第14章

类别:其他 作者:Paul Vinogradoff字数:4896更新时间:18/12/22 09:34:25
49。Palgrave,RotuliCuriaeRegis,ii。192。 50。PlacitorumAbbrev。25,29;Note-book,pl。88。(ThefatheriscalledAilfricusinthePleaRollDiversterms2John,2d。,attheRecordOffice。) 51。Bract。Note-book,pl。88。 52。Case70:’ConsideratumestquodterraillaestuilenagiumipsiusHugonis(corr。Johannis),etquodsiMartinusuolueritterramtenerefaciatconsuetudinesquaspatersuusfecit,sinautemcapiatterramsuaminmanumsuam。’ 53。MarginalremarkintheNote-booktopl。70:’Notaquodliberhomopotestfacereuillanasconsuetudinesracionetenementiuillanisetpropterhocnonerituillanus,quiapotestrelinqueretenementum。’Comp。MrMaitland’snotetothecase。 54。Bracton,f199b:’Undevideturperhoc,quodlicetliberhomoteneatvillenagiumpervillanasconsuetudines,contravoluntatemsuamejicinondebet,dumtamenfacerevolueritconsuetudinesquaepertinentadvillenagium,etquaepraestanturrationevillenagii,etnonrationepersonae。’ 55。Cf。Blackstone’scharacteristicofcopyholds:’Butitistheveryconditionofthetenureinquestionthatthelandsbeholdenonlysolongasthestipulatedserviceisperformed,quamdiuvelintetpossintfaceredebitumservitiumetsolveredebitaspensiones。’(LawTracts,ii。153。) Bract。Note-book,pl。1103:’EtideoconsideratumestquodWillelmusconuictusestdeuilenagioetsifacereuolueritpredictasconsuetudinesteneatillambouatamterrepereasdemconsuetudines,sinautemfaciatBartholomeusdeterraetdeipsoWillelmouoluntatemsuamutdeuillanosuoeteiliberaturCf。MrMaitland’snote。 58。Ishouldliketodrawattentiontoonemorecasewhichcompletesthepicturefromanotherside。Bract。Notebook,pl。 784:’SymondeT。petitversusAdamdeH。etThomamP。quodfacianteiconsuetudinesetrectaseruiciaqueeifaceredebentdetenementoquoddeeotenentinuillenagioinT。Etipsiueniuntetcognoscuntquoduillanisunt。EtSymonconcediteisquodteneanttenementasuafaciendoindeseruiciaquaepertinentaduillenagium,itatamenquodnondentplusinauxiliumadfestumSt。Mich。necperannumquamduodecimdenariosscilicetquilibetipsorumethocnominetallagii。’——Thewritofcustomsandserviceswasoutofplacebetweenlordandvillain。Theusualcoursewasdistraint。Thecaseisclearlyoneofprivilegedvillainage,butitiswelltonotethatalthoughtheservicesareinonerespectcertain,thepersonsremainunfree。 Bract。Note-book,pl。63:’DicuntquodidemW。nullumhabuitliberumtenementumquiaipseuillanusfuitetfecitomnimodauilenagiaquianonpotuitfiliamsuammaritarenecbouemsuumuendere。1819。R。deM。posuitseinmagnamassisamDom。Reg。IncomitatudeconsuetudinibusetseruiciisqueTh。B。petituersuseum,undeidemTh。exigebatabeodemR。quodreddereteideuillenagioperannum19den。etaruramtriumdierumetmessuramtriumdierum。etgersumamprofiliasuamaritandaetunamgallinamadNataleettotouaadPaschaettallagiumetquodsitprepositussuus。Setquiaillasuntserviliaetaduillenagiumspectanciaetnonadliberumtenementum,consideratumestquodmagnaassisanoniacetintereos,setfiatinquisicioperxii,’ Bract。Note-book,281:’EtPriordicitquodinpartebenerecordantursetinparteparumdicuntquiaiuratoresdixeruntquoddebuitdarexii。denprofiliasuamaritanda,etdebuitpluresaliasconsuetudinesetpetieruntrespectumutassensumhaberepossentadominoRobertodeLexintonautrumhocessetliberumtenementumexquosciuntquiddebuitfacereetquidnonetnullumrespectumhaberepotuerunt。’ 63。Example-Bract。Note-book,pl。1887。Fitzherbert,Abr。Villen。 38(13Ed。I):’QuiapredictusJ。nullamprobacionemproducitnequesectametcognoscitquodilleestinseisina。depatrepredictiW。quempotuitproduxisseadprobacionem,consideratumestquodpredictiW。etR。liberimaneant。’ 64。Bracton,f。199。Thejurycameinonlybyconsentoftheparties。 65。Britton,i。207;Fitzherbert,Abr。Villen。37。 66。CourtRollsofHaveringatteBower,Essex,Augment。Off。 Rolls,xiv。38。(Curia-dieJovisproximaantefestumSt。 BartholomaeiApostoliannor。r。RicardiII,21mo。) ’Inquisicio。dicit。quodnonestaliquishomonatiuusdesanguineingressusfeodumdomini,setdicuntquodestquidamJohannesShillyllgquiSepiusdictusfueratnatiuus。EtdicuntultraquodqnidamJohannesShillyngpaterpredictiJohannisfuitalienigenaetquodpredictusJohannesShillyngquodadeorumcognitionemestliberetliberecondicionisetnonnatiuus。’ Fitzherbert,l。c。:’Eceissufuittriepargentsdepaiisoulemanerestenemiouilnasquistpartoutslesjustices。’ isverygoodonallthesepoints。Howell,StateTrials,xx。38,39。 Bracton,f6,andonmanyotheroccasions。 Co。Lit。137,b。Cf。KingHenryI’swritinfavouroftheMonasteryofAbingdon。Bigelow,PlacitaAnglo-Normannica,96: ’faciashabereF。abbatiomneshominessuosquideterrasuaexieruntpropterherberiamcuriemee。’HenryIIputsittheotherway,p220……’Nisisuntindominiomeo。’ 74。AmostcuriouspleadingbasedontheconceptionsofGlanvilleoccursinaCor。Regecaseof10HenryIII,whichwaspointedouttomebyF。Maitland。SeeApp。IV。MrYorkPowellsuggeststhatthelimitationmayhaveoriginatedinthefact,thatinearlytimesamancouldnomoregiveawayaslavefromhisfamilyestatewithouttheconsentofthefamilythanhecouldgiveawaytheestateitselforpartofit。Therewasnoreasonforsuchlimitationinthecaseofaslavethathadbeenboughtwithone’sprivatemoney。Hencethenecessityofsellingaslaveinordertoemancipatehim。Theconjectureseemsaveryprobableone,butthequestionremains,howsuchancientpracticecouldhaveleftatraceinthefeudalperiod。Theexplanationinthetextmaypossiblyaccountforthetenacityofthenotion。 75。Note-book,pl。31,343。 76。Bracton,f。194,195。Bracton’stexthasbeenrenderedalmostunintelligibleherebythecarelesspunctuationofhiseditors,andSirTraversTwiss’translationisaswrongandmisleadingasusual。IwilljustgivethepassageinaccordancewiththereadingofDigby,222(BodleianLibr。),whichisthebestofalltheMSS。Ihaveseen:’Quiaestoquodseruusuelitmanumittietcumnichilhabeatpropriumeligatfidemalicuiusquieumematquasiprodenariissuis,pertalememptionemnonconsequituremptusaliquamlibertatemnisitantumquodmutatdominum。Inreemptainprimissoluidebetpretium,posteasequiturtraditiorei:soluiturhicpretiumpronatiuo,setnullasubsequiturtraditio,sedsempermanetinuillenagioquoprius。Sitenementumadquirattenendumlibereetheresmanumissorisuelaliussuccessoreumeiciat,sipetatperassisametheresopponatuillenagium,etvillanusreplicetdemanumissioneetemptione,herestriplicarepoterit,quodimperfectafuitemptiosiuemanumissioeoquodnunquaminuitauenditorissubsecutafuittraditio,etitatalissemperremanebitsubpotestateheredis。’ 77。Notebook,pl。1749:’Iudicatumestquodlibersitquantumadheredemmanumittentisetnonquantumadalios,quodiudiciumnonestuerum。’ AncientDemesneTheoldlawbooksmentiononekindofvillainagewhichstandsoutinmarkedcontrastwiththeotherspeciesofserviletenure。 ThepeasantsbelongingtomanorswhichwerevestedinthecrownatthetimeoftheConquestfollowalawoftheirown。Barringcertainexceptions,ofwhichmorewillbesaidpresently,theyenjoyacertaintyofconditionprotectedbylaw。Theyarepersonallyfree,andalthoughholdinginvillainage,nobodyhastherighttodeprivethemoftheirlands,ortoaltertheconditionofthetenure,byincreasingorchangingtheservices。 Bractoncallstheirconditiononeofprivilegedvillainage,becausetheirservicesarebasebutcertain,andbecausetheyareprotectednotbytheusualremediessuppliedatcommonlawtofreetenants,butbypeculiarwritswhichenforcethecustomofthemanor。(1*)Itseemswellworththewhiletocarefullyinvestigatethiscuriouscasewithaviewtogetatthereasonsofanotabledeviationfromthegeneralcourse,forsuchinvestigationmaythrowsomereflectedlightonthetreatmentofvillainageinthecommonlaw。 Legalpracticeisveryexplicitastothelimitationofancientdemesneintimeandspace。ItiscomposedofthemanorswhichbelongedtothecrownatthetimeoftheConquest。(2*)Thisincludesmanorswhichhadbeengivenawaysubsequently,andexcludessuchashadlapsedtothekingaftertheConquestbyescheatorforfeiture。(3*)PossessionsgrantedawaybySaxonkingsbeforetheConquestareequallyexcluded。(4*)InordertoascertainwhatthesemanorswerethecourtsrevertedtotheDomesdaydescriptionofTerraRegis。Asaruletheselandswereenteredascrownlands,T。R。E。andT。R。W。,thatis,wereconsideredtohavebeeninthehandofKingEdwardin1066,andinthehandofKingWilliamin1086。ButstrictlyandlegallytheywerecrownlandsatthemomentwhenKingWilliam’sclaiminured,ortousethecontemporaryphrase,’onthedaywhenKingEdwardwasaliveanddead。’TheimportantpointevidentlywasthattheNormanking’srightinthiscasebridgedovertheConquest,andforthisreasonsuchpossessionsareoftensimplysaidtohavebeenroyaldemesneinthetimeofEdwardtheConfessor。ThislegalviewiswellillustratedbyadecisionoftheKing’sCouncil,quotedbyBelknap,ChiefJusticeoftheCommonPleas,in1375。ItwasheldthatthemanorofTottenham,althoughgrantedbyWilliamtheConquerortotheEarlofChesterbeforethecompilationofDomesday,wasancientdemesne,ashavingbeeninthehandsbothofSt。EdwardandoftheConqueror。(5*)Andso1066andnot1086isthedecisiveyearforthelegalformationofthisclassofmanors。(6*) Inmanyrespectsthepositionofthepeasantryinancientdemesneisnearlyalliedtothatofmenholdinginvillainageatcommonlaw。Theyperformallkindsofagriculturalservicesandaresubjecttodutiesquiteanalogoustothosewhichprevailinotherplaces;wemayfindontheseancientmanorsalmostalltheincidentsofservilecustom。Sometimesveryharshformsofdistressareusedagainstthetenants;(7*)forfeiturefornon-performanceofservicesandnon-paymentsofrentswasalwaysimpending,inmarkedcontrastwiththeconsideratetreatmentoffreetenantryinsuchcases。(8*)Weoftencomeacrosssuchbasecustomsasthepaymentofmerchetinconnexionwiththe’villainsocmen’ofancientdemesne。(9*)Andsuchinstanceswouldaffordampleproofofthefactthattheirstatushasbranchedofffromthesamestemasvillainage,ifsuchproofwereotherwiseneeded。 Thesideofprivilegeisnotlessconspicuous。Theindicationsgivenbythelawbooksmustbelargelysupplementedfromplearollsandcharters。Thespecialfavourshowntothepopulationonsoilofancientdemesneextendsmuchfurtherthanaregulationofmanorialdutieswouldimply,itresolvesitselftoalargeextentintoanexemptionfrompublicburdens。Theking’smanoristreatedasafranchiseisolatedfromthesurroundinghundredandshire,itstenantsarenotboundtoattendthecountycourtorthehundredmoot,(10*)theyarenotassessedwiththerestfordanegeldorcommonamercementsorthemurderfine,(11*)