedone,indefendingtheiroutworks,issomuchtimeandlabourthrownaway。Discussanyoftheirschemes——theiransweris——ItistheactofthePEOPLE,andthatissufficient。ArewetodenytoaMAJORITYofthepeopletherightofalteringeventhewholeframeoftheirsociety,ifsuchshouldbetheirpleasure?Theymaychangeit,saythey,fromamonarchytoarepublicto?day,andto-morrowbackagainfromarepublictoamonarchy,andsobackwardandforwardasoftenastheylike。Theyaremastersofthecommonwealth;becauseinsubstancetheyarethemselvesthecommonwealth。TheFrenchrevolution,saythey,wastheactofthemajorityofthepeople;andifthemajorityofanyotherpeople,thepeopleofEnglandforinstance,wishtomakethesamechange,theyhavethesameright。Justthesame,undoubtedly。
Thatis,noneatall。Neitherthefewnorthemanyhavearighttoactmerelybytheirwill,inanymatterconnectedwithduty,trust,engagement,orobligation。Theconstitutionofacountrybeingoncesettleduponsomecompact,tacitorexpressed,thereisnopowerexistingofforcetoalterit,withoutthebreachofthecovenant,ortheconsentofalltheparties。Suchisthenatureofacontract。Andthevotesofamajorityofthepeople,whatevertheirinfamousflatterersmayteachinordertocorrupttheirminds,cannotalterthemoralanymorethantheycanalterthephysicalessenceofthings。Thepeoplearenottobetaughttothinklightlyoftheirengagementstotheirgovernors;elsetheyteachgovernorstothinklightlyoftheirengagementstowardsthem。Inthatkindofgameintheendthepeoplearesuretobelosers。Toflatterthemintoacontemptoffaith,truth,andjustice,istoruinthem;forinthesevirtuesconsisttheirwholesafety。Toflatteranyman,oranypartofmankind,inanydescription,byasserting,thatinengagementsheortheyarefreewhilstanyotherhumancreatureisbound,isultimatelytovesttheruleofmoralityinthepleasureofthosewhooughttoberigidlysubmittedtoit;tosubjectthesovereignreasonoftheworldtothecapricesofweakandgiddymen。
But,asnooneofusmencandispensewithpublicorprivatefaith,orwithanyothertieofmoralobligation,soneithercananynumberofus。
Thenumberengagedincrimes,insteadofturningthemintolaudableacts,onlyaugmentsthequantityandintensityoftheguilt。Iamwellawarethatmenlovetohearoftheirpower,buthaveanextremedisrelishtobetoldoftheirduty。Thisisofcourse,becauseeverydutyisalimitationofsomepower。Indeedarbitrarypowerissomuchtothedepravedtasteofthevulgar,ofthevulgarofeverydescription,thatalmostallthedissensions,whichlaceratethecommonwealth,arenotconcerningthemannerinwhichitistobeexercised,butconcerningthehandsinwhichitistobeplaced。Somewheretheyareresolvedtohaveit。Whethertheydesireittobevestedinthemanyorthefew,dependswithmostmenuponthechancewhichtheyimaginetheythemselvesmayhaveofpartakingintheexerciseofthatarbitrarysway,intheonemodeorintheother。
Itisnotnecessarytoteachmentothirstafterpower。Butitisveryexpedientthatbymoralinstruction,theyshouldbetaught,andbytheircivilconstitutionstheyshouldbecompelled,toputmanyrestrictionsupontheimmoderateexerciseofit,andtheinordinatedesire。Thebestmethodofobtainingthesetwogreatpointsformstheimportant,butatthesametimethedifficult,problemtothetruestatesman。Hethinksoftheplaceinwhichpoliticalpoweristobelodged,withnootherattention,thanasitmayrenderthemoreorthelesspracticable,itssalutaryrestraint,anditsprudentdirection。Forthisreasonnolegislator,atanyperiodoftheworld,haswillinglyplacedtheseatofactivepowerinthehandsofthemultitude:becausethereitadmitsofnocontrolnoregulation,nosteadydirectionwhatsoever。Thepeoplearethenaturalcontrolonauthority;buttoexerciseandtocontroltogetheriscontradictoryandimpossible。
Astheexorbitantexerciseofpowercannot,underpopularsway,beeffectuallyrestrained,theothergreatobjectofpoliticalarrangement,themeansofabatinganexcessivedesireofit,isinsuchastatestillworseprovidedfor。Thedemocraticcommonwealthisthefoodfulnurseofambition。Undertheotherformsitmeetswithmanyrestraints。Whenever,instateswhichhavehadademocraticbasis,thelegislatorshaveendeavouredtoputrestraintsuponambition,theirmethodswereasviolent,asintheendtheywereineffectual:asviolentindeedasanythemostjealousdespotismcouldinvent。Theostracismcouldnotverylongsaveitself,andmuchlessthestatewhichitwasmeanttoguard,fromtheattemptsofambition,oneofthenatural,inbred,incurabledistempersofapowerfuldemocracy。
MODERN“LIGHTS。”
Greatlightstheysayarelatelyobtainedintheworld;andMr。Burke,insteadofshroudinghimselfinexplodedignorance,oughttohavetakenadvantageoftheblazeofilluminationwhichhasbeenspreadabouthim。
Itmaybeso。Theenthusiastsofthistime,itseems,liketheirpredecessorsinanotherfactionoffanaticism,dealinlights——Hudibraspleasantlysaystothem,they,“HaveLIGHTS,wherebettereyesareblind,Aspigsaresaidtoseethewind。”
TheauthoroftheReflectionshasHEARDagreatdealconcerningthemodernlights;buthehasnotyethadthegoodfortunetoSEEmuchofthem。Hehasreadmorethanhecanjustifytoanythingbutthespiritofcuriosity,oftheworksoftheseilluminatorsoftheworld。Hehaslearnednothingfromthefargreaternumberofthem,thanafullcertaintyoftheirshallowness,levity,pride,petulance,presumption,andignorance。Wheretheoldauthorswhomhehasread,andtheoldmenwhomhehasconversedwith,havelefthiminthedark,heisinthedarkstill。Ifothers,however,haveobtainedanyofthisextraordinarylight,theywilluseittoguidethemintheirresearchesandtheirconduct。Ihaveonlytowish,thatthenationmaybeashappyandasprosperousundertheinfluenceofthenewlight,asithasbeeninthesobershadeoftheoldobscurity。
REPUBLICSINTHEABSTRACT。
Inthesamedebate,Mr。BurkewasrepresentedbyMr。FoxasarguinginamannerwhichimpliedthattheBritishconstitutioncouldnotbedefended,butbyabusingallrepublicsancientandmodern。Hesaidnothingtogivetheleastgroundforsuchacensure。Heneverabusedallrepublics。Hehasneverprofessedhimselfafriendoranenemytorepublicsortomonarchiesintheabstract。Hethoughtthatthecircumstancesandhabitsofeverycountry,whichitisalwaysperilousandproductiveofthegreatestcalamitiestoforce,aretodecideupontheformofitsgovernment。Thereisnothinginhisnature,histemper,orhisfaculties,whichshouldmakehimanenemytoanyrepublicmodernorancient。Farfromit。Hehasstudiedtheformandspiritofrepublicsveryearlyinlife;hehasstudiedthemwithgreatattention;andwithamindundisturbedbyaffectionorprejudice。Heisindeedconvincedthatthescienceofgovernmentwouldbepoorlycultivatedwithoutthatstudy。
Buttheresultinhismindfromthatinvestigationhasbeen,andis,thatneitherEnglandnorFrance,withoutinfinitedetrimenttothem,aswellintheeventasintheexperiment,couldbebroughtintoarepublicanform;butthateverythingrepublicanwhichcanbeintroducedwithsafetyintoeitherofthem,mustbebuiltuponamonarchy;builtuponareal,notanominal,monarchy,ASITSESSENTIALBASIS;thatallsuchinstitutions,whetheraristocraticordemocratic,mustoriginatefromthecrown,andinalltheirproceedingsmustrefertoit;thatbytheenergyofthatmainspringalonethoserepublicanpartsmustbesetinaction,andfromthencemustderivetheirwholelegaleffect(asamongstustheyactuallydo),orthewholewillfallintoconfusion。
Theserepublicanmembershavenootherpointbutthecrowninwhichtheycanpossiblyunite。
ThisistheopinionexpressedinMr。Burke’sbook。Hehasnevervariedinthatopinionsincehecametoyearsofdiscretion。Butsurely,ifitanytimeofhislifehehadentertainedothernotions(whichhoweverhehasneverheldorprofessedtohold),thehorriblecalamitiesbroughtuponagreatpeople,bythewildattempttoforcetheircountryintoarepublic,mightbemorethansufficienttoundeceivehisunderstanding,andtofreeitforeverfromsuchdestructivefancies。Heiscertain,thatmany,eveninFrance,havebeenmadesickoftheirtheoriesbytheirverysuccessinrealizingthem。
ANENGLISHMONARCH。
Heisarealking,andnotanexecutiveofficer。Ifhewillnottroublehimselfwithcontemptibledetails,norwishtodegradehimselfbybecomingapartyinlittlesquabbles,Iamfarfromsure,thatakingofGreatBritain,inwhateverconcernshimasaking,orindeedasarationalman,whocombineshispublicinterestwithhispersonalsatisfaction,doesnotpossessamorereal,solid,extensivepower,thanthekingofFrancewaspossessedofbeforethismiserablerevolution。
ThedirectpowerofthekingofEnglandisconsiderable。Hisindirect,andfarmorecertainpower,isgreatindeed。Hestandsinneedofnothingtowardsdignity;ofnothingtowardssplendour;ofnothingtowardsauthority;ofnothingatalltowardsconsiderationabroad。WhenwasitthatakingofEnglandwantedwherewithaltomakehimrespected,courted,orperhapsevenfeared,ineverystateofEurope?
PHYSIOGNOMY。
ThePHYSIOGNOMYhasaconsiderableshareinbeauty,especiallyinthatofourownspecies。Themannersgiveacertaindeterminationtothecountenance;which,beingobservedtocorrespondprettyregularlywiththem,iscapableofjoiningtheeffectofcertainagreeablequalitiesofthemindtothoseofthebody。Sothattoformafinishedhumanbeauty,andtogiveititsfullinfluence,thefacemustbeexpressiveofsuchgentleandamiablequalities,ascorrespondwiththesoftness,smoothness,anddelicacyoftheoutwardform。
THEEYE。
IhavehithertopurposelyomittedtospeakoftheEYE,whichhassogreatashareinthebeautyoftheanimalcreation,asitdidnotfallsoeasilyundertheforegoingheads,thoughinfactitisreducibletothesameprinciples。Ithinkthen,thatthebeautyoftheeyeconsists,first,initsCLEARNESS;whatCOLOUREDeyeshallpleasemost,dependsagooddealonparticularfancies;butnonearepleasedwithaneyewhosewater(tousethatterm)isdullandmuddy。Wearepleasedwiththeeyeinthisview,ontheprincipleuponwhichwelikediamonds,clearwater,glass,andsuch-liketransparentsubstances。Secondly,themotionoftheeyecontributestoitsbeauty,bycontinuallyshiftingitsdirection;
butaslowandlanguidmotionismorebeautifulthanabriskone;thelatterisenlivening;theformerlovely。Thirdly,withregardtotheunionoftheeyewiththeneighbouringparts,itistoholdthesamerulethatisgivenofotherbeautifulones;itisnottomakeastrongdeviationfromthelineoftheneighbouringparts;nortovergeintoanyexactgeometricalfigure。Besidesallthis,theeyeaffects,asitisexpressiveofsomequalitiesofthemind,anditsprincipalpowergenerallyarisesfromthis;sothatwhatwehavejustsaidofthephysiognomyisapplicablehere。
ABOLITIONANDUSEOFPARLIAMENTS。
Accordingtotheirinvariablecourse,theframersofyourconstitutionhavebegunwiththeouterabolitionoftheparliaments。Thesevenerablebodies,liketherestoftheoldgovernment,stoodinneedofreform,eventhoughthereshouldbenochangemadeinthemonarchy。Theyrequiredseveralmorealterationstoadaptthemtothesystemofafreeconstitution。Buttheyhadparticularsintheirconstitution,andthosenotafew,whichdeservedapprobationfromthewise。Theypossessedonefundamentalexcellence,——theywereindependent。Themostdoubtfulcircumstanceattendantontheiroffice,thatofitsbeingvendible,contributedhowevertothisindependencyofcharacter。Theyheldforlife。Indeedtheymaybesaidtohaveheldbyinheritance。Appointedbythemonarch,theywereconsideredasnearlyoutofhispower。Themostdeterminedexertionsofthatauthorityagainstthemonlyshowedtheirradicalindependence。Theycomposedpermanentbodiespolitic,constitutedtoresistarbitraryinnovation;andfromthatcorporateconstitution,andfrommostoftheirforms,theywerewellcalculatedtoaffordbothcertaintyandstabilitytothelaws。Theyhadbeenasafeasylumtosecuretheselaws,inalltherevolutionsofhumourandopinion。Theyhadsavedthatsacreddepositofthecountryduringthereignsofarbitraryprinces,andthestrugglesofarbitraryfactions。
Theykeptalivethememoryandrecordoftheconstitution。Theywerethegreatsecuritytoprivateproperty;whichmightbesaid(whenpersonallibertyhadnoexistence)tobe,infact,aswellguardedinFranceasinanyothercountry。Whateverissupremeinastate,oughttohave,asmuchaspossible,itsjudicialauthoritysoconstitutedasnotonlynottodependuponit,butinsomesorttobalanceit。Itoughttogiveasecuritytoitsjusticeagainstitspower。Itoughttomakeitsjudicature,asitwere,somethingexteriortothestate。Theseparliamentshadfurnished,notthebestcertainly,butsomeconsiderablecorrectivetotheexcessesandvicesofthemonarchy。Suchanindependentjudicaturewastentimesmorenecessarywhenademocracybecametheabsolutepowerofthecountry。Inthatconstitution,elective,temporary,localjudges,suchasyouhavecontrived,exercisingtheirdependentfunctionsinanarrowsociety,mustbetheworstofalltribunals。Inthemitwillbevaintolookforanyappearanceofjusticetowardsstrangers,towardstheobnoxiousrich,towardstheminorityofroutedparties,towardsallthosewhointheelectionhavesupportedunsuccessfulcandidates。Itwillbeimpossibletokeepthenewtribunalsclearoftheworstspiritoffaction。Allcontrivancesbyballotweknowexperimentallytobevainandchildishtopreventadiscoveryofinclinations。Wheretheymaythebestanswerthepurposesofconcealment,theyanswertoproducesuspicion;andthisisastillmoremischievouscauseofpartiality。
Iftheparliamentshadbeenpreserved,insteadofbeingdissolvedatsoruinousachangetothenation,theymighthaveservedinthisnewcommonwealth,perhapsnotpreciselythesame(Idonotmeananexactparallel),butnearlythesame,purposesasthecourtandsenateofAreopagusdidinAthens;thatis,asoneofthebalancesandcorrectivestotheevilsofalightandunjustdemocracy。Everyoneknowsthatthistribunalwasthegreatstayofthatstate;everyoneknowswithwhatacareitwasupheld,andwithwhatareligiousaweitwasconsecrated。
Theparliamentswerenotwhollyfreefromfaction,Iadmit;butthisevilwasexteriorandaccidental,andnotsomuchtheviceoftheirconstitutionitself,asitmustbeinyournewcontrivanceofsexennialelectivejudicatories。SeveralEnglishcommendtheabolitionoftheoldtribunals,assupposingthattheydeterminedeverythingbybriberyandcorruption。Buttheyhavestoodthetestofmonarchicandrepublicanscrutiny。Thecourtwaswelldisposedtoprovecorruptiononthosebodieswhentheyweredissolvedin1771——Thosewhohaveagaindissolvedthemwouldhavedonethesameiftheycould——butbothinquisitionshavingfailed,Iconclude,thatgrosspecuniarycorruptionmusthavebeenratherrareamongstthem。
Itwouldhavebeenprudent,alongwiththeparliaments,topreservetheirancientpowerofregistering,andofremonstratingatleast,uponallthedecreesoftheNationalAssembly,astheydiduponthosewhichpassedinthetimeofthemonarchy。Itwouldbeameansofsquaringtheoccasionaldecreesofademocracytosomeprinciplesofgeneraljurisprudence。Theviceoftheancientdemocracies,andonecauseoftheirruin,was,thattheyruled,asyoudo,byoccasionaldecrees,——psephismata。Thispracticesoonbrokeinuponthetenorandconsistencyofthelaws;itabatedtherespectofthepeopletowardsthem;andtotallydestroyedthemintheend。
Yourvestingthepowerofremonstrance,which,inthetimeofthemonarchy,existedintheparliamentofParis,inyourprincipalexecutiveofficer,whom,inspiteofcommonsense,youpersevereincallingking,istheheightofabsurdity。Yououghtnevertosufferremonstrancefromhimwhoistoexecute。Thisistounderstandneithercounselnorexecution;neitherauthoritynorobedience。Thepersonwhomyoucallking,oughtnottohavethispower,orheoughttohavemore。
CROMWELLANDHISCONTRASTS。
Cromwell,whenheattemptedtolegalizehispower,andtosettlehisconqueredcountryinastateoforder,didnotlookfordispensersofjusticeintheinstrumentsofhisusurpation。Quitethecontrary。Hesoughtout,withgreatsolicitudeandselection,andevenfromthepartymostoppositetohisdesigns,menofweightanddecorumofcharacter;
menunstainedwiththeviolenceofthetimes,andwithhandsnotfouledwithconfiscationandsacrilege:forhechoseanHALEforhischiefjustice,thoughheabsolutelyrefusedtotakehiscivicoaths,ortomakeanyacknowledgmentwhatsoeverofthelegalityofhisgovernment。
Cromwelltoldthisgreatlawyer,thatsincehedidnotapprovehistitle,allherequiredofhimwas,toadminister,inamanneragreeabletohispuresentimentsandunspottedcharacter,thatjusticewithoutwhichhumansocietycannotsubsist:thatitwasnothisparticulargovernment,butcivilorderitself,which,asajudge,hewishedhimtosupport。Cromwellknewhowtoseparatetheinstitutionsexpedienttohisusurpationfromtheadministrationofthepublicjusticeofhiscountry。
ForCromwellwasamaninwhomambitionhadnotwhollysuppressed,butonlysuspended,thesentimentsofreligion,andthelove(asfarasitcouldconsistwithhisdesigns)offairandhonourablereputation。
Accordingly,weareindebtedtothisactofhisforthepreservationofourlaws,whichsomesenselessassertorsoftherightsofmenwerethenonthepointofentirelyerasing,asrelicsoffeudalityandbarbarism。
Besides,hegaveintheappointmentofthatman,tothatage,andtoallposterity,themostbrilliantexampleofsincereandferventpiety,exactjustice,andprofoundjurisprudence。(SeeBurnet’sLifeofHale。)
ButthesearenotthethingsinwhichyourphilosophicusurperschoosetofollowCromwell。
Onewouldthink,thatafteranhonestandnecessaryrevolution(iftheyhadamindthattheirsshouldpassforsuch)yourmasterswouldhaveimitatedthevirtuouspolicyofthosewhohavebeenattheheadofrevolutionsofthatgloriouscharacter。Burnettellsus,thatnothingtendedtoreconciletheEnglishnationtothegovernmentofKingWilliamsomuchasthecarehetooktofillthevacantbishopricswithmenwhohadattractedthepublicesteembytheirlearning,eloquence,andpiety,and,aboveall,bytheirknownmoderationinthestate。Withyou,inyourpurifyingrevolution,whomhaveyouchosentoregulatethechurch?
Mr。Mirabeauisafinespeaker——andafinewriter,——andafine——averyfineman;——butreallynothinggavemoresurprisetoeverybodyhere,thantofindhimthesupremeheadofyourecclesiasticalaffairs。Therestisofcourse。YourAssemblyaddressesamanifestotoFrance,inwhichtheytellthepeople,withaninsultingirony,thattheyhavebroughtthechurchtoitsprimitivecondition。Inonerespecttheirdeclarationisundoubtedlytrue;fortheyhavebroughtittoastateofpovertyandpersecution。Whatcanbehopedforafterthis?Havenotmen(iftheydeservethename),underthisnewhopeandheadofthechurch,beenmadebishopsfornoothermeritthanhavingactedasinstrumentsofatheists;
fornoothermeritthanhavingthrownthechildren’sbreadtodogs;andinordertogorgethewholegangofusurers,pedlars,anditinerantJew-discountersatthecornersofstreets,starvedthepooroftheirChristianflocks,andtheirownbrotherpastors?Havenotsuchmenbeenmadebishopstoadministerintemples,inwhich(ifthepatrioticdonationshavenotalreadystrippedthemoftheirvessels)thechurchwardensoughttotakesecurityforthealtar-plate,andnotsomuchastotrustthechaliceintheirsacrilegioushands,solongasJewshaveassignatsonecclesiasticplunder,toexchangeforthesilverstolenfromchurches?
DELICACY。
Anairofrobustnessandstrengthisveryprejudicialtobeauty。AnappearanceofDELICACY,andevenoffragility,isalmostessentialtoit。Whoeverexaminesthevegetableoranimalcreationwillfindthisobservationtobefoundedinnature。Itisnottheoak,theash,ortheelm,oranyoftherobusttreesoftheforest,whichweconsiderasbeautiful;theyareawfulandmajestic;theirinspireasortofreverence。Itisthedelicatemyrtle,itistheorange,itisthealmond,itisthejasmine,itisthevine,whichwelookonasvegetablebeauties。Itisthefloweryspecies,soremarkableforitsweaknessandmomentaryduration,thatgivesustheliveliestideaofbeautyandelegance。Amonganimals,thegreyhoundismorebeautifulthanthemastiff;andthedelicacyofagennet,abarb,oranArabianhorse,ismuchmoreamiablethanthestrengthandstabilityofsomehorsesofwarorcarriage。Ineedheresaylittleofthefairsex,whereIbelievethepointwillbeeasilyallowedme。Thebeautyofwomenisconsiderablyowingtotheirweaknessordelicacy,andisevenenhancedbytheirtimidity,aqualityofmindanalogoustoit。I
wouldnotherebeunderstoodtosay,thatweaknessbetrayingverybadhealthhasanyshareinbeauty;buttheilleffectofthisisnotbecauseitisweakness,butbecausetheillstateofhealth,whichproducessuchweakness,alterstheotherconditionsofbeauty;thepartsinsuchacasecollapse;thebrightcolour,——thelumenpurpureumjuventae,isgone;andthefinevariationislostinwrinkles,suddenbreaks,andrightlines。
CONFISCATIONANDCURRENCY。
Astotheoperationofthefirst(theconfiscationandpapercurrency)
merelyasacement,Icannotdenythatthese,theonedependingontheother,mayforsometimecomposesomesortofcement,iftheirmadnessandfollyinthemanagement,andinthetemperingofthepartstogether,doesnotproducearepulsionintheveryoutset。Butallowingtotheschemesomecoherenceandsomeduration,itappearstome,thatif,afterawhile,theconfiscationshouldnotbefoundsufficienttosupportthepapercoinage(asIammorallycertainitwillnot),then,insteadofcementing,itwilladdinfinitelytothedissociation,distraction,andconfusionoftheseconfederaterepublics,bothwithrelationtoeachother,andtotheseveralpartswithinthemselves。Butiftheconfiscationshouldsofarsucceedastosinkthepapercurrency,thecementisgonewiththecirculation。Inthemeantimeitsbindingforcewillbeveryuncertain,anditwillstraitenorrelaxwitheveryvariationinthecreditofthepaper。
Onethingonlyiscertaininthisscheme,whichisaneffectseeminglycollateral,butdirect,Ihavenodoubt,inthemindsofthosewhoconductthisbusiness,thatis,itseffectinproducinganOLIGARCHYineveryoneoftherepublics。Apapercirculation,notfoundedonanyrealmoneydepositedorengagedfor,amountingalreadytofour-and-fortymillionsofEnglishmoney,andthiscurrencybyforcesubstitutedintheplaceofthecoinofthekingdom,becomingtherebythesubstanceofitsrevenue,aswellasthemediumofallitscommercialandcivilintercourse,mustputthewholeofwhatpower,authority,andinfluence,isleft,inanyformwhatsoeveritmayassume,intothehandsofthemanagersandconductorsofthiscirculation。
InEnglandwefeeltheinfluenceofthebank;thoughitisonlythecentreofavoluntarydealing。Heknowslittleindeedoftheinfluenceofmoneyuponmankind,whodoesnotseetheforceofthemanagementofamoniedconcern,whichissomuchmoreextensive,andinitsnaturesomuchmoredependingonthemanagersthananyofours。Butthisisnotmerelyamoneyconcern。Thereisanothermemberinthesysteminseparablyconnectedwiththismoneymanagement。Itconsistsinthemeansofdrawingoutatdiscretionportionsoftheconfiscatedlandsforsale;andcarryingonaprocessofcontinualtransmutationofpaperintoland,andoflandintopaper。Whenwefollowthisprocessinitseffects,wemayconceivesomethingoftheintensityoftheforcewithwhichthissystemmustoperate。Bythismeansthespiritofmoney-jobbingandspeculationgoesintothemassoflanditself,andincorporateswithit。Bythiskindofoperation,thatspeciesofpropertybecomes(asitwere)volatilized;itassumesanunnaturalandmonstrousactivity,andtherebythrowsintothehandsoftheseveralmanagers,principalandsubordinate,Parisianandprovincial,alltherepresentativeofmoney,andperhapsafulltenthpartofallthelandinFrance,whichhasnowacquiredtheworstandmostperniciouspartoftheevilofapapercirculation,——thegreatestpossibleuncertaintyinitsvalue。TheyhavereversedtheLatoniankindnesstothelandedpropertyofDelos。Theyhavesenttheirstobeblownabout,likethelightfragmentsofawreck,orasetlittoracircum。
Thenewdealers,beingallhabituallyadventurers,andwithoutanyfixedhabitsorlocalpredilections,willpurchasetojoboutagain,asthemarketofpaper,orofmoney,orofland,shallpresentanadvantage。
Forthoughaholybishopthinksthatagriculturewillderivegreatadvantagefromthe“ENLIGHTENED“usurerswhoaretopurchasethechurchconfiscations,I,whoamnotagood,butanoldfarmer,withgreathumilitybegleavetotellhislatelordship,thatusuryisnottutorofagriculture;andiftheword“enlightened“beunderstoodaccordingtothenewdictionary,asitalwaysisinyournewschools,Icannotconceivehowaman’snotbelievinginGodcanteachhimtocultivatetheearthwiththeleastofanyadditionalskillorencouragement。“Diisimmortalibussero,“saidanoldRoman,whenheheldonehandleoftheplough,whilstDeathheldtheother。ThoughyouweretojoininthecommissionallthedirectorsofthetwoacademiestothedirectorsoftheCaissed’Escompte,anoldexperiencedpeasantisworththemall。I
havegotmoreinformationuponacuriousandinterestingbranchofhusbandry,inoneshortconversationwithanoldCarthusianmonk,thanI
havederivedfromalltheBankdirectorsthatIhaveeverconversedwith。However,thereisnocauseforapprehensionfromthemeddlingofmoney-dealerswithruraleconomy。Thesegentlemenaretoowiseintheirgeneration。Atfirst,perhaps,theirtenderandsusceptibleimaginationsmaybecaptivatedwiththeinnocentandunprofitabledelightsofapastorallife;butinalittletimetheywillfindthatagricultureisatrademuchmorelaborious,andmuchlesslucrative,thanthatwhichtheyhadleft。Aftermakingitspanegyric,theywillturntheirbacksonitliketheirgreatprecursorandprototype。Theymay,likehim,beginbysinging“Beatusille“——butwhatwillbetheend?
“HaecubilocutusfoeneratorAlphius,JamjamfuturusrusticusOmnemrelegitIdibuspecuniam;
QuaeritCalendisponere。”
TheywillcultivatetheCaissed’Eglise,underthesacredauspicesofthisprelate,withmuchmoreprofitthanitsvineyardsanditscorn-fields。Theywillemploytheirtalentsaccordingtotheirhabitsandtheirinterests。Theywillnotfollowtheploughwhilsttheycandirecttreasuries,andgovernprovinces。
Yourlegislators,ineverythingnew,aretheveryfirstwhohavefoundedacommonwealthupongaming,andinfusedthisspiritintoit,asitsvitalbreath。ThegreatobjectinthesepoliticsistometamorphoseFrancefromagreatkingdomintoonegreatplay-table:toturnitsinhabitantsintoanationofgamesters;tomakespeculationasextensiveaslife;tomixitwithallitsconcerns;andtodivertthewholeofthehopesandfearsofthepeoplefromtheirusualchannelsintotheimpulses,passions,andsuperstitionsofthosewholiveonchances。Theyloudlyproclaimtheiropinion,thatthistheirpresentsystemofarepubliccannotpossiblyexistwithoutthiskindofgamingfund;andthattheverythreadofitslifeisspunoutofthestapleofthesespeculations。Theoldgaminginfundswasmischievousenoughundoubtedly;butitwassoonlytoindividuals。EvenwhenithaditsgreatestextentintheMississippiandSouthSea,itaffectedbutfew,comparatively;whereitextendsfurther,asinlotteries,thespirithasbutasingleobject。Butwherethelaw,whichinmostcircumstancesforbids,andinnonecountenances,gaming,isitselfdebauched,soastoreverseitsnatureandpolicy,andexpresslytoforcethesubjecttothisdestructivetable,bybringingthespiritandsymbolsofgamingintotheminutestmatters,andengagingeverybodyinit,andineverything,amoredreadfulepidemicdistemperofthatkindisspreadthanyethasappearedintheworld。Withyouamancanneitherearnnorbuyhisdinnerwithoutaspeculation。Whathereceivesinthemorningwillnothavethesamevalueatnight。Whatheiscompelledtotakeaspayforanolddebtwillnotbereceivedasthesamewhenhecomestopayadebtcontractedbyhimself;norwillitbethesamewhenbypromptpaymenthewouldavoidcontractinganydebtatall。Industrymustwitheraway。Economymustbedrivenfromyourcountry。Carefulprovisionwillhavenoexistence。Whowilllabourwithoutknowingtheamountofhispay?Whowillstudytoincreasewhatnonecanestimate?Whowillaccumulate,whenhedoesnotknowthevalueofwhathesaves?Ifyouabstractitfromitsusesingaming,toaccumulateyourpaperwealth,wouldbenottheprovidenceofaman,butthedistemperedinstinctofajackdaw。
“OMNIPOTENCEOFCHURCHPLUNDER。”
Theirfanaticalconfidenceintheomnipotenceofchurchplunderhasinducedthesephilosopherstooverlookallcareofthepublicestate,justasthedreamofthephilosopher’sstoneinducesdupes,underthemoreplausibledelusionofthehermeticart,toneglectallrationalmeansofimprovingtheirfortunes。Withthesephilosophicfinanciers,thisuniversalmedicinemadeofchurchmummyistocurealltheevilsofthestate。Thesegentlemen,perhaps,donotbelieveagreatdealinthemiraclesofpiety;butitcannotbequestioned,thattheyhaveanundoubtingfaithintheprodigiesofsacrilege。Isthereadebtwhichpressesthem?——Issueassignats。Arecompensationstobemade,oramaintenancedecreedtothosewhomtheyhaverobbedoftheirfreeholdintheiroffice,orexpelledfromtheirprofession?——Assignats。Isafleettobefittedout?——Assignats。Ifsixteenmillionssterlingoftheseassignats,forcedonthepeople,leavethewantsofthestateasurgentasever——issue,saysone,thirtymillionssterlingofassignats——saysanother,issuefourscoremillionsmoreofassignats。Theonlydifferenceamongtheirfinancialfactionsisonthegreaterorthelesserquantityofassignatstobeimposedonthepublicsufferance。Theyareallprofessorsofassignats。Eventhose,whosenaturalgoodsenseandknowledgeofcommerce,notobliteratedbyphilosophy,furnishdecisiveargumentsagainstthisdelusionconcludetheirargumentsbyproposingtheemissionofassignats。Isupposetheymusttalkofassignats,asnootherlanguagewouldbeunderstood。Allexperienceoftheirinefficacydoesnotintheleastdiscouragethem。Aretheoldassignatsdepreciatedatmarket?Whatistheremedy?Issuenewassignats——Maissimaladiaopiniatria,nonvultsegarire,quidillifacere?assignare——posteaassignare;ensuitaassignare。Thewordisatriflealtered。TheLatinofyourpresentdoctorsmaybebetterthanthatofyouroldcomedy;theirwisdomandthevarietyoftheirresourcesarethesame。Theyhavenotmorenotesintheirsongthanthecuckoo;though,farfromthesoftnessofthatharbingerofsummerandplenty,theirvoiceisasharshandasominousasthatoftheraven。
UGLINESS。
Itmay,perhaps,appearlikeasortofrepetitionofwhatwehavebeforesaid,toinsisthereuponthenatureofUGLINESS;asIimagineittobeinallrespectstheoppositetothosequalitieswhichwehavelaiddownfortheconstituentsofbeauty。Butthoughuglinessbetheoppositetobeauty,itisnottheoppositetoproportionandfitness。Foritispossiblethatathingmaybeveryuglywithanyproportions,andwithaperfectfitnesstoanyuses。UglinessIimaginelikewisetobeconsistentenoughwithanideaofthesublime。ButIwouldbynomeansinsinuatethatuglinessofitselfisasublimeidea,unlessunitedwithsuchqualitiesasexciteastrongterror。
GRACE。
GRACEFULNESSisanideanotverydifferentfrombeauty;itconsistsinmuchthesamethings。GracefulnessisanideabelongingtoPOSTUREandMOTION。Inboththese,tobegraceful,itisrequisitethattherebenoappearanceofdifficulty;thereisrequiredasmallinflectionofthebody;andacomposureofthepartsinsuchamanner,asnottoencumbereachother,nottoappeardividedbysharpandsuddenangles。Inthisease,thisroundness,thisdelicacyofattitudeandmotion,itisthatallthemagicofgraceconsists,andwhatiscalleditsjenesaisquoi;
aswillbeobvioustoanyobserver,whoconsidersattentivelytheVenusdeMedicis,theAntinous,oranystatuegenerallyallowedtobegracefulinahighdegree。
ELEGANCEANDSPECIOUSNESS。
Whenanybodyiscomposedofpartssmoothandpolished,withoutpressinguponeachother,withoutshowinganyruggednessorconfusion,andatthesametimeaffectingsomeREGULARSHAPE,IcallitELEGANT。Itiscloselyalliedtothebeautiful,differingfromitonlyinthisREGULARITY;
which,however,asitmakesaverymaterialdifferenceintheaffectionproduced,mayverywellconstituteanotherspecies。UnderthisheadI
rankthosedelicateandregularworksofart,thatimitatenodeterminateobjectinnature,aselegantbuildings,andpiecesoffurniture。Whenanyobjectpartakesoftheabove-mentionedqualities,areofthoseofbeautifulbodies,andiswithalofgreatdimensions,itisfullasremotefromtheideaofmerebeauty:IcallitFINEorSPECIOUS。